Latest

Sociological Analysis

Automated companies: the Argentine experiment that pits Milei against Harari

The clash between Milei and Harari over automated companies opens a debate on AI, the market and democracy

Automated companies: the Argentine experiment that pits Milei against Harari
Automated companies: the Argentine experiment that pits Milei against Harari

One of the most striking confrontations of recent days has been the one between the Argentine president, Javier Milei, and the Israeli historian and philosopher Yuval Noah Harari. Beyond the exchange of statements, the debate reflects two radically different ways of understanding the future of technology, the role of the State and the risks of artificial intelligence. In other words, two visions of the present in terms of the colonization of the future.

Milei and Harari at odds over AI

From Milei's position, the future can still be colonized, be the object of human agency, by making use of technology. Harari represents the fear of being colonized by the future; the vision of the future as a threat. Yet beyond the different perspectives, the object at the center of the dispute is the so-called automated company. An automated company is a company whose day-to-day management is carried out, to a large extent or entirely, by artificial intelligence systems instead of human managers.

It does not necessarily mean that the company has no human owners or shareholders. The difference is that operational decisions are made by an AI system. There are no fully automated companies yet. There are companies that use AI for decisions as important as those relating to logistics, investments, pricing, hiring suppliers or advertising strategies. But fully automated companies, no. Even less so with legal recognition, which is the step the Argentine government was beginning to take.

An invitation for big tech to set up in Argentina

The chronology of the dispute is as follows. Scene 1: Milei publishes an article in the Financial Times in which he sets out a strategy to turn Argentina into a global hub for artificial intelligence. Among the initiatives proposed is a legal reform to allow companies managed entirely by AI systems to have legal personality and limited liability, within a regulatory framework designed specifically for this type of organization.

Claude Mythos's AI certifies the end of Modernity: we enter cyber-transhumanism

It was fundamentally a formal invitation for big tech to set up in Argentina and, specifically, a way of attracting investment to the country. That said, given the profile of the Argentine President, it included phrases of considerable ideological condensation. As when he says that it is about: “offering the refuge that James Watt needed 200 years ago, allowing imagination to develop and grow freely”.

In fact, the title of the article is a statement in itself: Argentina invites AI to free itself (“Argentina invites AI to free itself, in its original English title). Milei argues, among other things, that the country must become for AI what Amsterdam represented for world trade during the 17th century: a territory where innovation encounters the fewest possible barriers. As can be seen, the far-reaching historical references condense the proposal to attract investment; making it seem, more than a proposal to attract investment, like Argentina's placement at the first point on the institutional map of a kind of new capitalism.

Legal personality for a robot

The article accompanied the sending to the Argentine Senate, on June 1, of a General Companies Bill. A deep reform of Argentine company law that defines the figure of the Automated Company. It is defined in the legislative text as one that: “carries out its corporate purpose through autonomous algorithmic systems or artificial intelligence agents, without requiring employees in an employment relationship or human resources for its ordinary operation”.

Indirectly, legal personality is being granted to a robot. From such legal personality, it has responsibilities. Thus, the company is liable with its assets for the damages it causes. An algorithm that commercially offers services is liable with its assets for damages. In short, an algorithm that offers a service or product autonomously can be incorporated as a company, negotiate with third parties and limit its liability to the corporate assets. It is worth considering, even if it is only a well-founded intuition, that the algorithm's decision to become a company may also be autonomous. A question that, in any case, seems to be outside the debate.

AI as a dangerous technology because it is infallible

Scene 2: Harari enters with his response in the same media outlet. Since the publication of his bestselling title Sapiens, Yuval Noah Harari has become one of the few planetary intellectuals, with his opinions heard all over the world. It is not the first time that the professor at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem has spoken about AI. In fact, it is the subject of his recent book Nexus: A Brief History of Information Networks from the Stone Age to AI. In it, he defines AI as the first technology in history that can make decisions and generate new ideas by itself. A book that has not achieved the sales success of the previous ones -Sapiens, Deus- and in which he portrays AI as a dangerous technology because it is infallible.

Harari described the initiative as extremely risky, placing more emphasis on the political dimensions than on the strictly technological ones. For Harari, granting legal personality to entities controlled by artificial intelligence could allow them to operate in the economy, the financial system or even in politics with an unprecedented degree of autonomy. Up to this point, it could be said that a consensus exists. However, it is on the consequences of such autonomy of autonomous companies that the conflict focuses. And it is no longer just that AI is infallible, but that it has no fear. If there is no fear, there is no responsibility.

Buenos Aires as a new Amsterdam

The historian argues that an AI cannot be deterred through traditional mechanisms of criminal liability. While a person can fear going to prison or suffering personal consequences, an artificial intelligence system lacks psychological incentives to obey the law. He also warns that sufficiently advanced models could learn to exploit legal loopholes or manipulate rules for their own benefit. Its own infallibility, power over others' failures and lack of responsibility are articulated in the argument responding to Milei.

A response that seeks to lay bare the Argentine leader's arguments: “Milei hopes to turn Buenos Aires into a new Amsterdam. He runs the risk of turning it into a new Batavia”. Batavia, today Jakarta, was the capital of the former Dutch colonies in Asia, historically associated with the power of the large trading companies. Harari does not dispute AI's capacity to generate wealth; but he denounces that legal personality is a general-purpose key that would also allow these new autonomous companies to access our financial, economic and political systems. Here lies the heart of the Hebrew historian's concern: the capacity for action given to these actors through the recognition of legal personality.

Terminator's Judgment Day

Scene 3: Milei responded through an official statement, issued by the so-called Office of the President, rejecting the criticism. It should be noted that Milei took ten days to draft the response. In other words, he thought it through, and it does not seem that it can be attributed to the explosive temperament with which the Argentine politician tends to be portrayed.

A broad justificatory stroke is used: “granting legal personality to AI companies does not mean launching Terminator's Judgment Day”. But also the relatively subtle nuances, using Harari's own work and his own defense of liberalism: “Harari's concerns are an argument in favor of legal personality, not the opposite”, emphasizing that legal personality “far from facilitating abuses, is precisely the mechanism through which a company channels its creative energy within the framework of the law, property rights and the principle of non-aggression that form the pillars of liberalism”.

He even showed knowledge of the historian's work, stressing that in Sapiens he praises limited liability, arguing that: “The idea behind such companies is among the most ingenious inventions of humanity”. But above all, the response emphasized that with the regulation, with his proposed new Law, what is achieved is protection, in opposition to Harari's argument of widespread vulnerability.

Tension between market and democracy

With this dispute between Milei and Harari, the opening of a new ideological battleground around AI is confirmed. The real interest of the exchange of messages, over which a certain harsh tone hovers following Harari's response, lies in the underlying debate. A debate between those who, on the one hand, believe that AI should be developed with minimal state intervention to accelerate innovation. On the other hand, those who consider that we are facing a technology with the capacity to profoundly transform the economy, politics and society, which is why it is essential to first build solid oversight mechanisms. A debate we have already seen with respect to other technologies, including Blockchain technology.

In that sense, the confrontation between Javier Milei and Yuval Noah Harari probably symbolizes one of the great discussions of this decade: whether AI should advance at the pace set by the market or at the pace allowed by democratic institutions. A debate that, updated with respect to AI, leads us to a tension that has been very present in the Modernity of the last hundred years, such as the tension between market and democracy. Without a market, there is no democracy. Without democracy, there is no market. They need to coexist. But coexistence generates great tensions. Well, AI enters into these tensions, like many other problems that surround us today.

Javier Callejo

Author

Javier Callejo

Professor of Sociology at the National University of Distance Education (UNED). Degrees in Journalism and Law

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading