Latest

Ethereum

Scroll becomes permissioned and moves its blockchain to Ethereum

Scroll proposes moving from an open network to a permissioned network for private AI, migrating SCR and USX to Ethereum and putting it to a vote before the end of the year.

Scroll becomes permissioned and moves its blockchain to Ethereum
Scroll becomes permissioned and moves its blockchain to Ethereum

Scroll was one of the layer twos competing to be the home of general-purpose applications. Its plan announced this week says something else: to become a permissioned network, specific to private artificial intelligence interactions, payments and verifiable rules. The summary was presented on the DAO's monthly call on October 29 and the formal proposal will come later, with the details of how access control will work and what it means for those who hold funds there.

The move has a logic that is better understood by looking at the product driving it. Compass is an iPhone app that gives access to language models, VPN and eSIM, with an API that routes requests to more than thirty models and a privacy layer built with zero-knowledge proofs. Scroll's network stops being the showcase and becomes the infrastructure that coordinates all of that.

For the ecosystem, the announcement is one more sign that the era of "everyone go build a general-purpose L2" is ending. Scroll is not closing: it is changing trades. And the change involves moving its two assets to Ethereum, reviewing user positions and opening a voting process that could redefine what the network is over the next two years.

Scroll's proposal

The proposal describes a transition from a permissionless network to a permissioned one, designed around three uses: private interactions with models, payments and verifiable rules. Instead of offering blocks to anyone who pays the fee, the network would move to admitting approved participants, with model providers and verifiers in explicit roles.

The rationale is product-driven, not ideological. If you sell private conversations and payments with a cryptographic proof layer, you need to know who operates the nodes that see that data. An open network forces you to trust strangers and complicates the privacy promise, so Scroll has decided that the promise matters more than openness.

The cost of that decision is measured in community. A permissioned network is still a blockchain for its users, but it stops being a space where anyone can deploy a validator, and that removes incentives for a part of the ecosystem that had been participating for three years. The DAO will have to vote on it, and it is not clear that the majority sees it as progress.

Compass, the app driving it all

Compass is the piece that explains everything else. The iOS app brings together access to models, a VPN and an eSIM, and its API routes requests to more than thirty language models. The trust layer, called CENO, uses zero-knowledge proofs to protect credentials and agent context, and USX provides the payment component.

In that scheme, Scroll is the coordination layer: it ensures that the agent's owner retains control over the rules and the data. It is not a network for deploying arbitrary contracts, but rather a registry where it is verified who can do what within a specific service. It is an architecture closer to enterprise infrastructure than to a playground for experiments.

The app already charges a subscription on iOS, with the Android version still pending according to the company itself. That detail matters because it turns the transition into a business decision with paying customers, not a laboratory experiment, and it explains the rush to have the assets on Ethereum before the product grows.

What happens with SCR and USX?

The two tokens have defined roles in the plan. SCR retains its governance and voting function, both over the network after the transition and over USX, and model providers and verifiers would have to deposit SCR as collateral to participate. USX, for its part, is proposed as the payment asset within Compass and as a yield-generating stablecoin.

The interesting detail is that SCR holders would govern USX's parameters, including how that yield is split among users, participants who deposit collateral and the protocol. It is an unusual design: governance of the payment currency rests with the owners of the network token, not those of the payment token.

Migrating both contracts to the Ethereum mainnet aims to preserve transparency and liquidity while the chain's function changes. With the assets on the layer one, a user can exit or enter without depending on the permissioned network, which reduces the risk of being trapped if the transition becomes complicated. For the DAO, that detail also works as insurance: if the vote fails or the schedule is delayed, the tokens still have a market where they can be traded.

Milestone Expected date What it entails
Deployment of SCR and USX on Ethereum Mid-November to December 2026 Liquidity and exit outside the network
Governance vote on the transition Before the end of 2026 The DAO decides whether the network closes
Full transition Second quarter of 2027 The permissioned network replaces the open one

Users with funds have work to do

The least glamorous part of the plan is the one that affects anyone with positions in Scroll. The company is preparing a site, positions.scroll.io, so that each user can review what they hold and move or withdraw it during the transition. The DAO's own documentation warns that decentralized finance positions will need a separate plan, because they do not migrate on their own.

That warning is the alarm signal for anyone with funds in protocols built on Scroll. Those protocols' contracts do not move to Ethereum by decree: if the team behind each one does not publish its plan, the user's position stays on a network that is changing its rules. Reviewing and exiting in time remains the cheapest option.

There is also a scheduling lesson. Between the vote and the full transition there are months, and during that period the network lives with two narratives: that of an open L2 that still works as always and that of a permissioned network that is about to arrive. Users who ignore the process will discover the change once it is already done.

An L2 that stops being an L2

What makes the Scroll case interesting is that it breaks an expectation the sector took as fixed. Layer twos were born as cheap extensions of Ethereum for general-purpose applications, and their success was measured in transactions and total value locked. Scroll is proposing to measure it in revenue from a subscription product and in verifiable privacy.

If the plan goes ahead, the ecosystem will have an uncomfortable precedent: a network that stopped competing to be the most open in order to compete to be the most useful to a specific service. Other teams with their own products could follow the same path, and the idea of a neutral layer two is starting to look like a stage, not a destination.

For the user, the practical question is simple and still has no good answer: if you hold SCR or USX, what happens to their liquidity in the interim period, and who guarantees the redemption if the transition is delayed? The DAO should answer that before voting, and it is worth reading the full proposal when it arrives instead of settling for the call summary.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading