While major European banks move forward with the Qivalis project to promote a euro-denominated stablecoin, the ECB president, Christine Lagarde, hardened her rhetoric against these digital assets this Friday and warned that private stablecoins can threaten European monetary sovereignty, weaken the transmission of monetary policy and reinforce the global hegemony of the dollar in the new tokenized economy.
Lagarde and stablecoins
Lagarde launched one of her harshest criticisms of stablecoins today, openly questioning the idea that Europe should respond to the US offensive by promoting euro-denominated stablecoins. During her speech at the "I LatAm Economic Forum", organized by Banco de España in Roda de Bará (Tarragona), Lagarde called for distinguishing between the technological and monetary functions of stablecoins.
The ECB president placed the growth of stablecoins among the most relevant financial phenomena of recent years. She recalled that the volume of stablecoins in circulation has gone from less than 10 billion dollars six years ago to more than 300 billion today. She also noted that nearly 90% of the market is controlled by Tether and Circle, whose main reference markets are in El Salvador and the United States.
Lagarde acknowledged that Europe was a pioneer in introducing a regulatory framework for this sector through MiCA, the European regulation on cryptoasset markets approved in 2024. However, she argued that the international context has changed radically following the political push in the United States through the GENIUS Act, legislation that, she noted, explicitly seeks to consolidate the global dominance of the dollar and reinforce international demand for US government debt.
Europe should not copy the US model
"The GENIUS Act has changed the terms of the debate and it is no longer about whether stablecoins should exist, but about whether different jurisdictions can afford to do without them," she said.
The core of Lagarde's speech revolved around the central idea that Europe should not rush to promote euro-denominated stablecoins simply as a geopolitical response to US advances.
As she explained, the current debate conflates two completely different dimensions. On the one hand, stablecoins perform a monetary function by facilitating global access to strong currencies such as the dollar outside traditional banking systems. On the other, they perform a technological function by acting as settlement instruments within infrastructures based on blockchain and distributed ledger technology (DLT).
Five Spanish banks join Qivalis to launch a euro stablecoin
For Lagarde, separating both functions is essential to avoid strategic mistakes. "Once we separate these two functions, the arguments in favor of promoting euro-denominated stablecoins become much less convincing than they appear," she said.
Criticism of the risks of stablecoins
The ECB president directly questioned the narrative according to which Europe risks digital dollarization if it does not develop its own stablecoins. In her view, the international strengthening of the euro should not be built on potentially unstable private instruments, but on more integrated capital markets, European safe assets and robust public infrastructure.
Although she acknowledged the innovative potential of blockchain technology and asset tokenization, Lagarde was especially critical of the structural risks of stablecoins.
She recalled that stablecoins are private liabilities whose stability depends on the quality and liquidity of the reserves backing them. When confidence disappears, mass redemptions can cause systemic stress. As an example, she cited the episode in March 2023 after the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank, when Circle revealed that 3.3 billion dollars of USDC reserves were deposited at that entity. At the time, USDC temporarily traded at 0.877 dollars. "At scale, this dynamic can transmit stress to the markets for the underlying assets," she said.
The ECB bets on central bank money and tokenized deposits
Lagarde also warned about the risks that stablecoins can create for the transmission of European monetary policy. As she explained, if bank deposits migrate en masse toward private non-bank stablecoins, the traditional financial system loses its capacity to channel credit to companies and households, weakening the effectiveness of ECB interest rate decisions.
In this sense, she argued that Europe's financial structure, far more dependent on banks than that of the United States, makes the eurozone especially sensitive to this type of transformation.
Despite her critical tone, Lagarde did not reject the technological innovation associated with blockchain. In fact, she devoted much of her speech to highlighting the potential of tokenization and DLT-based infrastructures to modernize European financial markets.
However, she insisted that the core of this new system should not rest on foreign private stablecoins, but on central bank money and interoperable solutions developed within the European framework.
The ECB president especially defended the role of tokenized deposits and the future European public infrastructure promoted by the Eurosystem. Among the projects mentioned, she highlighted Pontes, which will begin operating in September and will connect DLT platforms with TARGET, the ECB's settlement system.
She also referred to Appia, the European roadmap for building a tokenized and interoperable financial ecosystem before 2028.
"When central bank money is available natively onchain, and when tokenized deposits and euro instruments that comply with MiCAR can operate in the same interoperable environment, market participants will have no reason to rely by default on a foreign private substitute," she said.
Battle for monetary sovereignty
Lagarde's speech reflects growing fear in Europe that dollar-denominated stablecoins will become the new dominant financial infrastructure of the global digital economy. Currently, nearly 98% of stablecoins are tied to the US dollar, a situation that, as the ECB president herself acknowledged, could further reinforce the international hegemony of the US currency in the context of tokenized finance.
However, against those who argue that Europe must compete by replicating the US model, Lagarde proposed an alternative strategy based on building public infrastructures and preserving the singleness of the currency, that is, the principle according to which a monetary unit must be worth the same regardless of who issues it.
"Europe knows which port it is heading for. Our task is not to replicate instruments developed elsewhere, but to build the foundations and infrastructure that serve our objectives," she concluded.