Latest

Ethereum

Arca sees only a fifth of Ethereum's value as justified

Jeff Dorman, Arca's chief investment officer, questions Ethereum as a store of value and says he sees only a fifth of its value as justified

Translated from Spanish by an automated system. The Spanish original prevails. Read the Spanish original

Arca sees only a fifth of Ethereum's value as justified
Arca sees only a fifth of Ethereum's value as justified

Jeff Dorman, chief investment officer of Arca, a US firm specializing in digital assets, considers Vitalik Buterin's idea that Ethereum can serve to preserve wealth over the long term to be deeply mistaken. In an interview with Laura Shin published on November 13, Dorman said that, by his calculations, Ethereum's revenue and the use of ETH to pay for transactions explain only about a fifth of its market value,

Where the figure comes from

All ETH in circulation was worth about $246 billion combined, according to the figure Dorman used. To make his calculation, he estimated how much ETH users hold in their wallets to pay fees and how much the revenue generated by the network is worth. His total estimate was between $45 billion and $50 billion. He attributed the remaining roughly $200 billion to confidence in the asset and the expectation that it will rise in price. He called that speculative optimism hopium.

Vitalik Buterin and Joseph Lubin defend ETH as a store of value

Dorman argues that Buterin's thesis requires assuming that the other blockchains will eventually disappear. To explain why he doubts that ETH can follow in bitcoin's footsteps, he turned to the Zimbabwean dollar. The fact that the US dollar has served as a store of value, he reasoned, does not mean the Zimbabwean currency can serve the same function. His objection also applies to the business that already exists on Ethereum. An application like Uniswap can attract users and make money without that necessarily translating into more demand for ETH.

Buterin and Mougayar

Buterin, co-founder of Ethereum, had argued on November 8 that the network's security and the difficulty of anyone controlling it or censoring transactions give reasons to hold ETH over the long term. He also proposed maintaining the fee burn, which removes from circulation part of the ETH paid in each transaction. In his view, users can remain interested in holding the asset even if far fewer units are removed from circulation than are created.

After the interview, William Mougayar questioned Shin's choice of Dorman and noted that an Ethlabs thread brought together at least 17 people who could defend Buterin's thesis. Mougayar had already set out his own arguments at the Ethereum Market Research Center. Those who hold ETH can use it as collateral to take out a loan, and validators deposit it to take part in Ethereum's security. For Mougayar, those uses also count when explaining why someone decides to hold ETH.

Covadonga Fernandez

Author

Covadonga Fernandez

Covadonga Fernández is founder and director of the newspaper Observatorio Blockchain. She has worked with various companies developing crypto/blockchain projects, such as Singular DTV, a Switzerland-based platform and a pioneer in decentralizing the film industry, which led her to take part in the 2019 San Sebastián Film Festival. That same year she also took part in the Bern International Film Innovation Festival (Switzerland), with a presentation on linguistic plurality in blockchain. In 2022 she took part in the Acción Cultural Española edition with an article on Metaverse and Culture. In 2017 she wrote the chapter on Blockchain and Journalism in the book: «Blockchain: The Industrial Revolution of the Internet», published by Grupo Planeta. A year earlier, in 2016, she created the first Meetup on Blockchain and Journalism. That same year she also created the Blockchain Media site, to track the decentralization process of the cultural and creative industries. In 2020 she co-organized an event on how blockchain could help the cultural and creative industries, where the money received from sponsors was tokenized and speakers received payment in NFT format. Before founding Blockchain Media and Observatorio Blockchain, Covadonga worked at Grupo Z and the newspaper ABC; she was communications director of the Madrid Chamber of Commerce, a journalism professor at Universidad Carlos III de Madrid and chair of Telemadrid. Winner in the Outreach category at the 2024 Financial Innovation Awards and honored by Alastria at the 2025 Blockchain Awards

The latest
The N0N ransomware claims Starbucks, Samsung, Gap and Timberland

Keep reading