Latest

Artificial Intelligence

Argentine newspaper Perfil sues OpenAI and Microsoft for using its content to train AI

Perfil sues OpenAI and Microsoft for using journalistic content without permission to train their AI systems

Argentine newspaper Perfil sues OpenAI and Microsoft for using its content to train AI
Argentine newspaper Perfil sues OpenAI and Microsoft for using its content to train AI

The Argentine publisher Perfil is suing OpenAI, Microsoft Corporation and Microsoft de Argentina for damages over the alleged unauthorized use of journalistic content produced by its newsrooms. It accuses the technology companies of using its news reports, investigations, interviews and other content to train and improve artificial intelligence models without authorization or compensation.

Perfil sues OpenAI and Microsoft

The lawsuit was filed before Argentina's Federal Civil and Commercial Court and is led by lawyer Gonzalo Vidal Devoto, of the firm Biscardi & Asociados, according to the publisher itself. Perfil argues that the defendant companies used content it owns to develop commercial products and services based on artificial intelligence without the publisher's authorization and without compensating it financially.

The outlet notes that its lawsuit thus joins those of The New York Times against OpenAI and Microsoft in the United States and the dispute involving Folha de S.Paulo in Brazil. The Argentine outlet says the lawsuit sets a precedent for the Spanish-language press, as it becomes the first Spanish-language media outlet to sue OpenAI and Microsoft over the alleged misappropriation of intellectual property and unfair competition.

One of the main pillars of the lawsuit is the legitimacy of the historical and current training of artificial intelligence models. Perfil draws a distinction between a person accessing a news story published on the internet and a technology company collecting content on a massive scale to incorporate it into systems later intended for commercial exploitation.

Paywalls too

According to Perfil, OpenAI and Microsoft subjected the newspaper's content to scraping, tokenization and vectorization to track, download and store news reports, investigations, features and interviews, and use them as inputs to develop and optimize artificial intelligence models.

Perfil argues that the companies turned these journalistic materials into raw material for developing technology systems that generate businesses valued in the billions of dollars. The publisher says technical and IT expert evidence supports the lawsuit and documents the alleged use of its content.

The accusation also covers material protected by paywalls. According to Perfil, the use of its content would have affected even publications whose access was restricted to authorized users or subscribers.

The entire Microsoft ecosystem

Perfil's claim is not limited to the alleged use of content during model training. The publisher also focuses on the subsequent use of journalistic information within artificial intelligence products. Perfil points to services belonging to the Microsoft ecosystem such as Bing, Microsoft Copilot, Microsoft 365 Copilot, GitHub Copilot and Azure AI, as well as other tools and services related to artificial intelligence.

According to the outlet, these systems can draw on journalistic content to answer users' queries directly without users necessarily having to visit the pages where the information was originally published. For decades, much of the press's digital model has been based on drawing users to its websites. Visits generate advertising revenue and, at outlets with subscription models, convert part of that audience into customers.

In artificial intelligence systems, the user can ask a question and receive an answer compiled from multiple sources without needing to access the original pages directly. Perfil argues that this operation causes a decline in traffic, advertising impressions and revenue, thus affecting the economic sustainability of professional journalism.

Unfair competition

The lawsuit also includes an accusation of unfair competition and abuse of a dominant position, arguing that the large technology platforms occupy a privileged position within the digital ecosystem, while media outlets have considerably less bargaining power.

One of the arguments the Argentine company uses to support its position is precisely the agreements OpenAI maintains with various international news groups. OpenAI has reached agreements with organizations and media groups to use or integrate their content into certain artificial intelligence products.

Among them are Associated Press, Axel Springer, Financial Times, Le Monde, Prisa Media, Vox Media and Condé Nast, among others. For Perfil, these agreements show that journalistic content has economic value for the companies developing artificial intelligence systems.

The publisher questions why OpenAI has recognized that value through licensing agreements with major international news companies while, it argues in its lawsuit, it would not have applied the same standard to its content in Argentina.

Prisa and its agreement with OpenAI

Perfil places particular focus on Spain's Prisa, one of the major Spanish-language media groups that did reach an agreement with OpenAI. The existence of these agreements could become one of the relevant elements of the debate: if certain artificial intelligence companies pay to use content from some outlets, publishers that have not granted authorization can argue that their content also has licensable value.

The litigation opened by Perfil brings to the Spanish-speaking world a discussion that has already reached the courts in other markets. The underlying question is what rights artificial intelligence companies have to use content protected by intellectual property during the training and operation of their models.

In the current situation, newsrooms bear the costs of journalists, correspondents, editors, photographers, investigations and news production. If artificial intelligence systems can subsequently use that work to provide answers that partially replace visits to the original outlet, publishers believe this creates an imbalance between those who fund news production and those who build technology services on top of it.

Alfredo Collosa

Author

Alfredo Collosa

Alfredo Collosa is a tax specialist. Public accountant. Bachelor's degree in Business Administration. Official Master's in Public Finance and Tax Administration from UNED/IEF in Spain. AMLCA Anti-Money Laundering Certificate (Florida University, US) and member of MetaLaw

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading