Since May 2023, Local Traders, a Chilean platform for peer-to-peer cryptocurrency exchange (P2P), and the Chinese-origin crypto exchange Gate.io have been locked in a dispute over $400,000. It all began when Local Traders was the victim of a theft of cryptocurrencies worth 120 million Chilean pesos at the time. Today, that haul is equivalent to about $500,000.
After an investigation involving Chile's Policía de Investigaciones (PDI), the Eastern Metropolitan Regional Prosecutor's Office, one of the 19 regional prosecutor's offices of Chile's Public Prosecutor's Office, and the blockchain intelligence firm TRM Labs, the money was able to be located. The wallets used by the attackers were recorded on the blockchain and investigators were able to locate part of the assets in accounts linked to the exchanges Gate.io and Binance.
A year and a half after the incident, on November 18, 2024, Santiago de Chile's Eighth Guarantee Court authorized the seizure of the assets identified during the investigation, and on February 27, 2025, the same court ordered that those cryptoassets be transferred to the victim's wallet. Two months later, on April 28, 2025, prosecutor Alejandra Godoy again requested execution of the transfer and granted a five-day deadline to do so.
Binance did comply with the courts
According to Abdul Rehman, co-founder of Local Traders, the ruling became final for execution on August 21, 2025. The exchange Binance, also involved in the matter, complied with the courts' order and transferred approximately $100,000 of the funds identified during the investigation to Local Traders.
Ethereum price falls, but investors hold more ETH than ever
However, nearly $400,000 is still pending restitution because it remains at Gate.io. The platform rejects the accusations and maintains that it is not part of the Chilean criminal proceedings, that it has acted solely as a cooperating third party and that it has cooperated with the authorities throughout the investigation. It also denies having breached any legal obligation.
If part of the funds has been returned and there are final and enforceable court rulings, why is the conflict still open three years later? In Rehman's view, the answer has to do with the borders of the digital economy. Rehman tells Observatorio Blockchain that they have tried every possible avenue.
Local Traders' odyssey
"We hired lawyers in Lithuania, where Gate operates through Gate Global UAB. We submitted all the required documentation: court rulings, official translations and notarized certifications. This process alone cost us close to 15,000 euros. However, the Vilnius Court of Appeals rejected our request, arguing that Chile does not have an applicable cooperation treaty with Lithuania for this case. We then appealed to the Supreme Court, but the petition was also rejected," Rehman recounts.
After the Lithuania attempt, Local Traders acted in Dubai, where Gate operates through Gate Technology FZE. "We went to the local authorities and to the VARA regulator. The response we received was that the initiative had to come from the Chilean authorities and not from us as the affected company. For their part, the Chilean authorities told us that there were no direct cooperation mechanisms with the United Arab Emirates to move the procedure forward."
Faced with this situation, the Chilean company explored the United States route, but the response was that the competent jurisdiction for the case was Panama. They finally reached Panama, but the Panamanian authorities told them that the country does not have specific cryptocurrency legislation that would allow them to act in this matter.
Millions of dollars spent
Rehman tells this newspaper that after years of investigations, court rulings, international requests and tens of thousands of euros spent on legal proceedings, his company has still not recovered the funds that were stolen from Local Traders which, according to the investigations, remain under Gate.io's control.
Undoubtedly, the case takes on a greater dimension because Gate.io is not a marginal platform. In February 2022, Spain's National Securities Market Commission (CNMV) warned that the platform was not authorized to provide certain investment services regulated in the country. It was a routine warning at a time when much of the crypto industry operated in a still-blurred regulatory environment.
But the landscape has changed and today, Gate Technology Ltd is incorporated in Malta and holds authorization from the Malta Financial Services Authority ( MFSA ) to operate as a cryptoasset service provider under the European MiCA regulatory framework. Observatorio Blockchain contacted Gate.io's legal representatives to learn their version of the facts, but had received no response by the time this edition went to press.
Gate.io's reputation at stake
In other words, this is a company that is part of the new generation of regulated players in the European crypto ecosystem. For an industry that moves billions every day, $400,000 is a relatively small figure. The question that must therefore be asked is what trust is worth to Gate.io.
For years, the crypto sector has tried to convince regulators, banks, institutional investors and users that it can be part of the global financial system. It has sought licenses, supervision, legal recognition and has claimed legitimacy. But legitimacy is not built solely with regulator authorizations. Reputation is needed, and reputation takes years to build and barely a few days to call into question.
The question, therefore, is whether a global platform like Gate.io really wants to put its reputation on the line for $400,000. Especially when one of the other players involved in the investigation, Binance, has already returned the identified funds to Local Traders.
The case also highlights the problem of living in a borderless digital economy that still depends on legal systems built for a world that did have borders.