Barely two weeks after launch, Robinhood Chain already exceeds $163.8 million in total value locked (TVL), holds $327.3 million in stablecoins and records daily volume of close to $693 million on decentralized exchanges (DEX), according to DefiLlama. These figures have revived the debate about Ethereum's economic model and whether the mainnet is capturing a sufficient share of the value generated by layer-2 solutions.
The controversy erupted after Lorenzo Valente, ARK Invest's director of digital asset research, analyzed the revenue split generated by Robinhood Chain since its launch. By his calculations, the network has generated approximately $816,000 in revenue. Of that amount, Robinhood would retain around 89%, Arbitrum would receive 10% as the layer-2 infrastructure provider and Ethereum would take in just $1,538, equivalent to 0.15% of the total, from settlement fees.
Robinhood and Ethereum
For Valente, these figures expose a problem in Ethereum's economy. If the thesis is that ETH is money, then Robinhood building here is ultra bullish. But if the thesis is that ETH is an asset that generates revenue, this is the ultra bearish case, he said. In his view, Ethereum is offering the most valuable settlement layer in the crypto ecosystem at marginal cost and should capture a larger share of the value generated by the applications that use its infrastructure.
As a reference, the analyst proposed an alternative revenue split: 75% for Robinhood, 10% for Arbitrum and 15% for Ethereum, compared with the current model, in which practically all the value stays with the application and the layer 2.
However, Joseph Lubin, co-founder of Ethereum and founder of Consensys, stepped in to reject the idea of raising mainnet fees to improve its revenue.
In my opinion, Ethereum L1 fees should stay low to encourage growth, he wrote on his X account. According to Lubin, over the next two or three years tens of thousands of companies will deploy applications on Ethereum, layer-2 networks and private chains compatible with the Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM).
The entrepreneur argues that the priority should not be maximizing the base layer's current revenue, but consolidating Ethereum as the infrastructure on which the digital economy will be built. In his view, that growth will increase demand for ETH as a collateral asset, boost staking, reduce the available supply and raise token burning through the EIP-1559 mechanism, strengthening the asset's value over the long term.
Store of value? Is it a divine proclamation from some god
The discussion reveals two ways of understanding Ethereum's economic future. One camp believes the mainnet should capture a larger share of the value generated by applications and layer 2s to reinforce ETH's investment case. The other, represented by Lubin, argues that Ethereum's success will depend on attracting as many companies as possible, even if that means giving up part of the network's direct revenue.
Valente's post sparked a lively debate within the Ethereum community. One of the first to respond was Ryan Berckmans, a community member and ETH investor, who argued that the network has never aimed to maximize fee revenue.
"ETH is a store of value and the fees paid to layer 1 are intentionally minimal; they only serve to manage congestion. Ethereum and ETH are growing toward global ubiquity. It's that simple," he wrote. Valente's reply was: "Ryan, I suggest you look at what ARK Invest holds in its ETF. It's clear you're speaking from ignorance. What exactly does it mean that ETH is a store of value? Is it a divine proclamation from some god?"
Division in the industry
For his part, developer Kaue, linked to the Solana ecosystem, questioned Robinhood's strategy of launching its own blockchain instead of building directly where users already exist. Let's see how they're doing with that landlord thing in a year. It's incredible that companies are still so greedy and would rather launch another dead chain, he said.
Valente again came out in defense of the layer-2 model and recalled that Arbitrum is one of the most active layer-2 networks in the ecosystem, stressing that in Robinhood's case the company already has a massive customer base. Robinhood literally has the users, so obviously it's building where the users are, he replied.
The discussion reveals a growing division within the Ethereum industry. While one side believes the network's success depends on consolidating itself as global infrastructure with low fees, the other argues that Ethereum should capture a larger share of the economic value generated by the applications and layer-2 solutions built on its technology. Robinhood Chain has thus become the first major real-world case in a debate that Observatorio Blockchain has been following for months and that is already shaping the evolution of Ethereum's economic model.
Continuing to grow as infrastructure without losing value
Just yesterday, Observatorio Blockchain reported that Joseph Lubin has taken a leading role in the strategy to bring Ethereum to Wall Street through the creation of a web of organizations aimed at driving its institutional adoption. His defense of keeping base-layer fees low fits with the goal of prioritizing that large companies, banks and asset managers build on Ethereum, even if that means the mainnet captures a smaller share of the revenue generated by the ecosystem.
The underlying question is how Ethereum can keep growing as infrastructure for companies and banks without losing a significant part of the economic value it creates.