Latest

Tokenization

Columbia professor criticizes the New York Stock Exchange's tokenization model

Columbia professor questions the New York Stock Exchange's tokenized platform and calls it an initiative without real innovation

New York Stock Exchange accused of hollow tokenization
New York Stock Exchange accused of hollow tokenization

Omid Malekan, an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School, shows on his X account his deep skepticism about the recent announcement by the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) of the launch of a new platform for tokenized securities. An opinion that Malekan sets out in an article he wrote for Fortune. For Malekan, the NYSE initiative looks more like a marketing exercise wrapped in innovative rhetoric than a project with real disruption.

Tokenization in the financial system

The NYSE proposal was presented as a milestone for institutional blockchain adoption, with continuous trading, near-instant settlement and integration with distributed ledger technology. For Malekan, what the NYSE is proposing is relevant, since as well as being an iconic brand, it is part of a group that controls exchanges and clearing systems around the world. Its entry into tokenization therefore confirms that this technology is becoming widespread in the financial system.

However, in his view, the fact that shares will be tokenized and that regulators will oversee new issuance and trading models does not necessarily mean the NYSE is in a position to lead the next stage of financial markets. To illustrate this, Malekan turns to the case of AT&T in the late 1990s.

He describes how at that time, AT&T, then the world's largest telecommunications company, chose to partner with the startup Excite instead of betting on models that broke with its business logic. Google, which offered a far more efficient search engine, was discarded because it did not fit a corporate culture based on charging for access time. Over time, Google ended up redefining the Internet, while AT&T lost strategic relevance. For Malekan, the analogy is clear, since recognizing an innovation does not mean fully embracing it.

Lack of concrete details

One of the main reasons for his skepticism is the lack of concrete details in the NYSE announcement. The exchange has not specified which blockchains its platform will support, which stablecoins it will use, which programming languages or virtual machines will be supported, or which token standards will be adopted. Nor has it clarified in which jurisdictions it will operate or whether it will integrate decentralized tokens or DeFi tools. In Malekan's view, this absence of information makes any serious assessment of the project's viability difficult.

The professor also questions the supposedly innovative nature of some of the announced features. 24/7 trading and instant settlement, he argues, are not exclusive to blockchain and can be implemented using traditional databases. In fact, the NYSE itself operates some of the most advanced technological infrastructures in the world. The true differentiating value of platforms like Ethereum, Malekan stresses, does not lie in the database, but in its permissionless architecture, in bearer assets and in direct global access without intermediaries.

Restricted access

Apparently, the NYSE's tokenized platform would keep access restricted to qualified broker-dealers under a scheme the exchange describes as non-discriminatory. For Malekan, this wording contains an obvious contradiction. If it is a solution available only to authorized intermediaries, it can hardly be considered open. This design reflects what he describes as the classic innovator's dilemma. The NYSE currently derives much of its revenue from charging brokers, high-frequency trading firms and clearing members for access, trading, colocation and data. None of these revenue sources fits naturally into a public, decentralized blockchain.

The DeFi lie: why the financial revolution never arrived

From this perspective, Malekan asks how the NYSE intends to generate revenue in a truly tokenized system. His conclusion is that the platform appears designed to protect its current clients and partners, not to transform the structure of the market at its roots. Instead of integrating directly with DeFi, the exchange chooses to build an alternative platform, adapted to its business model and its historical incentives.

Tokenization as a trend

For the professor, this approach does not invalidate tokenization as a trend, but it does limit its transformative scope. The NYSE initiative is a clear sign that the financial system is changing, but it should not be interpreted as a break with the existing model. Rather, Malekan concludes, it is an attempt to adopt blockchain technology without allowing it to substantially alter the power relations, intermediation or revenue sources that have defined the institution for decades.

Maria Gonzalez

Author

Maria Gonzalez

Journalist specializing in cryptocurrencies, artificial intelligence and emerging technology, with experience in trend analysis, innovation coverage and writing features that connect the digital economy with the real world.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading