Latest

Artificial Intelligence

AI needs journalism, but it doesn't want to pay for it

Without journalism there is no AI, but the big platforms refuse to pay for the information they use to craft their answers

AI needs journalism, but it doesn't want to pay for it
AI needs journalism, but it doesn't want to pay for it

AI needs journalism, but it doesn't want to pay for it. Artificial intelligence (AI) is radically transforming the way citizens access information and poses one of the greatest challenges to the survival of quality, independent journalism. That is the argument of Argentine journalist Fernán Saguier in an article published in the Argentine newspaper La Nación, in which he analyzes the concerns expressed during the World Media Congress organized by the World Association of Newspapers (WAN).

The debate comes a few days after the publication of the first encyclical of Pope Leo XIV, entitled Magnifica Humanitas, and devoted precisely to the challenges posed by AI. According to Saguier, the pontiff warns that AI is not a neutral technology and that it can both foster justice and participation and deepen inequalities and social exclusion. 

AI, the third great digital revolution and the most serious

Saguier argues that the media are currently going through a third digital revolution. The first came with the Internet in the 1990s, when information began to circulate without borders. The second was led by smartphones and social media, which democratized the publishing and distribution of content. Now, artificial intelligence opens a new stage that the author considers more serious in scope.

The reason is that it gives platforms the ability to understand and generate answers on the spot, no longer as a tool, but as an all-terrain collaborator that resolves the user's need in a blink. AI thus becomes an intermediary capable of answering users' questions directly without them needing to visit the original sources.

As an example of this transformation, the journalist notes that ChatGPT receives 2.5 billion searches a day, reinventing the Internet user experience, which has shifted from browsing to delegating to bots an answer to all their demands.

The conflict over intellectual property

One of the main concerns of publishers is the use of journalistic content by the big technology companies without adequate compensation for the outlets that produce it. According to Saguier, companies such as OpenAI, Google, Microsoft or Meta have signed agreements with some international media, but most news organizations still receive no financial recognition for the use of their content.

During the congress, the publisher of The New York Times, Arthur Sulzberger, denounced that his company has been litigating in US courts for more than two years to prevent AI companies from using its content. Sulzberger acknowledged that he has already spent twenty million dollars on the litigation. A version impossible to verify is circulating in the corridors of this gathering: that the Times is demanding a sum close to 500 million dollars, Saguier writes.

Tomorrow, "International Day Against AI Scraping": For a human internet

To illustrate the problem of AI companies appropriating others' work, Sulzberger explained that last year the newspaper published a million stories that cost The New York Times 2 billion dollars. Who would subscribe to a newspaper when you can get the same answer from AI?, he said, with a blow to the lectern. "The annoyance is understandable: its distinctive journalism, rewarded by thirteen million digital subscribers, is being killed by crude plagiarism without consent or any compensation," Saguier writes.

A brazen theft of intellectual property without precedent

Sulzberger called things by their name and said that "Here there is a brazen theft of intellectual property without precedent." The director of the New York Times called for a collective awakening of the communications industry, and of newspapers in particular. He said that if journalism loses those resources there will be fewer journalists investigating, fact-checking and holding institutions and power to account.

"Investing in quality journalism is costly. It means reporting the facts from the place where they happen, that is, sending journalists to bear witness to events in situ, buying the rights to reproduce the best quality foreign press available, posting correspondents in the world's main capitals and hiring the local and international writers most valued by readers, among many other editorial commitments," Saguier says

The author explains that ChatGPT will never send a reporter to the war in Iran or to the invaded territory of Ukraine, it will not traipse the corridors of the courts to anticipate a judicial ruling, it will not take on the work, and the decision, of combing through hundreds of speeches by a political leader to detect contradictions, omissions, insults or simply lies, nor will it find in handwritten notebooks the notes that record a gigantic corruption scheme.

AI doesn't want to pay for journalism

According to the article's author, we face a paradox. AI desperately needs journalism. The problem is that it doesn't want to pay for it. And it does so because it can appropriate what belongs to others without penalty. 30 percent of AI's inputs are journalistic content. AI depends on journalism much more than journalism depends on AI, he writes.

As the author recounts, the ChatGPT representatives present on a panel barely said anything. "It was a hymn to irrelevance, an hour of words on the wind to dodge the widespread demand of an impatient audience: Will you extend your agreements to other outlets whose content you copy, or will you keep playing dumb?" The author reports that in Latin America, with the exception of Brazil, they have ignored the media of the nineteen countries that together total more than 600 million inhabitants.

Low-quality journalism

Beyond the economic debate, Saguier also warned about the quality of information. Bots too often give ambiguous, imprecise, if not incorrect, answers, because they also scan low-quality journalism, he said. Therefore, those who consume them take false truths as certain, which has a devastating effect on civic coexistence in democratic societies.

Saguier closes his article by quoting Hannah Arendt: "If everyone lies to you, the consequence will not be that you will believe the lies, but that no one will believe in anything."

Covadonga Fernandez

Author

Covadonga Fernandez

Covadonga Fernández is founder and director of the newspaper Observatorio Blockchain. She has worked with various companies developing crypto/blockchain projects, such as Singular DTV, a Switzerland-based platform and a pioneer in decentralizing the film industry, which led her to take part in the 2019 San Sebastián Film Festival. That same year she also took part in the Bern International Film Innovation Festival (Switzerland), with a presentation on linguistic plurality in blockchain. In 2022 she took part in the Acción Cultural Española edition with an article on Metaverse and Culture. In 2017 she wrote the chapter on Blockchain and Journalism in the book: «Blockchain: The Industrial Revolution of the Internet», published by Grupo Planeta. A year earlier, in 2016, she created the first Meetup on Blockchain and Journalism. That same year she also created the Blockchain Media site, to track the decentralization process of the cultural and creative industries. In 2020 she co-organized an event on how blockchain could help the cultural and creative industries, where the money received from sponsors was tokenized and speakers received payment in NFT format. Before founding Blockchain Media and Observatorio Blockchain, Covadonga worked at Grupo Z and the newspaper ABC; she was communications director of the Madrid Chamber of Commerce, a journalism professor at Universidad Carlos III de Madrid and chair of Telemadrid. Winner in the Outreach category at the 2024 Financial Innovation Awards and honored by Alastria at the 2025 Blockchain Awards

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading