As every year, the ARCO Contemporary Art Fair arrived in Madrid. That is, a periodic exhibition of visual innovation where the very definition of art is called into question. Before some works of contemporary art, this reflection emerges forcefully. But, moreover, a true work of contemporary art is one that provokes such reflection, questioning the definition of art. Perhaps this is one of the fair's great attractions.
Possibly the difficulty of finding a definition of art lies in the fact that everyone has their own. Every time we come across a work previously labeled as art. And, for this, ARCO gives us many opportunities. A definition of art in each work of ARCO, in what catches the eye; but also in the talks held in the various forums.
Artificial intelligence and art
Last Wednesday, sponsored by the law firm Cuatrecasas, professor of law Rafael Sánchez Aristi introduced us to "The concepts of originality and authorship in works of art," which was the title of his lecture. Concepts that have been much stirred up since the shadow of artificial intelligence spread everywhere. Concepts that make something meet the minimum requirements to be considered a work of art. A work of art is something that has originality and that, in modernity since the invention of the printing press and publishing houses, has an author. Especially an author interested in defending their rights as such, in having their originality and creativity recognized. It is precisely the law that exists to defend such rights.
ARCO's arrow did not hit the relationship between AI and blockchain
The professor and partner in Cuatrecasas' intellectual property area warned that it is not always easy to determine what an original creation is. It has to do with precedents and with the moment of a society. Nor can it always be clear what an author is, especially when the creative work - or supposedly creative, depending on the case - is applied to previous works, to pre-existing material products.
Creativity and AI
For example, a photographic work made from a previous photograph. All of this, of course, points toward AI: can something made with AI be considered a work of art, something original? The answer to this question requires evaluating how one works concretely with AI. First, how the work is prepared or instructions are given to the AI. That is, at bottom, observing the originality of the prompt. Then, how the product or response is produced by the AI. Here, Sánchez Aristi acknowledged the darkest and most opaque part of the process. Finally, there is the possible creative work in post-production, in the work done on what the AI previously produced.
In short, creativity, so intrinsic to the definition of a work of art, is possible with AI. Moreover, it can stimulate such creativity. Possibly another kind of creativity, even another way of understanding creativity. But, ultimately, creativity and, therefore, a work of art. That is, an expressive form produced by creativity attributable to an author. And most importantly, worthy of being plagiarized, the point at which legal professionals step in.
In short, a work of art is that plagiarizable expressive form, even if it is made with AI and there is an author who appeals to the protection of their intellectual property rights when they consider themselves plagiarized. AI goes from being a great plagiarizing parasite to a tool that elevates authors. It elevates authors by plagiarizing them, since it is still a form of recognition, even though it frequently hides the authorship of the original works it feeds on. But it also elevates authors who use AI for their creative work. Two types of creativity. Pre-AI creativity and post-AI creativity.
Contemporary art pre- or without AI
Perhaps the time has come to establish a division in contemporary art. Contemporary art pre- or without AI, on the one hand, and contemporary art with AI. So when will we have the ARCOia fair, or a fair of contemporary artworks with AI? I hope that, when it is held and thanks to the intelligent presence of artificial intelligence, it will be easier to find the way from the parking lot to the entrance of the venue, physical or virtual, where the new ARCOia is held.