Latest

Crypto

Mercado Bitcoin buys back assets and leaves 33 million outstanding

The Brazilian platform is carrying out a buyback plan with its own money while around 33 million remains in the attacker's hands. The website returns on November 9.

Mercado Bitcoin buys back assets and leaves 33 million outstanding
Mercado Bitcoin buys back assets and leaves 33 million outstanding

Mercado Bitcoin has begun buying back cryptocurrencies with its own money to replace the assets that left its wallets on November 2. Its Vice President of Crypto Business, Fabrício Tota, said so in a video published on November 6, and the figure that accompanies the explanation is the one that frames everything: around 33 million dollars remain in the attacker's hands, about 3% of the assets the platform holds in custody.

The operation is not a bailout or a negotiation. It is a trading desk buying the same assets on the market, with partners in Brazil and abroad, so that customers recover their balance without waiting for the investigation to return anything. The company bears the cost, and that decision is the most relevant part of the week for anyone with funds on an exchange, because it marks where the sector draws the line between custody risk and the custodian's responsibility.

The timetable was also set. The website returns on Monday, November 9, in read-only mode, with balances and history from before the incident. Trading, deposits and withdrawals will come later, by groups of cryptoassets and by networks, with no single date for everyone.

What is known about the missing money?

The figure for the haul has moved three times in five days. The first public estimate spoke of 36.3 million; Bitquery's tracing raised it to 48.6 million spread across ten chains; Brazilian coverage of the buyback plan mentions 49.2 million. The differences are not an arithmetic error: each measurement uses a different price snapshot and a different set of addresses.

Of the total amount, the platform has said it blocked more than 16 million with help from Tether, Circle and Chainalysis. The rest is split between what the attacker moved and what remains in identified but unblocked addresses. The reconstruction of the draining details how the move was made from operational wallets to customer deposit addresses.

The part that does not quite add up is the pace. The on-chain analysis showed funds leaving deposit addresses for about four hours after the company announced that the incident was contained. That gap could be explained by automated loads already in the queue, but no one has clarified it publicly yet.

There is one detail that helps gauge the scale of the problem. On Ethereum, 36,042 addresses were drained with a combined balance of around 266,000 dollars, that is, an average of seven dollars per address. The attacker did not pick the large wallets: it went through the entire deposit system, and that leaves a question about how many authorization points existed.

Buying back instead of waiting

An exchange can respond to a theft in three ways: wait for the investigation to recover funds, freeze operations until it has an expert report, or replace the assets with its own resources and argue later about who pays. Mercado Bitcoin chose the third, and with that it shifts the customer's financial problem onto its balance sheet.

The buyback has a practical advantage over waiting. Stolen assets take months to recover, and every month of waiting is a month of customers without access and of reputation falling. Buying on the market restores the balance on sight and leaves the pursuit of the haul as a separate matter, which is exactly what a user needs.

It also has a cost that is not visible. The desk buys with local and international partners, and that volume moves the price of the very asset it is replacing. In a market as battered as this week's, with bitcoin losing 76,000 dollars, the market drop makes replacing cheaper for the company and more painful for anyone who sold at the low.

The third option, freezing until there is certainty, is the one small exchanges choose because they do not have the balance sheet for anything else. The difference between choosing one or the other is not one of strategy: it is one of size and of access to liquidity over a weekend.

The timetable ahead

On November 9 the platform reopens balance and transaction history queries. It is a small step and it means a lot: for a week, thousands of customers have not been able to see whether their position was still there, and the first proof that the replacement works is that the number that appears matches the one from before the attack.

Then comes the complicated part. The release of trading, deposits and withdrawals will be done by groups of cryptoassets and by blockchain networks, according to Tota himself, and there is no date for the end. It is the same pattern the large exchanges apply: validating the signing engine against each network before opening the door.

That order has an explanation the statement does not give. The networks with the most volume and the most accumulated testing are the first to return, and those with their own bridges or different transaction formats wait. For the customer with an uncommon token, the reopening may come weeks after the November 9 snapshot.

For the customer there are three useful checks at that reopening. The first is to capture the balance and history as soon as access is possible. The second is not to move funds in the first hours, when queues and fees spike. The third is to check whether the account has pending verifications that could block a future withdrawal.

What this case leaves the sector

The Mercado Bitcoin story is the manageable version of the problem Binance faces with 6.430 billion. A platform that replaces assets with its own money sends a clear signal to the market: the custodian assumes custody risk, not the customer. That signal is worth more than any communications campaign and can be measured in the coming week.

It also leaves an uncomfortable lesson about insurance. The freezing of 2.600 billion by Circle and Tether showed that issuers can act fast when they want to, and that they only reach their own tokens. For the rest of the balance sheet, the exchange is on its own.

That division of responsibilities explains why the buyback is executed with partners and not with an accounting injection. Buying on the market returns an asset with a real price to the balance sheet, whereas a promise of future payment would have left the platform with the same debt and no collateral. In a sector where trust is measured in withdrawals, the difference between the two is what decides whether the customer comes back.

There remains the question no buyback resolves. If an attacker goes through deposit addresses one by one over days, the failure is not only technical: it is one of operational design, because the system allowed movements to be authorized from too many points. Replacing the balance covers the visible hole and leaves the other in view of anyone who wants to look.

On November 9 customers will see their numbers and will be able to check whether the replacement matches what they had. The real test will come days later, when someone tries to withdraw and finds out whether the platform is rebuilt or merely made up for the photo, and that gesture is worth more than any press release.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading