Latest

Regulation & CBDC

Brussels regulates open source software like a car factory

Brussels promises less dependence on Silicon Valley, but raises doubts about the future of European open source software

Brussels regulates open source software like a car factory
Brussels regulates open source software like a car factory

The new European technology sovereignty strategy bets on open source software as a tool to reduce the continent's digital dependencies. However, it also risks imposing on open source communities regulatory obligations designed for traditional industries, far removed from the decentralized and collaborative reality that characterizes open source software development.

The European Commission has just presented its biggest technology bet in decades. The so-called European Technology Sovereignty Package aims to strengthen the continent's digital autonomy through a combination of investment, regulation and industrial policy spanning everything from semiconductors to artificial intelligence, cloud computing and open source software.

Heavy dependence on technologies from outside Europe

On paper, the diagnosis is hard to dispute. Europe remains heavily dependent on technologies developed beyond its borders. The most advanced chips are manufactured mainly in Asia, cloud computing is dominated by US giants and the most powerful artificial intelligence models come mostly from North American companies. Even a significant part of the digital infrastructure used by European governments and administrations rests on technologies developed outside the Union.

Brussels' response is ambitious and the new Chips Act 2.0 aims to strengthen European semiconductor production. The future Cloud and AI Development Act seeks to triple the capacity of European data centers. The Commission wants to promote artificial intelligence gigafactories, develop European models and create mechanisms to assess the sovereignty of digital infrastructures.

But it is precisely in the chapter devoted to open source that a paradox appears that could determine the success or failure of the entire strategy.

More than three million open source contributors

For the first time, the Commission explicitly acknowledges that open source software is a strategic asset for European technology sovereignty. And this is no minor matter. Europe has more than three million open source contributors. Much of the world's digital infrastructure, from web servers to cryptographic libraries, operating systems, databases and artificial intelligence tools, depends on open projects maintained by communities distributed across the planet.

Europe's Open Source First plan threatens to suffocate open source software

The Commission itself admits that it needs to strengthen this ecosystem to reduce dependencies. However, there is a fundamental difference between recognizing the value of open source software and understanding how it actually works. Open source software is not a traditional industry, nor is it organized through hierarchical production chains. Nor does it respond to five-year plans, nor is it born in ministerial offices.

Its main characteristic is precisely the absence of a control center. And that is where the problem begins. The Commission talks about AI gigafactories, regions of excellence for semiconductors, certification frameworks, strategic data centers and sovereignty assessment mechanisms.

Linux, Apache, Python, PostgreSQL, Kubernetes, Bitcoin

All of this may be useful, but the history of open source software shows that the most transformative technologies of the internet rarely emerged from institutional programs. Linux, Apache, Python, PostgreSQL, Kubernetes or Bitcoin were not the result of a coordinated public strategy. They emerged from open communities that evolved in a decentralized and, in many cases, chaotic way.

Europe seems to assume that it can build technology sovereignty through regulation and industrial incentives without altering the delicate balance that makes open innovation possible. It is not clear that both things are compatible. While Brussels announces a strategy to strengthen open source software, European developers are watching regulatory pressure on the digital ecosystem increase at the same time.

The Cyber Resilience Act (CRA), the new Product Liability Directive and future obligations linked to artificial intelligence create an increasingly complex legal environment. The intention is understandable. Citizens want safer digital products. Governments want resilient infrastructures and companies demand greater guarantees. But the problem appears when these obligations meet projects maintained by small teams, foundations or independent developers.

Voluntary collaboration between people

Open source software has historically been built on the principle of voluntary collaboration between people who share knowledge without assuming responsibilities equivalent to those of a large technology corporation. Therefore, when the cost of regulatory compliance increases, incentives change. Not because developers are going to be pursued by Brussels, but because the perception of legal risk changes the behavior of the entire ecosystem.

Here a consequence appears that is rarely mentioned in official documents. When the regulatory environment becomes more complex, actors with robust legal departments gain an extraordinary competitive advantage. Large companies can absorb compliance costs, manage audits, respond to regulatory requirements and assume legal risks that are unaffordable for small community projects. In theory, the European strategy seeks to reduce concentrations of power, but in practice, it could reinforce them.

Independent developers would end up depending increasingly on large organizations capable of providing legal coverage, funding and regulatory compliance structures. The result would be a new form of dependence, not on Silicon Valley, but on a small number of large technology intermediaries capable of navigating the European regulatory maze.

Digital feudalism

A kind of digital feudalism where legal protection replaces military protection and where market access depends increasingly on the ability to comply with growing regulatory requirements. The European Commission is right to identify the problem. Europe needs to reduce its technology dependencies, strengthen its digital infrastructures, increase its computational capacity and develop more artificial intelligence on European territory. It also needs a solid and competitive open source ecosystem capable of sustaining a significant part of its technology autonomy.

However, there is a fundamental difference between building technology sovereignty and administering technology sovereignty. The first requires sustained investment in digital commons, stable funding for critical open source projects and mechanisms that allow communities to innovate without being trapped in regulatory burdens designed for much larger organizations. The second consists mainly of producing rules, certifications and compliance frameworks.

The European Technology Sovereignty Package devotes enormous attention to this second dimension. It defines strategies, sets objectives, creates new regulatory tools and designs oversight mechanisms. All of this may be necessary. But the decisive question is whether Europe will devote the same political, financial and institutional effort to strengthening the open foundations on which much of the digital economy rests.

Far from the offices of Brussels

Because true technology sovereignty does not depend solely on who owns the data centers, controls cloud infrastructures or manufactures the most advanced chips. It also depends on who maintains the code that makes the Internet work, protects communications, secures systems and allows new technologies to keep evolving.

And that code continues to be written, to a large extent, far from the offices of Brussels, thanks to the work of distributed communities that remain one of the most important and least understood strategic assets of the contemporary digital economy.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading