Latest

Cybersecurity

Why didn't Google publish part of its quantum research?

Justin Drake questions the partial disclosure of Google quantum research and its implications for Bitcoin and Ethereum.

Why didn't Google publish part of its quantum research?
Why didn't Google publish part of its quantum research?

Justin Drake, a researcher at the Ethereum Foundation, has reopened the debate on transparency in quantum research by commenting on a paper from Google Quantum AI on Shor's algorithm. That algorithm could in the future allow quantum computers to break some of the cryptographic systems most widely used today.

Drake refers to a paper presented on March 31 by researchers at Google Quantum AI, which described significant improvements in the efficiency of Shor's algorithm applied to elliptic curve cryptography. As a practical example, the paper analyzed the secp256k1 curve, used in Bitcoin and Ethereum digital signatures.

According to Drake, who is listed as a co-author of the study, the breakthrough meant a significant reduction in the quantum resources needed to carry out this type of theoretical attack. However, what draws his attention most is the way it was communicated.

A critique of the disclosure of the results

Drake argues that some optimizations developed during the research were not published in detail. Instead, the authors used a zero-knowledge proof (ZKP) to demonstrate the existence of certain improvements without fully revealing how they work.

The researcher describes this situation as an unusual case within academia, where results are traditionally published openly to allow review and reproduction by other scientists. However, Drake avoids assigning direct responsibility to the Google researchers. In fact, he expressly stresses that the team acted with a high level of professionalism and states that it deserves recognition for the quality of the work carried out.

Ethereum and Solana more vulnerable than Bitcoin to a quantum attack, according to Citi

His criticism focuses on the decision not to disclose all the technical details from the outset, a circumstance that, he explains, was related to a broader context he cannot describe publicly.

Independent paths

The controversy took on a new dimension when the French researcher André Schrottenloher later published a paper in which he independently rediscovered one of the optimizations that had not been publicly described in the original study.

For Drake, this episode illustrates what is known as the Streisand effect: attempts to limit the spread of certain information can end up generating even more interest and accelerating its discovery by third parties. The researcher also highlights that the scientific community has begun to collaborate actively in the search for new optimizations through open initiatives such as ecdsa.fail, where researchers and enthusiasts work on improving the quantum circuits related to Shor's algorithm.

The debate over "Q-Day"

Beyond the discussion on scientific disclosure, Drake's main concern is the development timeline for quantum computing. The researcher believes that recent advances in quantum algorithms and hardware could be shortening the time needed for machines capable of compromising cryptographic systems currently deployed in production to appear.

In his post, Drake notes that neither Google nor other companies working in this field usually link their technical advances to specific estimates about the arrival of the so-called "Q-Day," a term used to describe the moment when a sufficiently powerful quantum computer can break cryptography used in the real world.

Although he acknowledges that these forecasts are highly speculative, Drake states that, in light of recent progress, he considers it plausible that this scenario will arrive sooner than many organizations currently expect.

Ethereum works on the post-quantum transition

The reflection concludes with a call to accelerate research into cryptography resistant to quantum computers. Drake explains that part of his work within Ethereum focuses precisely on studying how to gradually replace some of the current cryptographic mechanisms with alternatives designed to withstand quantum attacks.

In his view, the industry still has time to prepare for that transition, but recent advances suggest that the debate should no longer focus solely on whether the quantum threat will arrive someday, but on how to prepare for it in an orderly and secure way.

Catalina Elidafamo

Author

Catalina Elidafamo

Journalist dedicated to covering the impact of innovation on markets and society, exploring everything from the potential of tokenization to the ethical dilemmas of AI.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading