The United States Senate has postponed until September the vote on the CLARITY Act, the legislation with which Washington intends to establish a comprehensive federal framework for the cryptocurrency market. The delay coincides with particularly delicate political negotiations between Republicans and Democrats, who are trying to agree on new ethics rules to limit President Donald Trump's crypto businesses.
One of the proposals would require the president to divest from certain digital asset-related businesses, a move that, according to Bloomberg and Reuters, could allow him to defer for years the payment of millions of dollars in capital gains taxes.
CLARITY, to September
Approval of the CLARITY Act will have to wait until at least September. Senate Republican Majority Leader John Thune confirmed to The Block that the upper chamber will postpone until after the August recess the procedural vote needed to move the legislation forward.
The Senate begins this Friday, August 7, a recess of approximately one month, and lawmakers will return in mid-September. The calendar adds pressure to the bill, since few weeks will then remain before the November legislative elections absorb much of the political attention.
The negotiations of recent days show that there is still not enough agreement to guarantee the necessary votes. According to The Block, Democrats identify three major outstanding issues: ethics rules, measures against illicit finance and the text coming from the Senate Agriculture Committee.
If those three pieces can be resolved, then we can definitely see ourselves wanting to move forward, a Democratic Senate staffer told The Block. Of all of them, the ethics issue has become one of the main obstacles because it directly affects Trump's economic interests in the cryptocurrency industry.
Trum memecoin and World Liberty Financial
Those interests include the TRUMP memecoin and his family's businesses at World Liberty Financial. In this context, Senators Thom Tillis, Republican of North Carolina, and Ruben Gallego, Democrat of Arizona, sent the White House last week a new bipartisan proposal to try to unblock the negotiations.
According to Reuters, the ethics provision is still being negotiated between Congress and the White House, and one of its fundamental elements would be to require the president to divest from certain cryptocurrency-related businesses. The measure seeks to reduce conflicts of interest arising from Trump's economic involvement in an industry whose rules are being redefined by Congress and his own Administration.
The solution, however, could have an unexpected consequence. According to Bloomberg, a mandatory divestment could allow Trump to use tax mechanisms to defer the payment of capital gains taxes derived from those assets, with potential savings of millions of dollars. Reuters, in reporting on the CLARITY negotiations, also mentions this possible tax benefit.
Ethics rules
The economic dimension of the president's crypto interests helps explain why ethics rules have become one of the central issues in the negotiation. As reported by Observatorio Blockchain, Trump declared in June more than $1.4 billion in revenue from his family's cryptocurrency businesses during the previous year, a figure that shows the weight digital assets have acquired within the presidential family's businesses.
This link between political power and economic interests is precisely at the center of Democratic demands. Reuters notes that ethics rules are essential to securing the support of certain Democratic senators, who are calling for greater restrictions to prevent policymakers from personally benefiting from cryptocurrency-related businesses while taking part in drafting the rules that affect the sector.
State attorneys general
The ability to enforce those rules is another point of friction. Democrats demand that state attorneys general be able to act in the event of possible breaches of the ethics provisions, while the version previously backed by Trump reserved that power for the Department of Justice.
That proposal also prohibited certain public officials and their spouses from issuing or sponsoring digital assets, but did not extend the same restrictions to other members of their families. It also included a sunset clause that would have ended the restrictions in January 2029.
Democrats question both the scope and the duration of those limitations. According to a Democratic Senate staffer who spoke to The Block, the new rules should allow state attorneys general to act, include a divestment provision and eliminate the expiration date. The goal is for the ethics rules not to be designed exclusively for Trump's presidency, but to remain in force and be applicable to future presidents, vice presidents and lawmakers as well.
Insufficient ethics language
Trump, for his part, has not closed the door to accepting conflict-of-interest rules and has shown his willingness to incorporate some form of ethics language into the legislation. The disagreement is over its scope. Democrats consider the formula proposed so far insufficient because it does not extend the restrictions equally to other family members, leaves their enforcement in the hands of the Department of Justice and includes the January 2029 expiration date.
The negotiation, therefore, no longer revolves so much around the existence of ethics rules as around how far they should go, who will have the ability to enforce them and whether they should remain in force beyond the current presidential term.
Nor does the White House have the final say on the wording of CLARITY. As a Democratic Senate staffer explained to The Block, lawmakers do not need Trump's prior approval to incorporate into the bill the ethics rules they deem necessary. The president, however, would retain the ability to veto the legislation afterward.
Hence the difficult balance the negotiators are seeking: securing enough Democratic votes for CLARITY to advance in the Senate, maintaining Republican support and, at the same time, reaching wording that Trump is willing to sign.
DeFi, the other front
Ethics is not the only obstacle. According to The Block, Democrats also maintain significant reservations about the provisions aimed at combating illicit finance and about the tools the future regulation will provide to the authorities.
One of the most critical voices has been Democratic Senator Catherine Cortez Masto, who has repeatedly expressed concern that the bill does not provide enough instruments to law enforcement and consumer protection agencies. Added to these objections is the National Sheriffs' Association, which questions some of the exceptions contemplated in CLARITY regarding money laundering prevention, sanctions and customer identification requirements, according to The Block.
A key law for the crypto industry
The crypto industry rejects these criticisms and argues that some law enforcement organizations are misinterpreting how CLARITY would treat decentralized finance. Thus, despite the strong pressure exerted by the sector in recent days to speed up approval of CLARITY, political differences have ended up prevailing. As reported by Observatorio Blockchain, the industry's main companies and organizations have closed ranks around a law they consider key to obtaining greater legal certainty, attracting investment and facilitating the integration of digital assets into the US financial system.
The CLARITY Act aims to establish a defined federal framework for digital assets, delineate the powers of the different regulators and grant the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) greater authority over certain digital assets and markets.