Latest

Bitcoin

Chinese fork in Bitcoin: A former PBOC official launches Bitcoin Purity

Bitcoin Purity, the fork by the former Chinese banker that wants to be Bitcoin: it rescues BIP-110 without altering mining or preventing replay

Bitcoin Purity, the fork by the former Chinese banker that wants to be Bitcoin
Bitcoin Purity, the fork by the former Chinese banker that wants to be Bitcoin

We have a new Bitcoin fork, this time called Bitcoin Purity, which began writing its history at block 961,637, barely a week after the BIP-110 soft fork attempt split in two.

Its promoter is Hong Shuning, a Tsinghua engineer and former official at the People's Bank of China (PBOC) for twenty years, who presents himself on X as "Nakamotwo Satoshi (BIP110)".

But unlike Luke Dashjr's bet, which seeks a hard fork that would change the mining algorithm to Blake2b this September 1, Purity keeps SHA256d, preserves BIP-110 permanently and, above all, claims the identity of Bitcoin: it does not intend to create a new token, but to be the "real Bitcoin". It is the most ambiguous maneuver in the saga and, for many, the most dangerous, especially because most of the code is created using the AI of Cursor.

The BIP-110 saga: two blocks and an ideological war

To understand Purity, one must go back to the events of early August. The BIP-110 fork, the "Reduced Data Temporary Softfork" drafted by the pseudonymous Dathon Ohm with Dashjr's blessing, sought to impose seven consensus rules to limit arbitrary data on the chain: non-OP_RETURN outputs limited to 34 bytes, OP_RETURN to 83, data pushes to 256, restrictions on Taproot and a ban on OP_IF/OP_NOTIF in Tapscript. The stated goal was to curb Ordinals, BRC-20 and Runes; the practical effect, to invalidate transactions that pay fees and that today are perfectly valid.

The problem was support. BIP-110 needed 55% miner signaling, a threshold already low compared with the historical 95% of SegWit, but it never exceeded 2.53% (51 of 2,016 blocks, almost all from Ocean, the pool co-founded by Dashjr).

Three blockchain uses that already work in the public sector

The BIP-110 fiasco

Thus, when the mandatory signaling window opened on August 8 at block 961,632, the nodes running the rules rejected the majority's blocks and the network split. The minority branch mined between two and four blocks and stopped. Within eight hours, the mainnet was already 48 blocks ahead. Because of all this, Dashjr was removed as BIP editor in Bitcoin Core, and his departure from Ocean was announced, whose hashrate fell 96.5%, from about 36 EH/s to 1.25 EH/s.

Dashjr's response was radical: change the proof of work and move even further away from Bitcoin Core. On August 11 and 12 he announced that the minority branch would hard fork to BLAKE2b, a CPU/GPU-friendly algorithm that makes SHA-256 ASICs obsolete, with a target date of September 1.

The choice of algorithm was, literally, by lottery: Dashjr intended to determine it with the last hexadecimal character of the hash of a Testnet4 block, a process he had to restart after admitting that "trolls" tried to manipulate it. In parallel, Dashjr calls the mainnet "Spamcoin" and "Bpedo", insists that his branch is the real Bitcoin and has shifted onto the dominant chain the responsibility for replay protection ("Replay protection was Spamcoin's responsibility," he said on August 18), all despite the fact that it was his group that started it all, and it was therefore his responsibility.

What is Bitcoin Purity? The same dream, another strategy

This is where Purity comes in. On August 16, the repository saltduck/bitcoinpurity became public, a fork of Bitcoin Knots, Luke Dashjr's node software. Three days later, the mainnet launch was made public. The proposal is an uncomfortable hybrid: it preserves the ideological backbone of BIP-110, but distances itself from Dashjr's path, keeping SHA256d as the mining algorithm.

Technically, Purity does four things. First, it turns the BIP-110/RDTS rules into permanent consensus. From block 961,637 they do not expire, cannot be disabled with startup parameters and do not depend on signaling. The philosophy is summed up in its motto: "Policy can change. Consensus endures". This is much harsher than Dashjr's original rules for BIP-110.

