Finfluencer is a term resulting from the contraction of finance and influencer: a content creator who talks about personal finance, saving, investment, the stock market or, also, cryptocurrencies. They address such matters in a simple way, with barely any technical language or with only the minimum needed to present themselves as experts. And, above all, they give advice. The recommendation takes precedence over the description and, above all, over the analysis. At most, a somewhat fake analysis because of the rhetorical demand for simplification, which, on the other hand, does not particularly interest their potential audiences either.
In that effort to simplify the complex, as the financial system and its constant flows are, the work of good finfluencers must be acknowledged. Those who make relatively difficult concepts easy for a lay audience. They set aside their expert suit and provide financial education to laypeople. The problem arises with those who have not set aside any expert suit because they have never had one. An expert suit is made of knowledge, experience, independence of judgment, professional ethics and responsibility.
The most promising finfluencers
The CNMV is very concerned about the most promising finfluencers. On 25 May it published a guide for finfluencers to act responsibly, devoting a chapter to cryptoassets. More recently, on 22 October it gave a greater show of its concern by organizing an event at the Matadero, in Madrid, entitled Finfluencers: Beyond the ‘like’. The very fact of assuming that there is something beyond the ‘like’ in our societies means positioning oneself within a particular cultural and ideological framework.
Promising finfluencers because they go as far as making promises of profit to anyone willing to heed their advice. The Spanish financial watchdog institution must be concerned about those who, from their positions on the web - podcasts, blogs or Telegram, Instagram, Tik Tok, X or YouTube - promise their thousands of followers that they will become millionaires if they follow their advice. Those who individually invite their followers to meetings in private spaces, where they are advised which financial education course to take or what to do with their wealth, after paying for the “advice”, are a particular cause for concern.
From tweet to conversation: this is Dessa, Jack Dorsey's AI that listens while you speak
Beyond whether their general views on the state of the economy and finance are well-founded, or whether their specific public diagnoses about businesses or companies are accurate, we are talking about the finfluencers who charge for offering self-interested recommendations. Their judgment, far from being independent, is incentivized by collecting commissions for bringing in clients. In some cases, personalized recommendations. And it must be acknowledged, in the field of cryptocurrency investment they remain very present. Even though it is also true that to a lesser extent than a few years ago. A practice that, on the other hand, is a lever for scams. In fact, it must be said that the very recommendation to invest in a specific asset, with a name and surname, already smells quite strongly of fraud.
They do not contemplate uncertainty
It smells of fraud because, first of all, it means assuming, before someone who anxiously lives the future of their finances, a knowledge one does not have. It is the knowledge of the future. Promising the future is, perhaps today more than ever, a fraud. That is why today's good professionals of the future disappoint us a little. Perhaps we seek certainties in them and they give us back uncertainties, risks. At most, probabilities of the future based on how the present has worked. And always with conditions: if everything stays the same, if nothing strange happens. But we know that the accident is normal, as the sociologist Charles Perrow tells us. But finfluencers do not contemplate uncertainty or the accident in their personalized and self-interested recommendation. They push the investor. The accident is themselves.
In a recently published book, Prophecy, Carissa Véliz tells us how the prediction industry has been configured. How businesses and the economy require frameworks of the future to function; but, also, how the production of that symbolic raw material that is the future is something that is manufactured, is a business, that sometimes crosses ethical and moral lines. It is a great industry, with large companies involved, media of all kinds, the most talented professionals involved and the most open imaginations at its service. But, also, with significant gaps.
As the author literally says, our anxiety about tomorrow makes us vulnerable to charlatans, sibylline techniques of deception and disappointments. And that is because we desperately seek the future. In particular, the future of our wealth. And it is through the gap of desperation that parasitic entities slip in. Well then, it is in the prediction industry that parasitic finfluencers have slipped in.
In her book, Véliz presents us with a synthetic universal history of prediction, especially focused on Greece and Rome. A history from which it can be derived as one of the general principles, that the good and most relevant elements of the prediction industry were linked to responsibility for what is recommended to be done with a view to the future. Even a responsibility linked to life, as was the case with the advisers of despots. But what finfluencers do is another matter. Their particular advice carries no responsibility whatsoever.