Latest

Technology

Aragón has accumulated €70 billion in data centers and Google hits the brakes

Google suspends its campus in Spain pending the decree while Aragón has accumulated €70 billion in data centers and the CNMC calls for relaxing the 80% renewable requirement

Aragón has accumulated €70 billion in data centers and Google hits the brakes
Aragón has accumulated €70 billion in data centers and Google hits the brakes

Google has shelved its plans to expand computing capacity in Spain and, with them, an investment of billions that the company has never detailed. The slowdown, reported on October 20, comes as the draft royal decree that will regulate these facilities has drawn more than 600 comments and awaits the State Council's opinion, with the government determined to approve it before the November 29 elections. The project left in limbo is the most symbolic one: the Sol submarine cable landing station in Cantabria, on a 5,907-square-meter plot in the Science and Technology Park.

The standoff is not Google's alone. Aragón has accumulated $70 billion in data centers attracted by fast-track permits, and Amazon has committed €33.7 billion through 2035 according to its own fact sheet. That money depends on a text that requires covering 80% of electricity consumption with new renewables and proving it hour by hour, a requirement that the National Markets and Competition Commission, the CNMC, wants relaxed.

The industry association Spain DC estimates that 80% to 90% of new investment will go to another European country, and three multinationals have put at €9 billion what they would withdraw. On the other side, the Ebro Hydrographic Confederation plays down these facilities' water consumption and minister Jordi Hereu defends the rule so they do not take everyone's power and water. The outcome depends on a text that does not yet exist and on a power grid that is already lagging behind the projects.

Google is not giving up on Spain, it is just waiting

The Madrid cloud region opened in 2021 with a five-year, €650 million investment plan that included the Grace Hopper submarine cable, landed in Sopela (Biscay). Since then Google has operated there with servers hosted in third-party facilities, and that arrangement is not in question: what has been suspended is the expansion.

Sol will link Santander with Palm Coast, Florida, with stops in Bermuda and the Azores. For its landing station, the company bought from Sodercan a 5,907-square-meter plot in the Cantabria Science and Technology Park. Google Cloud declined to comment on the suspension and there is no official figure: only "billions."

The difference matters, because buying land for a cable station is not the same as building a server campus. The slowdown affects the latter, and the rest of Google's Spanish infrastructure remains where it was, with no new timetable.

The draft that requires renewables hour by hour

The text requires backing at least 80% of consumption with new-build renewable energy and certifying it hour by hour, with no annual or monthly offsets. Each new megawatt consumed requires another renewable megawatt installed in the previous 18 months, and the obligation holds until renewables exceed 90% of the national electricity mix.

Requirement What the draft sets What the CNMC asks for
Renewables 80% of consumption backed in every hour of the year Apply it only in hours without enough renewable power
Additionality 1 new MW for every MW consumed, 18-month window Extend the window and set a gradual path to 2030
Water and power Category A under the European labeling in both indicators Prioritize water consumption and relax the electricity requirement
Deadlines 6 months to adapt and 3 for those awaiting an access auction Gradual treatment depending on each project's status

Non-compliance has two tiers: first surcharges on tolls and charges, which the CNMC puts at between 10% and 500%, and then loss of the right to grid access and connection. Projects in process have six months to adapt or withdraw without forfeiting guarantees, and those awaiting an access auction, three.

Who says the money will go elsewhere?

The CNMC report, non-binding and approved in plenary on October 9, does not ask for the decree to be struck down: it asks for it to be modulated. It suggests excluding from the hourly calculation the hours with surpluses or with prices at or below €20 per megawatt hour, and extending an additionality window it considers too short.

The figure hanging over the debate is that of access permits, which stand at around 12 GW granted, triple the 4 GW that the AI Strategy set as a ceiling for 2030. Aragón and Madrid have formally requested a comprehensive review of the text.

Spain DC, an industry association of which Google is a member, goes further and says the framework jeopardizes 80% to 90% of new investment. Its executive director, Begoña Villacís, put it this way: "It will be built elsewhere and that is where digital services will be provided to Spanish companies and citizens."

It is worth noting that the association defends its members and that the figure comes from its own calculations. Its annual report puts cumulative direct and indirect investment through 2030 at €66.9 billion, so 80% is not a bill but a warning.

Aragón, from fast-track permits to bottleneck

Fast-track permits turned the region into a magnet for $70 billion. The Basilio Paraíso Foundation study, presented in September 2025, counted eleven projects with regional general-interest declarations, €47 billion and up to 2,548 MW, enough to make Aragón Europe's third hub after London and Frankfurt.

That volume explains the political reaction. Economy minister Eva Valle called the draft "especially harmful" and argued that "no data center in process can currently meet the requirements"; her government filed comments in September seeking a comprehensive review and warned of the risk of compensation claims.

The knot is not land or fiber but the grid, because the eleven projects would double the region's current electricity consumption. As happened with the Nscale and Microsoft data center in Essex, power arrives after the permit and decides whether the build goes ahead.

Water, neighbors and the jobs that do not yet exist

Water is the other front. The figures developers gave the Aragón government put consumption by those eleven centers at up to 14 cubic hectometers a year, more than 10% of the region's total consumption. The Ebro Hydrographic Confederation sees it as moderate and describes it as "just another industrial use," with no conflict with irrigation.

The tension is already being voted on. In Cuarte, a district of Huesca with 144 residents entitled to vote, 117 turned out for the first local consultation on a data center held in Aragón and 99.1% said no to Amazon's facility next to the Walqa technology park, on September 28.

The promised jobs are slow to arrive. The Basilio Paraíso study puts direct employment at between 3,150 and 4,500 once the centers are operating, with a similar number indirect, and an average of 21,000 construction jobs a year between 2026 and 2029. Amazon confirmed the €33.7 billion but avoided detailing how much employment it already offers in the region.

Finland has already taken €13 billion

The flight threat has concrete precedents. Google announced in September €13 billion over two years for AI infrastructure in Finland, its largest-ever investment in Europe, with secured supply and a nuclear plant included. The list continues with €5.5 billion through 2029 in Germany and €5 billion in Belgium, plus almost €4 billion in the Netherlands and a first Alpine center in Kronstorf (Austria).

Money is not lacking. Alphabet raised its investment forecast for this year to a range of $195 billion to $205 billion and Sundar Pichai admitted that AI demand exceeds its computing capacity. That demand is not abstract either: deals such as Santander and Nvidia's with AI specialized in banking push work toward machines that need firm power.

The question that decides the ending is not whether there is capital, but which jurisdiction gives it stable rules before the contract is signed. Today that answer is not in Madrid or Zaragoza: it is in Helsinki.

What Spain stands to lose before November 29

The government maintains there is room for agreement. The executive has opened the door to softening requirements if data centers do not raise electricity bills, and Hereu defended the rule in Zaragoza on October 21, citing "the protests that are starting in the streets."

With 600 comments on the table, a CNMC report calling for the requirements to be modulated and an Aragón government up in arms, the text that emerges from the Council of Ministers will decide which projects get built and which go to Finland. The investment Spain attracted with fast-track permits is already committed; the rules that keep it there are not yet.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading