Latest

Tokenization

Tokenized government debt, three models of European tokenization

The ESM places 1 billion in Pontes, Italy wants its debt on the blockchain and Spain proposes it. Three models and the same outstanding problems.

Tokenized government debt, three models of European tokenization
Tokenized government debt, three models of European tokenization

Europe is no longer debating whether government debt can be issued on a distributed ledger. It is debating how, who gets paid for doing it and what part of the traditional financial system is left out. In October the European Stability Mechanism placed its first native digital bond for 1 billion euros, with delivery-versus-payment settlement through Pontes, the Eurosystem platform that had been running for five weeks.

The operation has concrete figures. A three-year term with a 3.375% coupon maturing on 8 April 2030. It received orders for 2.2 billion, more than double the amount offered. The Bundesbank acted as issuing and paying agent, the bond was issued on Deutsche Börse's D7 platform and DZ BANK, HSBC, Santander and Société Générale acted as lead banks, with the first two entities taking on additional digital advisory roles.

What is interesting is not the figure, which is modest in the European bond market. What is interesting is that the end buyer did not have to know anything about blockchain. Investors receive the security in Clearstream's conventional system and hold it in the same accounts as any other bond. The tokenization happens in a layer the client does not even see. That design contrasts with two projects going another way. Italy wants to bring its government debt onto the chain through a payments consortium with its own stablecoin, and in Spain the proposal has come through the political route, with an MEP calling for issuing tokenized debt and the CNMV authorizing platforms to trade tokenized shares and bonds. Three strategies that say the same thing with different instruments.

The European model bets on the plumbing

The rescue fund's issuance was done in a hybrid scheme that deserves explanation. The bonds live on a distributed ledger, settlement is coordinated in Pontes and cash moves through the settlement bank's TARGET account. The cycle is five days from the trade, the same as a conventional bond, which in practice means the new infrastructure did not speed anything up.

That choice is deliberate. The aim of the European authorities is not to gain speed, it is to prove that the plumbing works with central bank money and without changing the legal framework. If the buyer receives the bond in their usual account and payment is made in central bank money, the operation is legally equivalent to a traditional issuance.

The savings, if they come, will come from elsewhere and will be hard to quantify in a spreadsheet: the custody chain gets shorter and the settlement cycle loses manual touchpoints. These are real and hard-to-quantify benefits, which is exactly what a market that moves trillions and changes infrastructure once a decade needs.

There is a limitation that the participants themselves acknowledge. At this early stage, cash tokens have design drawbacks that affect settlement finality, which is why direct payments in the central bank account prove more reliable. The fully tokenized version of the cycle will arrive with a future update to Pontes.

The Italian model wants the domestic market

Italy has chosen a different and, in its rhetoric, more ambitious path. The Bancomat payments network is integrating the fintech Hercle into its euro stablecoin project, EUR.BANK, with a stated goal that until now no one had formulated so clearly: bringing Italian government debt onto the blockchain.

Market size matters less than structure. A small bond with impeccable settlement is worth more as a precedent than a large issuance with no secondary market. Issuers know this, which is why they start with controlled transactions before moving larger volumes.

The difference from the European model is the perimeter. While the rescue fund issues a bond with institutional liquidity and international placement, Bancomat targets its network of domestic banks and merchants, which is where it has a competitive advantage and where it can capture fees. If it works, the Italian Treasury would have a digital retail placement channel without depending on foreign investment banking.

The political appeal is obvious. A country with debt exceeding €2.9 trillion has strong incentives to seek new demand and to reduce the cost of placement. Tokenization does not change solvency, but it can broaden the buyer base and improve the perception of modernity.

The risk is also obvious. A private stablecoin that buys sovereign debt creates a dependency between the digital currency and the State's liabilities that regulators scrutinize closely. If the issuer has liquidity problems, the Treasury is left with one fewer buyer at the worst moment. Hercle's entry into the Italian payments network is detailed in coverage of the EUR.BANK project,with the three application fronts it proposes.

The Spanish model is still just a proposal

The distance between a proposal and an issuance is measured in years, not months. And in that interval it is decided whether the project has a buyer or remains a slide deck while the political calendar shifts priorities.

In Spain the movement has come through two separate channels. The first is political: MEP Fernando Navarrete raised in October the possibility of issuing tokenized government debt, an idea that sounds reasonable in Brussels and that in Madrid still has no timetable.

The second is regulatory and is already under way. The CNMV authorized Bit2Me to trade tokenized shares and bonds, which makes Spain one of the first European countries with an operating framework for digitalized fixed-income instruments. It is not government debt, but it is the infrastructure that would be needed to issue it.

The figure that puts the matter in perspective is Spanish public administrations' debt, which closed August at 1.75 trillion euros, 99.7% of GDP according to the Bank of Spain. Any improvement of a tenth in the financing cost of that volume is measured in hundreds of millions a year, and that arithmetic is what keeps the political discussion alive.

The distance between the proposal and the issuance is large. Issuing tokenized debt requires a law, a willing issuer, a settlement infrastructure accepted by the central bank and a secondary market with liquidity. Spain has the third piece and lacks the rest. The political proposal to issue tokenized government debt still has no timetable, and the closest operational precedent is the CNMV's authorization of Bit2Me.

What is missing is not technology

The three models share a bottleneck that cannot be solved with code. The secondary market for tokenized bonds barely exists, and without a secondary market a bond is a term deposit with more paperwork. Investors buy to hold, not to trade.

The second missing piece is settlement finality. A distributed system that does not guarantee that the transfer is final and irrevocable at the expected moment forces the maintenance of reconciliation layers and safety margins. That erases much of the promised saving.

The third is public accounting. A Treasury that issues on a distributed ledger has to integrate that liability into its accounting system, its debt statement and its statistics. None of those pieces is designed for assets that change holder every hour.

The fourth is the most political. If the debt is tokenized and sold to retail investors, the State exposes itself to a volatile creditor base, with less tolerance for bad news and more sensitivity to headlines. Sovereign issuers have historically preferred slow institutional investors for a reason.

Why the debate matters even if nothing changes tomorrow

The rescue fund's issuance is not going to transform the European debt market in 2027. What it does is set a technical and legal precedent that other issuers can copy without negotiating from scratch with each central bank.

That is the real value of the operation. Europe has shown that a sovereign bond can be issued on a distributed ledger, settled with central bank money and reach the investor through the usual channels. What it has not shown is that it is cheaper, faster or more liquid.

The next test is on the calendar. If more supranational issuers repeat the scheme, the infrastructure gains volume and fixed costs are diluted. If the experiment remains a yearly one-billion operation, the tokenization of government debt will be a showcase and not a market. And that outcome will depend less on technology than on the willingness of treasuries to move their financing onto a new rail.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading