The United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has granted a temporary five-year exemption to the crypto industry to facilitate the trading of tokenized US shares on blockchain. The move comes after Congress failed to pass the CLARITY Act. SEC Chairman Paul Atkinsexplicitly linked both events when presenting the measure yesterday, September 17.
Innovation Exemption
The so-called Innovation Exemption will allow certain trading venues, called Tokenized Securities Venues (TSV), to trade tokenized shares from the US market without being subject to all the obligations that apply to a traditional exchange. The SEC also grants a specific exemption to certain liquidity providers so that they are not considered dealers under the Exchange Act.
The measure opens a regulatory path to experiment with blockchain-native infrastructure within the US securities market. TSVs will be able to use mechanisms such as automated market makers (AMM) and authorized liquidity pools, bringing into regulated markets some of the technologies developed in recent years around decentralized finance.
The failure of CLARITY pushes the US crypto industry toward piecemeal regulation
However, the SEC sets important limits. Tokenized shares must represent real shares and give their owners the same rights and privileges as traditional securities, including dividends and voting rights. Issuers will also have the option to prevent their shares from being traded on one of these tokenized markets. Federal anti-fraud and anti-manipulation rules will continue to apply in full.
Five years to turn the experiment into a market
The length of the exemption also introduces a political dimension to the decision. The five-year period takes the experiment roughly to 2031. The legislative elections of November 2026 will not automatically alter the exemption even if control of Congress changes, because the SEC approved the measure under the powers granted to it by current legislation.
The next major inflection point will come with the presidential elections of November 2028 and the inauguration of a new Administration in January 2029. A political change would not automatically repeal the exemption either. However, a future SEC with different priorities could try to modify or replace the regime through the corresponding procedures.
That gives the industry a little more than two years, until the next presidential change, to demonstrate how far the tokenization of US markets can go. A future SEC could find itself in 2029 facing either a small regulatory experiment or an infrastructure used by platforms, financial institutions, liquidity providers and investors to trade US shares directly on blockchain.
Wall Street's blockchain laboratory at the SEC
In both cases the rules could be modified. But the economic and operational cost of reversing the second scenario would be very different. Atkins is aware of that vulnerability and, before the failure of CLARITY, argued that legislation from Congress was essential to provide lasting rules and prevent the regulatory work carried out by the current SEC from being undone by future regulators.
The five years will also allow the SEC to observe what happens when tokenized shares leave pilot projects and begin trading in real markets. TSVs will have to provide information on prices, trading volume, transactions and liquidity pools. That data will allow the regulator to assess the behavior of this new infrastructure and decide which elements should later be incorporated into permanent regulation.
The SEC insists precisely that it does not intend to turn current technology into the definitive standard. Atkins defines the exemption as a bridge toward lasting regulation. That is, allowing the market to evolve first, observing how it works and then using that experience to design the definitive rules.
Commissioner Hester Peirce has gone a little further and has indicated that the intention is to allow participants to experiment and be prepared for a future in which trading tokenized shares directly on blockchain could become commonplace.
UBER Model
According to commissioner Mark Uyeda, there is a precedent in the SEC's history. In defending the measure, Uyeda recalled that products now fully integrated into financial markets, such as money market funds, index funds and ETFs, also benefited in their early stages from exemption powers used by the regulator.
Atkins' decision coincides to some extent with the proposal by Stani Kulechov, founder and CEO of Aave, who put forward a similar strategy for the development of decentralized finance after the failure of CLARITY. Stani's argument is that DeFi should focus on building useful products and gaining millions of users instead of relying exclusively on Washington first passing a legislative framework. Uber managed to transform urban transport while regulators were still trying to decide how its model should fit legally.
If in 2029 tokenized shares remain a marginal experiment, Washington will continue debating an emerging technology. But if by then there is liquidity, institutional investment, infrastructure and significant economic activity around these markets, the debate will be different.