When it comes to money, the layers of security required are multiple. The trust we need to make an investment or deposit decision is built from very different materials. Technological security is essential, but it is only one of the nodes in that constellation.
The first dimension is, precisely, technology security. Its role is to ensure that the money deposited in an exchange or wallet stays where it is and that no one can access it without authorization. It is, in short, the security of custody: the promise of a box that is inaccessible to third parties.
Money and hacks
We demand that the entity providing us with that box take its custody role to the highest possible level of protection. This is not a new concern. Custody technology has been, along with military technology, one of the great drivers of innovation throughout history. Since the earliest human communities, safeguarding and protecting assets has been a fundamental need, to which some of the greatest efforts of human ingenuity have been devoted.
Binance's haul: 3.110 billion that the market does not move
Even when we talk about digital assets and cryptoassets, we still picture security in a very physical way: some coins, a box and a key. As if we still needed a safe and a private key to sleep soundly. Yet the technological logic of the deposit changed radically some time ago. Digital custody works through mechanisms that have little to do with that traditional image, just as the logic of a sewing machine has little to do with the seamstress's movements. Our imagination, however, still demands safes and well-protected keys.
The news about the latest hacks in the crypto industry hardly help anyone sleep easy. We keep waiting for someone to announce the launch of the great technically inviolable safe. Though perhaps that safe will never exist in absolute terms.
Money is always active
But there are other sources of security. One of the most important is legal certainty. It is the kind that, backed by the force of law and by the action of public authorities, allows us to operate within known rules of the game. It also allows us to use our money with a minimum of guarantees.
And here it is worth recalling a particular feature of money: even when it remains still, it is still in use. Money is always active, it is essentially active. Like cryptoassets, as their name suggests. Depositing it, holding it in custody or leaving it available for a future transaction are also ways of using it. Its mere availability has an economic function. Its "being there", to borrow a philosophical expression, is already part of its usefulness. Hence the importance of regulation.
At the European level, progress has been made with initiatives such as MiCA, the Regulation on Markets in Cryptoassets. The institutional recognition of cryptoassets and the establishment of common rules represent a significant step. However, the regulation is also aimed at preserving the stability and integrity of the European financial system. It does not, by itself, amount to establishing comprehensive protection for the holder of cryptoassets, for users.
Transaction fees
In particular, in certain cases of theft or loss due to cyberattacks, the owner may face significant limitations on recovery and compensation guarantees. The existence of a regulatory framework does not therefore mean that all risks are covered or that protection equivalent to that of other financial instruments exists.
A third dimension is the commercial securityIts role is to give us the assurance that we will not be deceived in the transactions we carry out with our cryptoassets. This is not about preventing someone from stealing our money, a matter that falls under custody security, but about ensuring that the economic terms of our relationship with the entity are reasonable and transparent.
We are talking, for example, about transaction fees, the prices applied to trades or the costs associated with custody. We are talking, in short, about commercial fairness. But a fairness conditioned by competition and by technological development itself. What we consider a fair price will depend both on the alternatives offered by the different market participants and on the costs involved in developing and maintaining custody and transaction tools.
Then there is market security. This no longer depends on a single agent in the crypto industry, but on the sector as a whole, on its evolution, growth and institutionalization. It consists of having confidence that there is a sufficiently broad market, with demand and activity, in which cryptoassets can find buyers and sellers.
Collective security
This collective security gives rise to another particularly important one: liquidity security. Liquidity is one of the essential characteristics of money. The more developed the cryptoasset market is, the greater, in principle, the chances of finding a counterparty when we want to sell. Market depth and the existence of sufficient demand thus contribute to confidence in the ability to convert those assets into available money. However, market growth does not eliminate volatility risks nor does it by itself guarantee the liquidity of each asset.
We must not forget strategic security. When we speak of money as a store of value and as an instrument for projecting our investment decisions into the future, we need to trust that what we hold today will retain some economic recognition tomorrow. It is not enough for an asset to be technically protected in the present: we also need some reasonable expectation about its future value. Strategic security therefore has to do with the continuity, acceptance and survival capacity of the asset over time. It is not enough to protect today's money; we must also trust in the value and usefulness of tomorrow's money.
There are, moreover, other forms of security, such as corporate securityThrough it, the brand of the entity in which we deposit our cryptoassets conveys additional protection: backing, solvency, responsiveness or special guarantees. It is the security provided by a reputation built up over time.
Peace of mind
In fact, this is one of the entry points for traditional financial institutions into the cryptoassets industry. Banks and other established institutions bring more to the sector than technology or services: they bring the value of a recognizable brand, a track record and an image of solidity that can reinforce customer trust. Naturally, reputation does not replace effective guarantees, but it is a relevant factor in the perception of security.
Of course, there is also the moral security. It is the one that gives us the peace of mind of knowing that the way entities use our money matches our own principles and ethical standards. We do not only want our money to be protected and available; we also want to know that its management does not contradict what we believe in.
And so we come to the most important security of all: internal security. It is the one that results from the convergence of all the others. The one that lets us be at ease, convinced of our decision and confident that we have properly assessed the risks. It does not depend on a single mechanism or a single institution. It arises from the balance between the different dimensions of security and from the trust we are able to place in them.
In short, technological security can withstand a hack, legal security can protect us against certain abuses, commercial security can prevent us from being deceived and corporate security can offer us backing. But none of them, on its own, guarantees trust.
A constellation
True security is a constellation. And its fullest expression is the inner peace of mind of those who know where they place their money, who holds it in custody, under what rules it operates and what they can expect from it in the future.
That is, probably, the hardest security to hack. However, beyond the material content obtained by the hackers, what they steal from us is the feeling of security. They produce a hole in the constellation of securities, affecting all its nodes.