Vitalik Buterin, co-founder of Ethereum, argues that Ethereum should prioritize ETH as a store of value and that in the long term its value will depend more on the network's ability to remain secure and decentralized than on the number of coins it removes from circulation.
Joseph Lubin, also a co-founder of Ethereum and founder of Consensys, joined the debate today, Wednesday, November 11, and said that ETH can go beyond gold and bitcoin as a store of value because of the uses it has within the Ethereum blockchain. Among them he highlighted the possibility of taking out a loan using ETH as collateral, without having to sell it.
The cost of burning more ETH
Since 2021, every time someone makes a transaction on Ethereum, the network permanently removes the ETH that person pays as a base fee. At the same time, Ethereum issues new ETH to pay the validators who maintain the network. If more coins are removed than are created, the total supply falls. Hence the idea that the more Ethereum is used, the more ETH could be burned and the scarcer it could become.
Buterin wants to keep that mechanism, but believes ETH can serve as a store of value even if the burn is very low for years. He gives an example. If Ethereum issues 100 ETH and burns less than 10, the supply increases by more than 90. For Buterin, what can give ETH value in the long term is that its owners can hold it and move it on a network that is secure and hard for a single actor to control.
The problem, according to Buterin, arises when burning more ETH becomes a goal for the network. One way to do that would be to favor higher fees, which would make operations such as a payment or a private transfer more expensive. Another would be to adapt Ethereum's rules to attract activities willing to pay more. That would give more weight to those who influence changes to the protocol and more reasons for companies to lobby for rules that benefit their business.
Lubin takes the debate into credit territory
For Buterin, the first test of a store of value is survival. In the case of ETH, that means its owners can hold it securely, verify for themselves that the network follows its rules and move their coins even if someone tries to block the transaction. The Ethereum co-founder attributes that stability to decentralization and believes users will value it more as artificial intelligence accelerates technological change.
Lubin, chairman of Sharplink, a listed company that holds ETH as its main treasury asset, anticipates a period of high inflation and strong economic volatility. In that scenario, he believes ETH can serve to preserve wealth and use it as collateral. A user can deposit ETH in a lending protocol and receive stablecoins pegged to the dollar. If the price of ETH falls far enough, the protocol can liquidate the collateral.
There the two co-founders agree. Lubin expects the shift of more financial operations to Ethereum to expand demand for ETH. Buterin sees one more reason to hold it if more assets are issued on the main network that can be exchanged for ETH or financed with it as collateral.