Latest

DeFi

Staking and lending come onto MiCA's radar

AMLA and ESMA call for rules on staking, crypto lending and borrowing. The custody trick no longer washes, and the yield black boxes now have a date.

Staking and lending come onto MiCA's radar
Staking and lending come onto MiCA's radar

Crypto yield lives in a legal limbo and Brussels wants to pull it out of there. The European anti-money laundering authority, AMLA, published on October 7, 2026 its response to the consultation on the MiCA review and asks the Commission to consider regulating staking, lending and borrowing with cryptoassets as activities with risks of their own. Its text, dated September 30 like the other responses, joins that of the markets regulator ESMA of the same date, which details the information sheets it will require for each product, according to AMLA and the analysis by RegReportingDesk.

The shared diagnosis sounds forceful. MiCA does not regulate staking, lending or borrowing as independent activities, even though all three already move a substantial part of the market. Staking slips in sideways through the custody and administration authorization of Article 75, which covers safekeeping of the coins but not the risks of pooling assets, generating yield, temporarily ceding control or blocking customer access for periods. That partial coverage leaves out precisely what makes these products dangerous.

The key point is that two regulators with different mandates see the same hole. AMLA looks at money laundering and ESMA looks at the retail investor, though both describe black boxes where the customer hands over their coins in exchange for uncertain returns. Nothing changes for now, because these are recommendations to the Commission, which must report before June 30, 2027. But the map of where supervision will press is already drawn.

The hole that custody does not plug

You have to understand the legal trick that sustains half the market to gauge what is coming. An exchange with a custody license offers staking because it holds your coins, and the rule covers that safekeeping. So far, all in order. The problem starts when your coins enter a pool with those of thousands of customers, generate yield in protocols you never saw and come back labeled as a reward. None of that journey appears in the custody authorization.

AMLA describes the perverse incentive with a policeman's coldness. The current framework pushes operations to be channeled through unregulated lending wrappers, with exposure to high-risk jurisdictions and customers no one identifies or monitors. A staking or lending wrapper breaks the money trail, since assets enter a pool, earn yield and exit as apparently legitimate returns after circulating through protocols without identity controls. It does not claim that every product launders money, though it does say the design allows it without friction.

Related article: Crédit Agricole invests 100 million in a tokenized fund on Ethereum

Staking is not just holding coins

ESMA distinguishes four forms of staking and it is worth knowing them because future treatment will depend on the degree of intermediation, according to its official response. Self-directed staking without an intermediary would be left out, while technical staking, pooled staking with custody and liquid products with a yield token would come in with proportional duties. The more control the provider has over your assets, the more demanding the rule will be.

The risks listed by the markets regulator read like a manual for the victims. Rewards advertised without mentioning slashing for validator misconduct, lockups that prevent withdrawal in the middle of a crash, opaque validator selection and doubts about what happens to your coins if the provider goes bankrupt. Each of those points corresponds to a real loss that some European customer has already suffered in previous cycles.

What each regulator asks for on yield

The Banking Authority opened the way on September 24, 2026 by asking for a cost-benefit analysis of turning lending intermediation into an authorized service, including access to decentralized protocols from licensed applications, according to our coverage. ESMA set out the information sheets on September 30. It will require data on rewards, lockups and slashing, as well as validator selection and fees. Operational dependencies and treatment in the event of insolvency complete the list. AMLA closed on October 7 with the criminal lens and the call for dedicated requirements within the provider framework.

Product What ESMA requires What AMLA adds
Staking with custody Sheet with rewards, lockups, slashing and validators Its own requirements beyond custody
Lending Explicit written consent and breakdown of the destination Dedicated requirements in the CASP framework
Borrowing Sheet on collateral, liquidation and leverage Measures on access via providers

Lending gets the harshest treatment because it left the most visible bodies. ESMA describes yield programs as black boxes where the customer does not know who the final borrowers are, what collateral backs the loans and how much yield the platform keeps along the way. It calls for the customer's written and explicit consent before lending their coins, along with full information on destination and guarantees. The proposal does not create a new service with separate authorization, though it does create enforceable conduct duties.

Borrowing completes the triptych with its own mirage. Borrowing looks like a simple liquidity tool, though it exposes you to lightning liquidations, leverage and collateral volatility, with opaque reuse of guarantees. ESMA's response ranges from collateralized lending to chained rehypothecation setups.

The black boxes have a memory

After all, Europe already paid the tuition for this lesson in 2022. Celsius and BlockFi took in billions in deposits with yield promises and went bankrupt leaving customers in the creditors' queue, as we recalled in the EBA's request. The mechanism was the one regulators now describe, with coins lent without sufficient collateral, rehypothecated to third parties and returns partly retained by the platform. MiCA was born with that wound open and left lending for the review that now arrives.

The difference from back then is important. In 2022 there was no European cryptoasset framework and each country improvised its response. Today the provider perimeter has been closed since July 1, 2026, according to RegReportingDesk's roundup, and regulators are discussing the exact calibration of the duties, not whether there should be any. The debate matured from prohibition to design, and that benefits serious companies that already report well.

Pure technical staking fares better than packaged yield if one follows ESMA's letter. Validating blocks on a proof-of-stake network is a necessary technical function, and ESMA refuses to treat it automatically as investment management, according to its response. The magnifying glass points at whoever intermediates, pools or markets the yield, not at the protocol or the lone validator. That proportionality lets infrastructure breathe while squeezing the marketer.

The calendar that decides when the law changes

None of these requests changes the law for now, and the calendar matters as much as the content. The consultation closed on September 30, 2026 and the Commission must report before June 30, 2027, with a possible legislative proposal alongside. Then Parliament and Council will negotiate for years, because each requirement adds costs that states will want to calibrate.

Meanwhile, supervision does not wait sitting down. It is foreseeable that ESMA will ask about these products in authorization reviews long before any reform is approved. The written rule will take time, though scrutiny begins this autumn.

For the investor, the practical message is to look at the sheets before the percentage. A product that details its rewards, its lockups and its risks competes with an advantage over one that promises a round number without explaining anything. The European market already rewards transparency, and the regulation to come will only accelerate that selection.

Related article: The EBA calls for extending MiCA to lending and DeFi in 2026

What to watch until June 2027

We will have to wait for the Commission's report to know the text Brussels defends, and then comes the long negotiation between Parliament and Council. But companies can prepare this autumn without waiting for the law, because regulators have already said out loud where they will look. Anyone who has inventoried their yield products with their sheets and consents will have the documentation ready when the inspector asks.

The to-do list fits in an afternoon. Inventory each staking, lending or borrowing product with its backing authorization, the journey of assets outside custody and the identity of counterparties or protocols. Review each supported stablecoin with its authorized issuer and each access to protocols with its documented due diligence. If a page does not answer those questions, the prudent move is to fix the page or pause the product before a regulator asks.

Europe learned in 2022 that yield without information comes at a high price, and in 2026 it is preparing rules so as not to repeat the course. Staking and lending will not disappear from the European market, though they will stop being sold blind.

For the attentive saver, the rule to come is good news with a 2027 date. Comparing sheets instead of percentages is the habit that protects the retail investor, and Brussels is about to force platforms to make it easier. Whoever starts today will have an advantage when the rule takes effect.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading