Stani Kulechov, founder of Aave; Joseph Chalom, CEO of SharpLink, a company with a significant ETH treasury; and investor William Mougayar oppose EIP-8363, a proposal aimed at reducing ETH issuance linked to staking. All three question whether cutting rewards is the right way to improve Ethereum's economy and argue that the network should focus on increasing demand, activity and its competitiveness.
Industry against the Ethereum staking cut
The EIP-8363 proposal has become one of the most controversial debates in the Ethereum ecosystem. The initiative, called Tapered Issuance Burn, proposes gradually reducing the ETH issuance linked to the rewards validators receive for participating in the network's consensus mechanism.
The possibility of reducing those rewards has prompted a reaction from Kulechov, Chalom and William Mougayar, who have publicly expressed their opposition and question both the economic consequences of the measure and the priorities shaping Ethereum's development.
All three warn that reducing staking yields could harm DeFi and particularly affect smaller validators. They also fear that thinner margins will end up favoring large operators, who are better able to exploit economies of scale.
The founder of Aave says EIP-8363 could go down in history as one of the most resisted Ethereum proposals of all time, perhaps surpassed only by ProgPoW, he claims. Kulechov also questions Ethereum's priorities and directs his criticism at the Ethereum Foundation, which he accuses of maintaining an overly academic vision far removed from those building applications and businesses on the network. What people really want is for Ethereum to focus on solving problems that drive real demand and make the network more competitive, he argues.
SharpLink: EIP-8363 comes at the wrong time
The founder of Aave accuses the Foundation of acting from an ivory tower, disconnected from the trenches where developers build on Ethereum every day. His criticism thus moves the discussion beyond monetary policy. For Kulechov, the priority should be generating demand, attracting activity and improving Ethereum's competitiveness.
Rhett Shipp, founder of the Avant protocol, has also questioned devoting resources to this type of initiative when, in his view, there are more urgent problems to solve.
For his part, the CEO of SharpLink says EIP-8363 is the wrong proposal at exactly the wrong time. SharpLink believes that reducing rewards could harm DeFi, drive capital out of Ethereum and weaken one of the features that sets ETH apart from bitcoin: its ability to generate yields natively. According to Chalom, Ethereum currently pays validators a variable yield of approximately 2.75% through newly created ETH. EIP-8363 would gradually reduce that issuance over roughly a year and a half, burning a growing share of the rewards as the amount of ETH deposited in staking increased.
Impact on DeFi
In the scenario described by the executive, when staking approached half of the ETH supply, the issuance allocated to validators could be reduced to zero. They would then depend on other income, such as transaction tips, which according to Chalom currently account for around 15% of staking yields.
For Chalom, one of the main risks lies in DeFi. The executive recalls that decentralized finance was born on Ethereum and believes it will be the destination for much of the stablecoins and tokenized assets that financial institutions are bringing to blockchain. Harming DeFi is harming the destination of everything institutions are bringing onchain, he argues.
Chalom believes that staking yield, once costs and inflation are discounted, effectively works as a base interest rate within the Ethereum economy. He particularly highlights the role of liquid staking tokens (LSTs), which he puts at approximately USD 35 billion in total value locked and which are an important part of onchain lending markets.
LSTs allow holders to maintain exposure to staking yield while using those assets as collateral in DeFi applications. In this way, the same capital can contribute to Ethereum's security and continue participating in its financial economy.
Risk for small validators
Chalom fears that reducing rewards will break that balance. Once operating and liquidity costs and slashing risk are included, he argues that the real yield could approach zero or even turn negative. This could push part of the collateral toward higher-yielding assets and reduce liquidity in lending markets.
SharpLink also warns that a significant reduction in yield could particularly affect small and medium-sized operators. According to Chalom, with yields close to zero, those most likely to remain would be operators with lower capital costs and greater economies of scale. Solo stakers and mid-sized operators, who bear real infrastructure costs, could be the first to leave.
Mougayar shares this diagnosis. If the goal of EIP-8363 is to limit the growth of staking, he believes that pushing its yield to near-zero levels means using the wrong tool. You're solving centralization by accelerating it. A double-edged sword cuts both ways, he argues.
The investor also does not believe that ETH inflation justifies an aggressive reduction in rewards. By his calculations, once the burn is discounted, annual inflation is below 0.5%, so he considers Ethereum's monetary policy already conservative enough.
Staking as a source of funding
Mougayar also introduces the argument of staking rewards as a source of funding for the ecosystem. In his view, reducing them when the Ethereum Foundation is scaling back its role as a funder could weaken a mechanism whose importance has not been sufficiently valued.
Chalom makes a similar case. He argues that the issuance allocated to validators should not be seen simply as a cost to Ethereum because much of those resources remain within the ecosystem. The rewards fund node operators and infrastructure companies and can also feed funds, treasuries, developers and new projects, he says.
Chalom uses SharpLink as an example. He explains that the company's ETH does not sit idle on its balance sheet. The company works with validation providers such as Coinbase, Anchorage, Figment and Galaxy Digital and also deploys capital in initiatives linked to ether.fi, Linea and EigenCloud.
For the executive, staking rewards can thus return to Ethereum in the form of investment and funding. He therefore argues that EIP-8363 would not shift that value elsewhere in the ecosystem, but would reduce the capital available to keep feeding it. He even warns that some institutions might withdraw their ETH from staking and sell it if the yield stops being attractive.
ETH as an advantage over bitcoin
The CEO of SharpLink recalls that for certain investors, Ethereum's ability to generate yield natively has helped attract capital to ETH. Reducing yield would, in his view, weaken a competitive advantage precisely when institutional interest in Ethereum is growing.
Hence he also questions the timing chosen to change the model. Chalom puts the stablecoins settled on Ethereum at approximately USD 159 billion and tokenized real-world assets at more than USD 15 billion. He also cites as signs of institutional interest Robinhood's new chain, built on an Ethereum Layer 2, BlackRock's tokenization and the addition of staking to BNY's institutional custody services through a collaboration with Galaxy Digital.
More applications, users and activity
For Chalom, these moves show that major institutions have ended up choosing Ethereum after years of assessing its stability. Mougayar also considers the change ill-timed, though for different reasons. In his analysis he takes a reference price of approximately USD 1,900 per ETH and argues that reducing yield under those conditions would add pressure on validators. By contrast, he poses a hypothetical scenario with ETH between USD 6,000 and USD 8,000, a range he considers closer to its intrinsic value, and annual appreciation of 20%-30%.
The investor also warns of the risks of applying the cut in an unfavorable macroeconomic environment. If interest rates remain high, appetite for risk declines and institutional demand falls, an exit of staking participants could generate selling pressure precisely when the market had less capacity to absorb it.
Mougayar does not reject any change to Ethereum's monetary policy. What he questions is the tool chosen, and he says that before reducing staking rewards, changes related to the fee architecture and the EIP-1559 burn should be studied. The sacred staking yield should be the last lever pulled, not the first, he says.
Growing the Ethereum economy
He also advocates gradual adjustments. As an example, he proposes a reduction from 0.8% to 0.7%, tied to the evolution of the staking ratio, instead of going directly from 0.8% to 0.5%.
Mougayar also agrees with Kulechov that Ethereum's future lies in having more apps, more users and more usage. If the network manages to grow its economy, he believes the discussion about reducing issuance will lose much of its importance.
The EIP-8363 proposal was presented in early August by researchers and collaborators from the Ethereum ecosystem and discussed on August 6 at All Core Devs Consensus. The initiative has not been approved and there is currently no expected date for its implementation.