Latest

Sociological Analysis

The threat of quantum computing to Bitcoin's governance model

Quantum computing threatens not only Bitcoin's cryptography, but its greatest pillar: the network's governance model.

The threat of quantum computing to Bitcoin's governance model
The threat of quantum computing to Bitcoin's governance model

A few weeks ago, Coinbase announced the first result of its panel of expert cryptographers. The company led by Brian Armstrong formally created an independent council of experts on quantum computing and blockchain. It gave it a name: Coinbase Independent Advisory Board on Quantum Computing and Blockchain.

Its first document appeared a couple of months ago and answered a question: to what extent the security of crypto was threatened by quantum computing. As always when threats are sought, some figures emerge as more vulnerable than others; in this case, the so-called bitcoin accounts were given the dubious honor of representing that place of entities in danger. Even though what is surely most threatened is Bitcoin's own governance model.

Quantum computing and Bitcoin's governance

When only a handful of experts know what quantum is, what is striking is that, for laypeople, it is presented as one more threat to add to the already bulging portfolio of sources of uncertainty and threat. It seems everything comes with risk, even when it is technically and civilizationally an advance, and every morning we wake up to one more risk. The profound risk of reason is beginning to be seeing everything almost exclusively from the perspective of risk. Especially a Western reason that over the centuries grew strong from the conception of risk, which brought the Protestant Reformation under its doctrinal arm.

Bitcoin has until 2029 to adapt to the quantum era, according to Google

Quantum refers to the smallest scales of matter and energy. To those atomic and subatomic entities with a behavior radically different from the everyday physics we see and touch every day. Microscopic entities - in fact, less than microscopic - that, depending on how they are used, can come to change social, economic, political and geopolitical structures, as well as ideological macrostructures. They can also come to change Blockchain's great treasure: its security.

The quantum computing model takes advantage of some of the properties of quantum mechanics. Something that makes it possible to solve complex problems at a speed unattainable for current or binary computing computers. Well then, bearing in mind that one of the principles of Blockchain technology is cryptography - translatable as complex problems - based on binary computing, seeing how binary computing can be affected seems a relevant reflection.

Worrying unconcernedly

Experts of the stature of Justin Drake, Sreeram Kannan, Scott Aaronson, Dan Boneh, Yehuda Lindell or Dahlia Malkhi reviewed the degree of preparedness of networks such as Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana, Algorand, Aptos and others against quantum computing. The result of their work: we can worry unconcernedly or be unconcernedly concerned. That is, they worked to tell us that the ecosystem was not in any danger at present. But that we must worry for the future. A future that is accelerating faster than was thought.

The main source of unconcern: the cryptography used by the main blockchains is secure today. The quantum computer capable of erasing the security barriers of the various blockchains and thus stealing millions of coins does not exist. The concern: on the one hand, that at some point quantum computers capable of breaking certain current cryptographic schemes will be built and, on the other hand, that the migration to quantum-resistant cryptography will take years. Because of the latter, they recommend acting now, in the present, so as not to do it too late. A recommendation to overcome situations like the one described by sociologist Anthony Giddens regarding climate change: since we don't see it, we don't act; when we see it, it will be too late to act.

Asset ownership on Bitcoin

Despite the message wrapped in unconcern, risks are pointed out. Some closer than others. One of the closest lies in the digital signature systems that prove asset ownership on Bitcoin. Neither the ledger itself nor the rule that new bitcoins can be created through mining is in danger. Therefore, blocks would continue to be produced and the blockchain would continue to be produced.

The ownership of some assets would not survive. These are fundamentally coins that no one moves. The advice is clear: Bitcoin must prepare for quantum attacks. It is estimated that a quantum computer could drain between 1.7 and 6.9 million BTC, including Satoshi's. These are bitcoins found in wallets with visible public keys. A threat that has been known in academic circles since 2017, but which has been highlighted in the report.

The quantum threat mainly affects the ECDSA/Schnorr digital signatures that prove ownership of an address. A sufficiently powerful quantum computer could use Shor's algorithm to derive a private key from a known public key.

Public key has been visible since day one

It should be stressed that the first bitcoins were frequently stored in P2PK outputs (Pay-to-Public-Key), where the public key is visible from day one. Hence Satoshi's bitcoins may be included. If you have access to your keys, you can transfer your BTC to a more resistant cryptographic scheme when the technology is available. Lost or abandoned coins cannot do so.

Therefore, in the case of abandoned accounts, the quantum computer would have all the time in the world - including quantum time - to decrypt them. What to do with them? Should Bitcoin let those vulnerable coins be stolen by whoever has the quantum computer? Should it act with some operation that would lead to freezing them? Work to establish some special recovery mechanism? Recovery, toward what? This means touching something that, by definition of the principles of Bitcoin philosophy, is untouchable.

What higher reason can lead to transgressing one of the fundamental crypto reasons? One of these reasons could be as simple as preventing someone from taking what is not theirs. Another, added to this one, but with the added value of reason of state, is preventing a country on the dictatorship blacklist from taking advantage of those millions of cryptocurrencies. Will cryptographic reason, which it must be remembered originally feeds on anarchist ideological frameworks, be subordinated to reason of state?

A network built to resist coordinated changes

It is in preparing for such a threat that Bitcoin's blockchain may encounter important dilemmas. Bitcoin is a network built to resist coordinated changes. But: can it coordinate the largest security upgrade in its history before quantum hardware can act? Bitcoin does not have, like Ethereum, a foundation that funds engineering work and a governance process that regularly approves major upgrades.

More than the amount of money itself, which is enormous, perhaps what is most at stake is the symbolic capital of the bitcoin network. Part of its philosophy is at stake. If, in order to protect them, those threatened assets are touched. Some even describe it as confiscation, creating a "dangerous" precedent.

Javier Callejo

Author

Javier Callejo

Professor of Sociology at the National University of Distance Education (UNED). Degrees in Journalism and Law

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading