A person, identified under the pseudonym Noah Doe, together with two companies domiciled in Wyoming, has filed a lawsuit before the Supreme Court of the State of New York to claim ownership of 39,069 Bitcoin wallets that have remained inactive for at least six years.
Forgotten bitcoins and quantum computing
The lawsuit introduces the development of quantum computing as a technical variable that could gain strength in the future. Although Bitcoin's current architecture makes it impracticable to enforce a court ruling without the private keys, future advances in quantum technology could compromise the cryptographic security standards in force. In that scenario, a favorable ruling for the plaintiffs would cease to be a mere symbolic recognition and would grant them the legal standing to access these historical assets.
The lawsuit, filed on May 1, 2026 under case number 153119/2026, was brought by the New York law firm Lewis & Lin LLC on behalf of Noah Doe and the companies ABC Company and XYZ Company. The 901-page court document argues that the wallets constitute abandoned property under Article 7-B of the New York State Personal Property Law.
The plaintiffs ask the court for a ruling recognizing them as the legitimate owners of the funds associated with those Bitcoin addresses, many of which have recorded no movements since the early years of the network created by Satoshi Nakamoto.
An algorithm to track dormant wallets
According to the documentation submitted to the court, Noah Doe would have developed an algorithm capable of identifying tens of thousands of potentially abandoned addresses between late 2024 and April 2025. In a first analysis it detected more than 42,000 wallets, although 2,932 were subsequently discarded, finally leaving the 39,069 that are part of the legal dispute.
Spain leads the institutionalization of digital assets in Europe
The plaintiffs claim to have followed the procedure required by US law on "found property" before filing the lawsuit. As they explain in the court documents, they formally notified the New York Police Department (NYPD) of the find and made public communications on the blockchain through OP_RETURN transactions to alert possible owners of the wallets.
In addition, they carried out an advertising campaign and created a website to facilitate possible claims on the funds. After these actions, they claim to have waited the legal period of 90 days without any legitimate owner coming forward or claiming the bitcoins.
The core of the lawsuit's legal argument holds that the prolonged inactivity of these wallets, together with the total absence of public response, would make it possible to consider the associated bitcoins as abandoned assets under New York State law
Up to $290 billion in Bitcoin
According to independent estimates cited in judicial circles, the wallets could contain between 3.7 and 3.79 million bitcoins, a figure that makes the case one of the most extraordinary in the history of the crypto ecosystem.
At current prices, the value of those funds would range between $285 billion and $290 billion, a figure comparable to the GDP of some mid-sized countries. Among the addresses included in the lawsuit would be historical wallets associated with the early years of bitcoin, some allegedly linked to Satoshi Nakamoto, mining pioneers and funds related to the collapse and hack of the exchange Mt. Gox.
The private keys
Despite the enormous media impact of the case, numerous experts question the practical viability of the claim. The main obstacle is that in Bitcoin, actual possession of the funds depends exclusively on control of the private keys. In fact, David Schwartz, one of the most recognized voices in the sector, has publicly questioned the usefulness of an eventual favorable ruling. Even if the court recognized the plaintiffs' legal ownership, that would not automatically give them access to the bitcoins.
Without the corresponding private keys, the funds would remain immobile within the Bitcoin network. The protocol's decentralized architecture does not recognize court judgments as a valid mechanism for transferring self-custodied assets. The case thus reopens the debate on the difference between legal ownership and cryptographic control.
A precedent for the future of Bitcoin
The lawsuit could become a historic precedent on the fate of millions of lost or inactive bitcoins that exist on the network. Various studies estimate that between 3 and 4 million BTC could be permanently inaccessible due to forgotten keys, destroyed hard drives or the death of their owners.
Until now, inaccessible funds remain locked forever, which reduces the circulating supply. However, the legal offensive introduces the possibility that civil courts may attempt to reinterpret those funds as abandoned property eligible for claim.
The New York Supreme Court has not yet set a date for the first hearing. Meanwhile, the case has already opened an intense legal, technological and philosophical debate on the boundaries between traditional law and the cryptographic sovereignty that defines Bitcoin. To this is added the potential impact of quantum computing. Although today it is practically impossible to access these funds without the private keys, future advances in quantum cryptography could alter the security foundations on which Bitcoin is built and reopen the discussion on effective control of millions of lost or inactive bitcoins.




