Latest

Blockchain

Vitalik takes on the State over judging software developers

Vitalik defends the creator of Tornado Cash and warns of the risk that the State will criminalize developers for the use of their software

Vitalik takes on the State over judging software developers
Vitalik takes on the State over judging software developers

Vitalik Buterin, co-founder of Ethereum, has published a document on his X account in which he defends in extraordinary terms the developer Roman Storm, awaiting trial for his work in developing the privacy protocol Tornado Cash. The case has opened a debate in the technology world about the limits of criminal liability for software developers.

Tornado Cash is an open source software protocol based on smart contracts that allows private cryptocurrency transactions. Its developers do not control users' funds and cannot modify or stop the system once deployed. The non-custodial nature is key to Storm's defense.

 Vitalik, the State and software developers

In his document, Vitalik warns that Storm's prosecution could mark a turning point in the relationship between State power and software development. Storm, co-founder of the privacy protocol Tornado Cash, was arrested in August 2023 and was charged by the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York with conspiracy to commit money laundering, violating international sanctions and operating an unlicensed money transmitting business. The indictment alleges that the open source software he helped develop was used to channel more than one billion dollars in illicit transactions. Storm was accused of helping cybercriminals, such as the feared North Korean hacker group.

After a long trial, in August 2025 the jury found Storm guilty of the charge of unlicensed money transmission, punishable by up to five years in prison, but failed to reach agreement on the charges carrying penalties of up to 20 years. The Department of Justice has requested a retrial in 2026 on those charges.

In his statement, Vitalik recalls that Tornado Cash was developed, in part, as a result of a suggestion of his, and states that not supporting Storm would be dishonorable. For Buterin, the case raises a key underlying question. Whether software development can become a criminally prosecutable activity because of how third parties use it. In this sense, he argues that equating code with crime amounts to altering the traditional limits of legal liability.

Privacy and power in the digital age

Buterin argues that privacy is not a privilege or a technological eccentricity, but an elementary protection against the abuse of state and corporate power. He notes that the massive accumulation of personal financial, location or communications data is creating new forms of vulnerability, aggravated by recurring leaks of public and private databases.

From that perspective, he rejects the idea that privacy should be sacrificed in the name of security. In his view, accepting that the State has unlimited access to personal information does not eliminate risks, but rather displaces them and, in many cases, amplifies them.

The proceedings have generated a major mobilization among legal scholars, developers and companies, who warn that a conviction based on such an interpretation could have a chilling effect on innovation, by introducing legal uncertainty for those who develop open and decentralized tools.

Public letters

Storm has opened a website, where he requests public letters of support and donations to cover the costs of the legal proceedings. The initiative has drawn a broad response, with contributions exceeding several million dollars. Among them is the donation of 750,000 dollars in June 2025 by the Ethereum Foundation, which has turned the campaign into one of the sector's most significant mobilizations. The Foundation is defending a developer who has been charged over the use third parties have made of his software. In 2025, Storm 's cause raised 6,392,417 dollars.

For Buterin, the outcome of the Storm case will not affect only the world of cryptocurrencies. It will define, to a large extent, whether writing code will continue to be considered a legitimate and protected activity, or whether developers can be held criminally liable for consequences they do not control.

Covadonga Fernandez

Author

Covadonga Fernandez

Covadonga Fernández is founder and director of the newspaper Observatorio Blockchain. She has worked with various companies developing crypto/blockchain projects, such as Singular DTV, a Switzerland-based platform and a pioneer in decentralizing the film industry, which led her to take part in the 2019 San Sebastián Film Festival. That same year she also took part in the Bern International Film Innovation Festival (Switzerland), with a presentation on linguistic plurality in blockchain. In 2022 she took part in the Acción Cultural Española edition with an article on Metaverse and Culture. In 2017 she wrote the chapter on Blockchain and Journalism in the book: «Blockchain: The Industrial Revolution of the Internet», published by Grupo Planeta. A year earlier, in 2016, she created the first Meetup on Blockchain and Journalism. That same year she also created the Blockchain Media site, to track the decentralization process of the cultural and creative industries. In 2020 she co-organized an event on how blockchain could help the cultural and creative industries, where the money received from sponsors was tokenized and speakers received payment in NFT format. Before founding Blockchain Media and Observatorio Blockchain, Covadonga worked at Grupo Z and the newspaper ABC; she was communications director of the Madrid Chamber of Commerce, a journalism professor at Universidad Carlos III de Madrid and chair of Telemadrid. Winner in the Outreach category at the 2024 Financial Innovation Awards and honored by Alastria at the 2025 Blockchain Awards

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading