Covenant AI, a project focused on developing decentralized AI, announces its definitive exit from the Bittensor network. The decision comes after the publication of an extensive statement in which the team openly questions the protocol's supposed decentralization and denounces centralized control.
The project, responsible for developing Covenant-72B, a 72 billion parameter language model trained in a decentralized way by more than 70 contributors, said its exit responds to a fundamental conviction about the need for truly open infrastructures. According to the company, its work proved that decentralized training is viable at large scale.
Control over the network, the crux of the conflict between Covenant AI and Bittensor
In the statement, its founder, Sam Dare, directly accuses Bittensor's CRO, Jacob Steeves, of exercising effective control over the network. "When a single actor can suspend emissions, override operator decisions and use economic mechanisms to force compliance, that is not decentralization, it is centralized control with a decentralized narrative," Dare argues.
Covenant AI details a series of recent actions that, it claims, precipitated the break. Among them, the suspension of rewards in its subnets, the removal of moderation permissions in its own channels, the unilateral depreciation of its infrastructure and the use of TAO token sales as a pressure tool during operational conflicts. The company stresses that these decisions were not carried out through transparent processes or distributed consensus, but unilaterally.
Dare also questions Bittensor's governance structure, which he describes as a triumvirate in charge of network upgrades. According to Covenant AI, this system works as a facade, since real control would remain concentrated in a single figure. "The network constantly talks about decentralization, but power has never left the hands of one person," the document states, describing the model as decentralization theater.
Risks for investors
From the team's perspective, this situation compromises the project's long-term viability. Covenant AI maintains that it cannot continue operating on an infrastructure where the absence of central control does not match reality. It warns of risks for investors, developers and participants who depend on a system that, it denounces, can be altered at will.
Despite the break, Dare says he will continue working on the development of decentralized artificial intelligence and will soon announce new projects. As a result of the dispute, the price of the TAO token fell 16,87 % in the last 24 hours, trading at this hour at 269.25 dollars.
It is worth recalling that the arrival of Barry Silbert, CEO of Digital Currency Group (DCG), at the end of 2024, marked a turning point for the network. Through DCG, Silbert launched Yuma, an ambitious incubator designed to be the Consensys of Bittensor, providing capital and operational support to new subnets.
In fact, the engine that governs the entire network and decides which projects receive rewards is called Yuma Consensus (YC). By naming his company after the consensus algorithm, which is the brain that measures intelligence in the protocol, Silbert projected an image of central control over the mechanism that distributes value.