The administration of Donald Trump has taken sides in the copyright litigation with The New York Times and other rights holders. The United States Department of Justice (DOJ) has backed OpenAI's position in one of the battles that could decide who wins and who loses money in the new artificial intelligence economy.
The US government filed a Statement of Interest on September 1 before a federal court in New York arguing that the use of protected works to train artificial intelligence models may be covered by fair use under US law.
Copyright takes on a geopolitical dimension
According to Reuters, this appears to be the first intervention by the US government in the current wave of copyright lawsuits against artificial intelligence companies. The government's argument goes far beyond OpenAI, as the Department of Justice maintains that making it harder to train models through an overly restrictive interpretation of copyright could harm scientific progress, the economy and US national security.
The Trump administration believes the country needs a strong artificial intelligence industry to maintain its technological leadership against international competitors. Copyright thus takes on a geopolitical dimension. If US companies have to negotiate and pay licenses for the millions of pieces of content used to train their models, developing new AI will be more expensive and slower. For the Trump government, overly restrictive copyright rules could end up weakening the United States' position in the global race for AI.
They must pay
The government also warns that such a system could end up favoring Big Tech, which can afford enormous licensing costs, over smaller AI companies. The New York Times argues precisely the opposite. The newspaper sued OpenAI and Microsoft in December 2023, accusing them of using millions of protected articles without authorization to develop their technologies. The Times believes artificial intelligence and content creation can coexist, but argues that technology companies must compensate those who produce the content that contributes to the development of their products.
For years, search engines used media content, but they also sent readers to their pages. With generative artificial intelligence, a user can get an answer directly without necessarily visiting the website where the information was originally produced.
Small outlets, the hardest hit
The government's position raises a paradox. Trump argues that forcing AI companies to pay for content could benefit Big Tech, which is the one with the money to buy licenses. But if AI companies do not have to pay, small outlets will be the hardest hit. A newspaper like The New York Times can negotiate multimillion-dollar deals with tech companies or take them to court. A small outlet does not have the means to do so.