Latest

Tokenization

El Salvador records $5 billion in RWA with CNAD

El Salvador's CNAD totals $5 billion in tokenized issuances as of October 9, with 74% in unlisted instruments and ERC-3643 leading.

El Salvador records $5 billion in RWA with CNAD
El Salvador records $5 billion in RWA with CNAD

The CNAD El Salvador public registry closed on October 9 with about $5 billion in real-world asset token issuances enabled since the commission began authorizing operations in 2023. The figure adds up the destinations of funds recorded issuance by issuance in its public registry, not a market estimate, and that detail changes the value of the data: these are amounts that a regulator reviewed, certified and kept under continuous supervision, with an issuer and a registration number behind each line.

The breakdown by destination explains what that tokenization is made of. Unlisted financial instruments account for $3,711.2 million, almost three quarters of the total, and that includes private debt and unlisted shares along with leasing and factoring contracts seeking a buyer outside an exchange. Construction and real estate projects contribute $640.3 million and listed financial assets $482.7 million, according to the cutoff the commission published this Monday.

By token type the bias is even more marked: 86.3% of enabled issuances are revenue tokens, which distribute a share of a project's cash flows, versus 10.6% debt and 3.1% equity. On the technical layer, 51.7% use ERC-3643, the standard designed for securities with identity control. Both clues point to the same place: whoever issues in El Salvador is not a crypto startup, but a company that needs to finance construction or working capital and wants to move its registry onto a chain with verified participants.

The breakdown by destination of funds

Destination of funds Amount Share
Unlisted financial instruments $3,711.2M 74,2%
Construction and real estate $640.3M 12,8%
Listed financial assets $482.7M 9,7%
Working capital and investment (CAPEX) $165.7M 3,3%
Total about $5 billion 100%

The dominant category is the least flashy one. The $3,711.2 million in unlisted instruments describe classic corporate financing, with private loans and stakes in private companies seeking a buyer outside an exchange. It is investment banking tokenization, not window dressing, and it lets a mid-sized company place debt without depending on the appetite of a local bank.

Real estate contributes $640.3 million and represents about 13% of the total. The list includes residential construction and apartment towers, as well as industrial warehouses and hotel complexes in areas such as Surf City. CAPEX contributes $165.7 million for the issuer's investment and working capital.

The series deserves a caveat. As of September 4 the commission reported $4,847.7 million in RWA with $3,781 million in unlisted instruments, so the main category fell while the total rose. It may be an accounting reclassification, but the 74% works better as a snapshot of the cutoff than as a trend.

A clear bias toward revenue tokens

86.3% of issuances are revenue tokens, the structure that gives the investor a percentage of the revenue of an operating asset. It is similar to buying an income stream: the owner of the project collects when the project bills and the token distributes that flow without voting rights or equity participation. The 10.6% debt pays a coupon and returns principal, while the 3.1% equity gives a share of the asset.

That split says something about the market's maturity. A portfolio dominated by revenue implies projects that are already operating and need to refinance or distribute cash, because a revenue token without flow is worth nothing and the issuer would have to justify why it is placing it. Debt, the natural gateway for any company to the capital market, falls short.

For the investor, the consequence is twofold. The commission reviews the financial, legal and technological structure of the issuance, not the quality of the business: a token for a hotel with low occupancy keeps the same registration as a profitable one. Compliance and profitability are different things, and that distance is what separates a regulated market from a safe market.

ERC-3643 dominates and ERC-20F follows in its footsteps

51.7% use ERC-3643, the standard that the EIP-3643 specification defines for permissioned tokens. Its mechanics are those of a securities registry: each holder is tied to a verifiable identity, each transfer goes through a compliance module that checks country, limits and blocks, and the issuer retains powers to freeze balances or recover a lost position.

29.1% use ERC-20F, which is not a rival but rather the Fireblocks implementation on ERC-3643, with upgradeable contracts and role control to mint, pause and administer. Combined, the two labels cover 80.8% of issuances: a single architecture with two commercial names.

The practical consequence is that the issuer decides who can hold the token. There are no anonymous wallets buying private debt: each holder goes through an identity registry that the commission can audit and the secondary market is restricted to authorized wallets.

Liquid and Algorand split what remains

Liquid Network appears with 12.7% through AMP, Blockstream's asset management platform. There control does not live in a contract but in a signature: each transfer requires the issuer's signature on a 2-of-2 multisig wallet, with restriction groups that define which wallet can receive the asset and what caps it has, according to the Liquid documentation.

The final 4.5% is labeled ASC1, the name with which Algorand identifies its smart contracts, a route that adds programmable rules to that chain's native assets. The four labels add up to 98.0% and do not close at 100%, so there remains 2% that the cutoff does not assign to any family.

The technical map leaves a deeper reading. The four dominant standards require identifying the holder, and the first three were born for regulated securities or for assets with an identifiable issuer: the debate over stablecoins and RWA described by the GENIUS Act and the new financial order is about turning the chain into a registry with gatekeepers.

A license that does not remove risk

Before enabling an issuance, the commission reviews the issuer's financial, legal, technological and operational profile, as well as anti-money laundering and terrorist financing controls. It also verifies the digital asset service provider and the certifier that signs the technical report, and keeps the issuance under surveillance throughout its life, according to the procedure detailed by the commission.

The entity itself clarifies that its authorization does not eliminate the risks inherent to the investment, a warning that weighs more than usual here because revenue tokens depend on flows that have not yet occurred. Supervision reaches the issuer and its structure, not the market where that token is resold, and there the classic gap of private assets remains: little liquidity and prices that nobody publishes.

The international dimension completes the picture. The commission maintains memoranda with nine countries, Argentina and Colombia among them, while Argentina authorizes the tokenization of shares, bonds and funds. Regional competition is no longer about attracting exchanges, but about registering issuers.

Who is really issuing

The numbers in the cutoff sketch a corporate financing market that uses the chain as a ledger, with revenue securities for real estate construction and private debt for working capital. That profile explains the dominance of ERC-3643 and ERC-20F and also the silence of the small investor, who barely appears because the product requires whitelisting and verified identity.

What is missing to know whether the model holds up is secondary and boring, and for that very reason decisive: how many of those issuances place their full amount, how many revenue tokens pay their flow on time and how the price is set when a holder wants to exit. A registry that adds up to $5 billion without a deep secondary market is a snapshot of the origin of capital, not yet of its circulation.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading