Latest

Tokenization

Javier Callejo, the sociologist of social tokenization

Javier Callejo, the sociologist of social tokenization, analyzes how tokens can transform ownership and the middle classes

Javier Callejo, the sociologist of social tokenization
Javier Callejo, the sociologist of social tokenization

In 2020, the Spanish sociologist Javier Callejo began asking at Observatorio Blockchain what would happen to the middle classes if tokenization allowed the fragmentation, even micro-fragmentation, of ownership of assets that until then had been out of their reach, a question that was barely part of the tokenization debate. Six years later, when banks, asset managers and financial markets have incorporated tokenization into their strategies, the question takes on another dimension.

A review of the earlier literature turns up work on fractional ownership, democratization of investment and even the social consequences of tokens, but we have not located an earlier Spanish-speaking author who expressly took tokenization into the terrain of social classes.

Social tokenization

On September 3, 2020, Callejo published in Observatorio Blockchain: Tokenización de bienes y la necesaria criptoculturización de las clases medias. At that time, tokenization was explained mainly as a technological and financial innovation capable of representing assets on a blockchain, dividing them and facilitating their trading. Callejo, however, focused on the people who could become owners of those fragments.

He spoke of the fragmentation, even micro-fragmentation, of ownership and linked it to a middle class that saw some of its traditional expectations of social mobility deteriorating. For Callejo, the possibility of accessing, through small amounts, assets previously reserved for large fortunes could change the relationship of those middle classes with savings, investment and ownership. A small investor is a financial category; a middle class is a sociological category. Callejo asked what consequences a new form of ownership could have on the social structure.

The intellectual background of Callejo helps explain that perspective. Callejo is a professor of Sociology at UNED. Previously, he carried out applied research in the market field for various companies, including: Telefónica, Iberia, RTVE, Tele 5, Canal Plus, Zurich Seguros and Microsoft. UNED itself lists among his main fields the methodology of social sciences, the sociology of communication and the sociology of consumption.

Privacy as a commodity

This is important for understanding his articles in Observatorio Blockchain. Callejo did not come from the crypto industry looking for a social interpretation of a new technology. He was a sociologist who found in blockchain a new object from which to observe old questions, such as ownership, value, institutions, inequality, collecting, consumption and social classes.

In August 2019 he published in our newspaper the article: Blockchain, una oportunidad para que los usuarios conserven o exploten su privacidad. In this text, Callejo historically reconstructed the separation between the public and the private from the rise of the Western bourgeoisie, the Enlightenment and the emergence of the modern home.

From there he moved through radio, television, the telephone, phone booths, the internet, digital assistants and the Internet of Things to finally arrive at blockchain. His interest was in how technologies alter institutions and social behavior. In that case, the institution chosen was privacy.

Ownership

Callejo argued that privacy has become a commodity. The data generated within the private space had acquired economic value and was being exploited mainly by the large platforms. Blockchain could introduce, in his view, mechanisms to give users greater decision-making power over those records.

A year later, the object of his analysis was no longer privacy but ownership. The 2020 article is especially interesting because Callejo starts from the middle class. He talks about social mobility, savings and ownership before introducing the possibilities of blockchain. That direction of reasoning distinguishes his analysis from much of the technological discourse of those years.

Ownership has historically been one of the elements that help explain the differences between social positions. It is not only important how much a person earns, but also whether they own housing, land, companies, shares, savings and other assets capable of providing security, income or transferable wealth. Tokenization introduced the possibility of dividing some of those assets into much smaller economic units.

Social stratification

Fractional ownership and the promise of democratizing investments were already part of the international debate on tokenization. Francis Jervis, of New York University, published in March 2019 From Economization to Tokenization: New Forms of Economic Life On-Chain, a work devoted to the new forms of economic life created through tokens.

The difference is that Callejo introduced into that debate a specific sociological category: the middle classes and their relationship with ownership. And it was not an isolated reference. Three years later, he returned to and expanded that idea in Observatorio Blockchain with Tokenización y estilo de vida de las nuevas clases medias globales. Tokenization, he argues, allows access through fragmentation to business projects, works of art, jewelry and other assets. From this he derives a much more ambitious hypothesis: The middle class will be defined by the structure of tokens it owns.

The phrase introduces the token directly into the analysis of social stratification. If profession, income, education, housing, consumption or wealth have traditionally been used to analyze the social position of individuals, Callejo suggests that in a deeply tokenized economy the composition of the digital assets each person owns could also matter.

Hernando de Soto

He adds moreover that tokenized assets can circulate in markets that overflow national borders. Hence his reference to new global middle classes. Digital ownership could contribute, in his hypothesis, to building forms of economic belonging less tied to territory than the middle classes developed during the 20th century.

At the end of 2023, Callejo expanded the framework again. In the article «La tokenización es la segunda revolución de la propiedad» he turned to the Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto to recall the importance that the modern recognition of property rights had in the development of capitalism. His argument is that tokenization may represent a new transformation because it facilitates the division and circulation of those rights and their conversion into capital.

The intellectual trajectory was beginning to become clear. What in 2020 had appeared as micro-fragmentation of ownership for the middle classes ended up becoming a reflection on the very nature of ownership in capitalism. In 2024, that expansion continued with his texts on financialization and the tokenized economy. The question was what happens when more and more assets can be transformed into tradable assets and when, in parallel, more and more citizens can become investors.

Tokenization and society

It is the continuity of these articles that gives interest to the role of Observatorio Blockchain. Its archive allows the public development of a sociological interpretation of blockchain to be reconstructed over several years while the technology itself was evolving.

Callejo used the newspaper to analyze questions that went far beyond cryptocurrency prices. Privacy, ownership, middle classes, lifestyles, globalization, business financing and capitalism progressively entered his texts. That space also allowed a type of reflection unusual in the early years of blockchain. While much of the specialized conversation was devoted to explaining how the new technologies worked, Callejo tried to ask what kind of society they could produce.

Six years later, the question is who will own those assets and what owning them will mean. Because if tokenization changes the way ownership is distributed, it can also change the way ownership distributes positions within society.
Observatorio Blockchain

Author

Observatorio Blockchain

The site where people interested in the new industries and businesses of the crypto economy and the decentralized web stay informed

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading