The United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) is preparing a plan B in the face of the blockage of CLARITY, the law that will regulate the crypto industry in the United States. Its chairman, Mike Selig, announced yesterday on his X account that he has ordered the agency's staff to study how to establish a regime for cryptoasset markets using the powers currently granted to it by U.S. legislation.
The CFTC's plan B to regulate crypto
If CLARITY continues to stall due to Democratic obstruction, the CFTC will use its existing powers to begin establishing a regime for cryptoasset markets, Selig said during the inaugural meeting of the CFTC's Innovation Advisory Committee in Washington.
The bill remains stalled in the Senate, where negotiations remain open on issues such as investor protection, financial stability and possible conflicts of interest related to the crypto businesses of Donald Trump and his family.
The CFTC chairman's warning comes after Trump again called on Congress to approve the law, designed to establish a clearer federal structure for the digital asset market and delimit the powers of the different regulators.
Leveraging the CFTC's powers
Selig's plan B involves leveraging the powers the CFTC already has. The regulator's chairman has ordered a study into creating a Designated Contract Market (DCM) category specifically adapted to cryptoassets.
According to Selig, both currently registered entities and unregistered cryptocurrency exchanges could eventually be designated by the CFTC as this new type of market. Platforms could offer cryptoasset trading with leverage or margin under specific rules and agency oversight. Selig had already raised in January the possibility of adapting the DCM framework to the crypto market.
The announcement now increases pressure on Congress, since if CLARITY does not move forward, the CFTC is willing to proceed with the regulatory tools it already has.
DeFi developers
The initiative also extends to decentralized finance. Selig has ordered the CFTC to contact developers of on-chain financial protocols to study ways to offer these protocols legally in the United States.
The CFTC chairman says he wants to establish protections for developers once and for all. The issue has been one of the main sources of legal uncertainty for DeFi in the United States, especially when determining when software development may become subject to obligations that apply to financial intermediaries.
How far the CFTC can go without CLARITY
Selig's announcement opens a scenario the industry has been contemplating for months. It is about how far crypto-friendly regulators can go if Congress fails to approve a new market structure. The CFTC and the SEC can use the powers already recognized by federal legislation to adopt rules, issue interpretations and modify certain supervisory criteria. However, their room for maneuver is not unlimited.
The difference is especially important in the spot market for cryptoassets that are not securities, such as bitcoin. Although the CFTC considers BTC a commodity and can pursue fraud and manipulation in its spot market, it currently does not have the same comprehensive regulatory authority over that spot market that it exercises over derivatives markets. CLARITY aims precisely to fill part of that gap and establish by law which assets and platforms fall under CFTC oversight.
There is also a difference in permanence. Rules adopted by regulators can be modified by future administrations and challenged in court. A federal law provides a more stable legal basis for establishing the division of powers between the SEC and the CFTC and defining market rules.
CLARITY remains a priority
Selig makes clear that his plan B does not mean abandoning CLARITY, which remains a priority. We are going to give CLARITY a breather for a vote, he said. If the Senate fails to reach an agreement and send a version of the bill to President Trump, he assured that he will order his staff to act quickly to propose the new rules.
CLARITY has already passed the House of Representatives and has since advanced in the Senate, but has not yet completed its passage. Political differences have so far prevented a final agreement.