Luke Dashjr, one of Bitcoin's veteran developers, has been removed as editor of the BIPs (Bitcoin Improvement Proposals) after losing his permissions in the repository. Mark Erhardt proposed his removal and several Bitcoin developers publicly backed the initiative.
The decision comes in the midst of the crisis over BIP-110, the controversial proposal backed by Dashjr to introduce new restrictions on Bitcoin, whose attempt at activation through a soft fork failed to gather enough support. After that failure, the promoters of BIP-110 are studying pushing a hard fork that would change the proof-of-work (PoW) algorithm and give rise to a chain separate from the current Bitcoin network..
The removal came a few hours after Murch formally proposed removing Dashjr as BIP editor. The central accusation is that he would have used his editorial privileges in a manner incompatible with the established procedure during the processing of BIP-110, a proposal in whose creation and implementation he was directly involved.
Bitcoin governance
Bryan Bishop confirmed the change at the end of the intense discussion held among developers. The person known as Luke Dashjr is no longer a user with permissions in the BIP content repository, he wrote.
BIPs are the documents through which improvement proposals, standards and possible modifications related to Bitcoin are presented and described. BIP editors do not have the ability to unilaterally change Bitcoin's rules, but they occupy a position of trust in the management and organization of these proposals.
The conflict has taken on a dimension that goes far beyond BIP-110 and once again raises one of the most complex issues in Bitcoin governance. Namely, who grants and withdraws positions of trust when there is no company, board of directors or central authority governing the network. Bitcoin can function without a leadership able to unilaterally impose its decisions, but around its development there are responsibilities, permissions and structures that grant varying degrees of influence to certain people.