Latest

Cybersecurity

Privacy is dead, the security of your data depends on you

Mass leaks, surveillance and age verification show why protecting your data, your privacy and security depends on you

Privacy is dead, the security of your data depends on you
Privacy is dead, the security of your data depends on you

Seven and a half years ago, Professor Jason Hong explained why privacy is so hard and proposed treating it like spam. Since then we have added almost 2.7 billion records leaked by a single broker, ID-based age verification in the United Kingdom and a regulation that allows your messages to be scanned. He was right about the diagnosis, but he fell short on the prognosis.

In my case, I defend an uncomfortable thesis. Privacy is not hard by accident, nor because users are careless. Instead, it is hard because the game is rigged. Companies and governments take a cut of the same surplus, your data, and you play with a marked deck. Even so, giving up would be a mistake. There are ways to defend yourself today and battles to win tomorrow.

What Hong saw in 2019 and still holds true

Hong, a researcher at Carnegie Mellon, published in the ACM eleven reasons why privacy resists. Some sound prophetic today. Technology captures more data than ever, companies' incentives push toward unchecked collection, the burden falls on an saturated user and AI models make it unpredictable what can be inferred from every crumb.

His flagship proposal deserves to be rescued. In the early 2000s spam flooded email, and the problem was not solved by asking each user to filter better. It was solved by providers blocking senders, the DKIM and SPF standards, automatic filters and police dismantling botnets. Hong asked whether we could do the same with privacy. Shift the burden from the individual to the system.

The answer, seven years later, is that we did exactly the opposite. We loaded more weight onto your shoulders and loosened the system's screws. Spam was tamed, but privacy was not.

Companies squeeze you

Actively, the business is direct. More data means better advertising models, and every click point translates into millions. Ad networks share your profile with dozens of intermediaries in a tangle that no legal notice manages to explain. You accept a cookie banner and your history travels halfway across the internet before coffee.

The extreme case has a name and a date. National Public Data, a Florida broker nobody had heard of, accumulated names, addresses and Social Security numbers of hundreds of millions of people. It suffered an intrusion in December 2023, the data circulated in April and summer 2024, and in August of that year the leak was confirmed of almost 2.7 billion records in plain text, according to BleepingComputer documented. You were never its customer. Your data was there all the same.

Blockchain, an opportunity for users to preserve or exploit their privacy

Passively, the strategy is attrition. Privacy settings buried in fifth submenus, options that reactivate themselves with every update, policies nobody reads because reading them all would take weeks a year. Hong already calculated then that reviewing every privacy policy would require about 25 full days annually. Since then the texts have only grown.

Governments protect and surveil at the same time

Here my skepticism is split. Governments legislate in your favor with one hand and cut back with the other, and it is worth looking at both without naivety.

The cutting hand acts first in the name of security. The European Union has kept in force since July 31, 2026, barely six weeks ago, Regulation 2026/1881, which allows providers to scan private messages in unencrypted services. End-to-end encryption is excluded by law, and scanning is voluntary, not mandatory. So far, nuances that honor those who negotiated.

But the permanent negotiation, the so-called Chat Control 2.0, is still on the table. The fifth trilogue collapsed on June 29, 2026, the next round comes on September 29, in fifteen days, and Germany holds the key to the agreement. What is decided there will set for years who can order your communications scrutinized and under what conditions. As Euronews explains, if scanning reaches encryption it will have to be done on your own device, before the message is sealed. Your phone looking over your shoulder.

The United Kingdom already shows the second act. Since July 25, 2025, fourteen months ago, the Online Safety Act requires robust age verification, with a selfie or ID document, to access certain content. The result was told by the BBC. Five million extra verifications a day, according to the sector, and VPNs topping the App Store, with Proton registering 1,800% more sign-ups. When the State asks for your face to let you through, people vote with their feet.

The protecting hand exists, I don't deny it. The European GDPR has been biting for years with million-dollar fines and has inspired laws across half the world. But punishing after the damage does not return the leaked data, and the underlying asymmetry persists.

The State holds your data in public records that brokers and hackers then scrape and resell. That is the passive government channel, less visible and perhaps more harmful.

Not everything is getting worse

An opinion piece that only piles up defeats lies by omission. End-to-end encryption, marginal a decade ago, is today the default mode of billions of conversations on WhatsApp, Signal or iMessage. That the current Chat Control excludes encryption by law is a victory that took years of citizen and technical pressure. It must be noted.

Even so, every defensive victory confirms the thesis. None of this was won by users adjusting preferences. It was won by engineers encrypting by default, organizations like the EFF litigating and journalists exposing abuses. Progress comes when the burden moves from the individual to the system, just as Hong asked with his spam analogy.

Progress exists, but it is never born in your settings. The difference matters, because I am not telling you that your gestures don't matter, but that they are not enough.

Privacy is not dead, but it must be fought for

I withdraw the headline halfway. Privacy is not dead. It is in the ICU, connected to machines others control, and its prognosis depends on whether we accept that caring for it is only an individual task. Hong was right in the essentials. This is not fixed with more options, more notices and more tools for each person to defend themselves alone. It is fixed by changing incentives, encrypting by default and putting the burden where it belongs. On the companies that design, the governments that legislate and the systems that filter for you.

You can start tonight by reviewing two settings, but don't accept that this is all that is up to you.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading