The United States has changed its method without changing its goal. The CLARITY bill, meant to divide responsibilities between the SEC and the CFTC, stalled on October 15 at 49 votes in favor and 50 against, and with it the legislative route to ordering the crypto market disappeared. Instead, the CFTC published on October 13 in the Federal Register a proposed rule for cryptoasset transactions and markets, and has opened the way to bring event contracts, the basis of Polymarket and Kalshi, within swaps regulation.
The result is a regulatory map built by agency action, not by law. Every rule the CFTC proposes will be exposed to the next administration, to judicial review and to shifts in the congressional majority. For the sector's lawyers, that is worse than an imperfect law: it is an uncertainty that renews itself every four years.
For operators, the October picture offers a useful paradox. The rule that was supposed to clarify who is in charge does not exist, and both agencies have kept publishing rules while Congress was deadlocked. Anyone who waited for the law to move has been standing still for two years.
What does the CFTC propose and why does it matter?
The advance notice of proposed rulemaking published in the Federal Register addresses two blocks. The first defines what a cryptoasset transaction is and how conduct rules apply to the intermediaries that execute them. The second orders the markets where those assets are traded, with registration requirements for platforms that want to operate with US clients.
The proposal is published in the Federal Register of October 13, with its comment period open.
The most relevant move is on event contracts. The CFTC has proposed treating them as swaps, which allows it to regulate platforms such as Polymarket and Kalshi under the same framework it applies to financial derivatives. In doing so, the agency draws a border between prediction market and betting, and that border is what decides whether an operator needs a federal or state license.
The distinction is the key to the whole conflict. If event contracts are swaps, jurisdiction is federal and states cannot ban them. If they are bets, the states are in charge, and several have begun to turn off the tap. The NFL has joined the dispute and backs the states before the Supreme Court.
The failure no one wants to own
CLARITY sank by one vote. The bill sought to assign digital assets to the SEC when they function as securities and to the CFTC when they function as commodities, with a certification process for new networks. The text reached the floor with enough support on paper and fell one short of a tie.
The reactions were more self-interested than sincere. Several industry executives said they saw an opportunity in the failure, arguing that the absence of a law lets those who already comply innovate. Lawyers responded with the obvious objection: without a law, every new product is resolved through costly litigation and through decisions that depend on the judicial district where they are filed.
The most concrete consequence is that the current framework has been built by accumulation of administrative decisions. The CFTC had already moved forward in September and early October with rules for cryptoasset markets and now adds the formal proposal. The SEC, meanwhile, continues to resolve case by case.
What does it mean for prediction markets?
The business of Polymarket and Kalshi has grown on a legal ambiguity that was running out. Kalshi operates as a futures market regulated by the CFTC and Polymarket has operated abroad for years with restricted access from the United States. The new classification gives both a path, with requirements that include market surveillance and limits on manipulation.
The cost falls on smaller competitors and on offshore markets, which will have to choose between registering or leaving the US market. It is the same pattern seen with stablecoins: regulation does not eliminate the sector, it concentrates it.
The law that returns in 2027
Congress has two paths. It can retry CLARITY with changes to the division of responsibilities, or let the agencies build the framework and limit itself to ratifying it later. The first option requires a majority that does not exist today; the second enshrines a model in which the regulator changes with the occupant of the White House.
While that is decided, the CFTC has ahead of it a comment period that usually lasts between 60 and 90 days. That is where the sector will fight its real battle: not over the text of a law that was not passed, but over the technical details of a rule that determines who can operate and with what capital.