Second, it keeps SHA256d, explicitly rejecting the change of mining algorithm. Its official website reads: "do not destroy the capital that secures Bitcoin to save Bitcoin". This is a clear allusion to the fact that changing the consensus algorithm is sheer madness and will only end up destroying the ecosystem that forms on the new fork.

Destroying Bitcoin's economic legacy

Third, it replaces the difficulty adjustment with the use of ASERT with a 24-hour half-life, something it borrows from Bitcoin Cash, anchored to block 961,632 of the enforcement chain. Basically, the difficulty adjustment that was always active in Bitcoin since Satoshi's time is not honored in Bitcoin Purity; now the chain is analyzed every 24 hours and difficulty is adjusted according to the historical block generation level. Something that breaks Bitcoin's economic dynamics and that Satoshi clearly laid out in his whitepaper.

Fourth, it introduces "parking" of deep reorgs. That is, if a block would rewrite more than six blocks of history, it is parked pending human review. This is perhaps the worst of all the things Purity is capable of doing.

Basically, if this happens, node operators must manually decide whether or not to accept that reorganization, which shifts consensus from the mathematics of the network to human governance. This breaks Nakamoto's Heaviest Chain Rule and opens the door to network fragmentation (netsplit) or to social centralization if operators blindly follow the guidelines of a dominant figure or client. This destroys the network's decentralization, it does not protect it.

Luis Garicano to lead the group created by Draghi and the CEO of Stripe to relaunch Europe

Making a bad bet

Added to these changes are other somewhat strange points. Purity keeps Bitcoin's P2P magic bytes (f9beb4d9), the default port 8333, the address formats, transaction serialization, the sighash, the binary names and the data directory. And, deliberately, it implements no transaction-level replay protection.

. The project justifies this as a strategy: there is no forced migration day, nothing has to be converted, no token is created. The "theory of victory" is that economic consensus will slowly migrate toward Purity's rules and that the legacy chain will be abandoned. In its own words: "The intended long-term outcome is economic migration to Purity's rules, not the creation of a separate 'new coin'."

The cost of that bet is real. A transaction signed today can be valid simultaneously on the mainnet and on Purity: any user moving BTC near the fork boundary may be transacting, without knowing it, on a chain they did not choose. The developers of Mempool.space have already documented that the few blocks of the BIP-110 branch contained "replay of mainnet transactions from days ago". The absence of protection makes Purity the direct heir to that risk, multiplied by its promise of indistinguishability.

That is why you will not see Purity on an exchange; supporting it would generate brutal economic chaos, billion-dollar losses and market crashes.

The man behind the fork: the central bank "prophet"

So far, Purity could be read as just another technical dissident from maximalism. But the second layer of it all is the person behind the project: Hong Shuning. His biography is extraordinarily well documented by himself in interviews with Wu Blockchain (2023), Chinese media and his own LinkedIn.

A 1992 graduate in Computer Science from Tsinghua University, he worked for nearly twenty years at the Nanjing branch of the People's Bank of China, in payment and clearing management, software, systems and networks.

In 2011, when Bitcoin surpassed the dollar, he wrote what is considered the first Chinese academic paper on Bitcoin, published in the magazine "China Credit Card": Bitcoin: a new type of currency that challenges the financial system. The article included three proposals aimed at his own employer, the central bank: first, that the PBOC use national computing power to mine Bitcoin; second, that a Bitcoin bank be created to channel the currency to the population; third, that a new legal tender backed by Bitcoin reserves be issued to compete with the dollar. Chinese media dubbed him the "Bitcoin prophet".

Ties to the government and to BSV

In 2017 he left the central bank and entered the private sector. There he created the blockchain lab of Suning Finance in Nanjing, directed the Jin Qiu Blockchain Research Institute in Shanghai, was a senior expert at CCB Fintech, the technology subsidiary of China Construction Bank, and chief strategy officer at the Chinese blockchain firm Zhejiang Yongqi.

He donated bitcoin to the LNP/BP association (RGB protocol) and publicly defended BSV, except for Craig Wright, whom he called a "liar". His X handle, "Nakamotwo Satoshi (BIP110)", and his August tweets show him as an active militant for the cause: "Mining and holding concentration are never threats to Bitcoin. The only threat is the centralization of developers. Generate more Bitcoin forks," he wrote on August 20, a day after the launch.

Vitalik explores new cryptography resistant to quantum computers

The China question: what is true and what is speculation?

Here it is worth separating fact from suspicion, because the topic lends itself to conspiracy. First, there is no public evidence that the Communist Party, the PBOC or CCB Fintech finance, direct or sponsor Bitcoin Purity. Hong Shuning is today, rhetorically, the opposite of a state agent: he defines himself as "far right", a disciple of Hayek, a maximalist, and his public discourse denounces fiat money and central bank inflation, starting with that of his former employer. That a former central banker preaches against central banks does not make him a state instrument.

But that same biography raises three legitimate concerns that are documented. The first is ideological. Hong's vision of Bitcoin and state power, as he himself formulated it in 2011, was statist. His paper did not defend individual sovereignty against the State; it defended that the Chinese State mine Bitcoin, create a national Bitcoin bank and issue yuan backed by BTC.

That is a vision of Bitcoin as a geopolitical tool against dollar hegemony, not as borderless money. There is no indication that the PBOC adopted it, but the public record shows how Hong thinks about the relationship between Bitcoin and sovereign power.

Sowing confusion

The second is the most concrete: a project with Chinese state connections does not need to be directed by the State to be destabilizing. Purity inherits the BIP-110 enforcement branch, which represents less than 3% of miner support, and claims to be Bitcoin.

It does not create a recognizable token or a clean separation: it presents itself as "the true and pure Bitcoin", with the same transaction format and no replay protection. That is not a classic technical attack, but it is an attack on coordination: it confuses users, wallets, exchanges and custodians about which chain is which, right in a summer in which Bitcoin is already dealing with eCash, Paul Sztorc's Drivechains fork, and the aftermath of BIP-110. In an ecosystem with ETFs managing tens of billions, chain identity confusion is a real operational risk vector.

The third is the historical precedent. The very idea that Beijing would use "national computing power" to seize a network mined by SHA-256 is not new: Hong proposed it fifteen years ago, and China came to concentrate more than half of the global hashrate before the 2021 ban. That today a former official of that same central bank leads a fork that keeps the mining algorithm, competes for the same ASICs and offers its own pools reopens that question with new nuances.

So while there is no proof that Purity will be "Chinese state mining", it is legitimate to point out that the design lends itself to it. And it is much worse, because precisely the use of ASERT and Parking that Purity does have opens the door for state attacks on the network to be carried out without major technical difficulties.

The relationship with Dashjr: rivals or accomplices?

On the other hand, the relationship between Purity and Dashjr is the darkest element of the whole affair, and it deserves precision. Purity is a fork of Bitcoin Knots, Dashjr's software. Its consensus base is the BIP-110 enforcement chain, the same one Dashjr promoted. It shares the complete thesis: arbitrary data must be eliminated from consensus. Its anti-Ordinals motto is the same. Its timeline is suspiciously complementary: Purity activated on August 19, a day before Dashjr publicly declared that replay protection "was Spamcoin's responsibility", and twelve days before the hard fork to Blake2b scheduled for September 1.

But there is also a real fracture. Dashjr bet on breaking with existing mining, since Blake2b makes ASICs obsolete and creates, de facto, a new token. While Purity does exactly the opposite: it keeps SHA256d, preserves mining investment and denies being a new currency.

If Dashjr's hard fork fails, Purity remains as the only operational heir to the BIP-110 legacy that did not self-destruct with an algorithm change. If Dashjr succeeds, they compete for the same ideological niche. The soberest reading is not that of a formal conspiracy, but that of a fragmentation of the puritan sect: two people who share dogma but not method, and who separately generate the confusion that together multiplies the network's risk.

The numbers fail

Despite this, the numbers, for now, do not favor either of them. Anthony Towns calculated that Purity's hashrate is around 0.2 EH/s versus the ~912 EH/s of the mainnet. The chain completed its first difficulty adjustment on August 25 and produces blocks, but without exchanges, without price and without infrastructure, it is a worthless currency. But that does not stop it from being a threat, one that the community must keep an eye on.

CoinMarketCap reinvents itself: it allows trading with cryptocurrencies and bets on AI agents

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading