Latest

Technology

The subscription trap: easy to enter, hard to leave and more expensive every time

The subscription trap turns ownership into rental: we pay every month, prices go up and it gets harder and harder to leave

Software is no longer bought, it is rented forever
Software is no longer bought, it is rented forever

The subscription stopped being a way of paying and became a way of commanding. Netflix raised its standard plan to 19.99 dollars in March 2026, and that gesture sums up the deal: you pay every month for something that will never be yours.

The scene repeats itself in software, in music, in video games and even in car features, because digital rental has become the default model of the technology industry. What began as a convenient alternative to buying has become a permanent structure: companies no longer sell products, they sell access, and access renews itself while the user looks the other way.

The subscription trap

In practice, 89% of consumers underestimate what they spend on subscriptions, according to the report by Apprupt, a figure that grows every year. The result is an unbalanced relationship in which each side plays by different rules.

Entering costs a click and a card; leaving requires navigating retention screens, calling a customer service line or accepting a penalty for having paid in advance. Nobody disputes that paying for a useful service makes sense; what fails is that the bill renews itself and that the price changes with no possible negotiation.

The lure of flexibility

We were sold digital rental as an advantage. With no upfront outlay and updates included, they said, the user came out ahead compared with buying a perpetual license that aged on the hard drive.

The trap begins with not knowing how much you pay. Again, the Apprupt report makes it very clear, 89% of consumers underestimate their subscription spending, and someone who calculates 86 dollars a month from memory ends up paying around 219 when they check their statement.

That mismatch is not an accident of bad memory. The automatic charge is designed so that you do not look at it, and your annual bank statement is the only moment when the system answers to you.

The flexibility existed on paper, because you could cancel whenever you wanted. The problem is that the exit door was designed so that you do not feel like using it, with too many steps and too few notices.

The great AI gap: 1.4 trillion invested and 613 billion in revenue

Raising the price is not a decision, it is a model

And that is because raising the price is not a decision, it is a model. For example, Netflix raised prices again in March 2026, its second increase since early 2025. Disney+ went from 6.99 dollars in 2019 to 18.99 on its ad-free plan, four increases in four years, according to Deadline's tracking. HBO Max and Peacock applied their own increases between 2025 and 2026.

The pattern is clear: the industry does not compete to lower prices, it competes to see who can withstand the increase without losing subscribers, and so far they all withstand it. Here it is worth remembering what the user buys with that money. They buy exactly the same as the previous month, but with a higher bill, because the catalog does not grow at the pace of the receipt.

Microsoft took the idea to the extreme in January 2025. It raised Microsoft 365 by three dollars a month to include Copilot, the first increase in twelve years, according to The Verge. The company presented it as an included improvement and not as an increase.

The artificial intelligence you did not ask for, you pay for anyway, and if you wanted to keep the previous price you had to try to cancel so that they would offer you the classic plan, hidden in that maze.

Cancelling is the battlefield

And in the middle of that universe of price increases, the other side of the whole thing appears: fighting to cancel the subscription. In June 2024, Adobe rewrote its terms of use and unleashed a revolt of creators who threatened to cancel. The reason? Abandoning an annual plan could cost up to 50% of the outstanding balance, according to Ars Technica. They charge you even for cancelling, they charge you for a service and they charge you for not using it in the future.

The United States tried to restore order with the "click-to-cancel" rule, which required cancelling to be as easy as subscribing. The Eighth Circuit struck it down in July 2025, over a procedural defect, according to the analysis by Gibson Dunn. But the FTC did not sit still. In January 2026 it sent a new draft rule and in March it opened the public consultation, according to the FTCitself. Meanwhile, it continues to pursue cases under the 2010 online shopping law.

The pattern is always the same. Subscribing fits in one click and cancelling requires calling to explain why you are leaving and surviving several retention screens that exist only to discourage you.

Europe moves faster than Washington

For its part, the European Union approved in November 2023 a directive that requires offering a cancellation button in all distance contracts, with a two-step process and acknowledgement of receipt. The rules apply from June 19, 2026, according to the review by Legal Nodes.

. The European diagnosis is devastating. 62% of consumers suffered automatic renewals without prior notice, 44% paid for extra months because they did not know it was renewing and 40% saw the price rise after the initial promotion, according to the Digital Fitness Check cited by.

Lexology

. Germany and France already require cancelling in two or three clicks. France gives notice of renewal between one and three months in advance and Italy requires reminding customers thirty days ahead.

Brussels is also preparing the Digital Fairness Act, expected by the end of 2026, focused on dark patterns and on free trials that turn into payment. The theory is good; the timetable, slow.

AI is the perfect excuse to raise your fee Subscribers to AI tools pay on average for four services, about 66 dollars a month, and 53% cancel and reactivate as needed, according to the Bango study from November 2025 compiled by.

Readless

. AI arrived as a gift and is billed as a service. First it comes included, then it asks for a higher plan, and in the end the useful feature sits behind a paywall that did not exist before.Cory Doctorow named this cycle in January 2023. He called it enshittification in

his Pluralistic blog

: first the platform takes care of the user, then it squeezes them, and in the end they are left with a worse service for more money. The subscription is the perfect vehicle for that drift.

Biological computing: Singapore tests 20 computers with human neurons

The honest counterargument

It would be convenient to present every subscription as a scam, and it is not. There are services that are worth what they cost, because they include storage, continuous improvements and support that a one-time purchase never gave. For a small creator, paying ten euros a month for a professional tool can be much cheaper than buying it. For a company, recurring spending is easier to plan than an unexpected outlay.The industry is also correcting itself. 61% of software companies have shifted toward usage-based or hybrid pricing, according to data compiled by

Value Add VC

, which suggests that the customer is beginning to have a voice.

Acknowledging this does not weaken the criticism. The question is not whether the subscription can be fair, but who decides the rules when it stops being fair and what real room you have to leave before the relationship becomes abusive.

The exit is not free, but it exists The first defense is knowing how much you pay. Auditing recurring charges once a year, cancelling what you do not use and remembering that the price of a free trial is almost never zero gives you back control.The second is the path of software that is not rented. As we explained when reviewing the

free alternatives to the big tech companies

, there are one-time-payment or free replacements for almost everything that today arrives in the form of a monthly fee.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading