Latest

Ethereum

Vitalik warns of the risk of depending on developers in Ethereum

Vitalik explains why excessive dependence on developers can become a risk to Ethereum's decentralization.

Vitalik warns of the risk of depending on developers in Ethereum
Vitalik warns of the risk of depending on developers in Ethereum

The latest text published by Vitalik Buterin on his X account is not a minor correction nor a nostalgic reflection on technical debates of the past. It is a political statement about the future of Ethereum and also a confirmation of many of the tensions that Observatorio Blockchain has been pointing out for some time: the fragility of the network's decentralization when it is subjected to the logic of the real world.

When Vitalik states that he no longer agrees with his famous 2017 tweet, in which he described as a mountain man fantasy the idea that users would personally validate the entire history of the chain, he is not disavowing efficiency, nor proposing that millions of people become technical operators. He is saying that a blockchain that only works while everything goes well is not a self-sovereign blockchain.

From academic theory to experience

For years, the debate around Ethereum was framed in almost academic terms. Honest-majority assumptions, acceptable trust models, computational efficiency, trade-offs between scalability and decentralization. And Vitalik was one of the great architects of that theoretical framework.

But the latest post introduces a clear break with that. The real world does not behave like the models. P2P networks fail. Latency spikes. Infrastructure providers disappear or censor. Mining and staking concentrate. Intermediaries, pressured by regulators or political interests, stop being neutral. And when that happens, the question stops being technical and becomes existential: who really controls access to the network?

How the move to proof of stake led Ethereum to depend on large companies

This point has been repeatedly taken up by Observatorio Blockchain when analyzing the concentration of staking, the dependence on large RPC providers (MetaMask, a DeFi dApp or a mobile wallet), the accelerated institutionalization of the ecosystem and the risk that Ethereum ends up operating under the same logic of power it sought to overcome.

The mountain man's cabin

The metaphor that Vitalik uses is revealing. The mountain man's cabin is not a desirable lifestyle for everyone nor an everyday solution. It is a refuge. A last-resort option. Something that is not used daily, but that must exist, be operational and be accessible when everything else fails. In practical terms, this means that Ethereum must allow, technically and socially, for a user to verify the state of the network without depending on an intermediary, to interact with the chain even if centralized providers fail, to exercise technical sovereignty when institutional sovereignty breaks down. All of this, not because it is efficient, but because it is necessary.

This idea connects directly with one of Observatorio Blockchain's most persistent editorial lines: decentralization is an operational capacity that is only demonstrated in adverse scenarios.

Technology with political consequences

The role of zero-knowledge proofs is fundamental in this shift in stance. Vitalik does not mention them as just another technical advance, but as the solution to a very specific problem. Until now, verifying the blockchain on one's own was unfeasible for most people.

For years, the reason for not doing so was that it was too expensive and too complex. With ZK-SNARKs, that obstacle ceases to exist. And when there is no longer a real technical limitation, continuing to depend on intermediaries stops being a necessity and becomes a choice.

Here a key point of contact arises with Observatorio Blockchain's analyses of ZK, rollups and Ethereum's technical roadmap. Technology is not neutral. It defines which models of power are possible and which are not. And in this case, it enables a model where self-sufficiency stops being heroic and becomes plausible.

The developers

One of the harshest passages in Vitalik's text is the one warning that, if the systematic response to failures is to call the devs, developers become the new center of power. Not out of bad faith, but by design. This point is important in an ecosystem where many solutions to structural problems have been addressed through patches or ad hoc interventions. Technical self-sufficiency does not eliminate the need for developers, but it limits their systemic power. And that, from a political perspective, is a much deeper form of decentralization than any metric of nodes or validators.

Tornado Cash

When Vitalik mentions the Tornado Cash case, he does not do so as an isolated episode, but as a warning. When all intermediaries censor at the same time, the only real alternative is direct access to the chain. This scenario, which Observatorio Blockchain has covered extensively, shows that decentralization fails through an accumulation of dependencies. And when those dependencies collapse simultaneously, what remains is the base architecture. If that architecture does not allow for self-sufficiency, the original promise is emptied out.

In his latest text, Vitalik does not propose going back or abandoning scalability, usability or institutional adoption. He proposes designing Ethereum for conflict, censorship and failure. A reflection that reinforces the thesis Observatorio Blockchain has defended in its recent analyses. Ethereum has entered a phase of maturity in which growing or scaling is no longer enough. The key question is whether the protocol can remain usable when the environment becomes hostile, whether due to regulatory pressure, censorship, systemic failures or disruptive technological advances such as quantum computing.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading