Michael Saylor, executive chairman of Strategy, says the main risk to Bitcoin no longer comes from governments or regulators, but from factions seeking to modify the network's consensus rules. His remarks come amid the debate over the BIP-110 proposal, which would change the rules governing data use in transactions.
Bitcoin has won. Now it must survive the victory. With this phrase, Michael Saylor opens an extensive argument from his X account in defense of the immutability of the Bitcoin protocol. The businessman argues that the biggest threat to the cryptocurrency no longer comes from outside, but from corruption from within. From groups that, he denounces, seek to rewrite the consensus rules to impose their own interests.
Although the businessman expressly mentions BIP-110, he extends his criticism to other proposals debated in recent years, such as the incorporation of covenants or a possible increase in block size. In his view, all of them propose modifying Bitcoin's fundamental rules to respond to specific interests.
BIP-110 reopens the debate on Bitcoin governance
Saylor's remarks come amid the discussion over BIP-110, a proposal driven mainly by developer Luke Dashjr that would modify certain consensus rules related to data use in Bitcoin transactions.
According to the text of the proposal, the aim is to set time limits on data storage within transactions to restrict uses its promoters consider alien to the network's monetary function. Its supporters argue that the initiative seeks to protect Bitcoin from the mass storage of non-financial data, while its critics believe it would introduce new restrictions on transactions that are currently valid, opening a debate on the neutrality of the protocol.
In recent weeks, the discussion has moved beyond the strictly technical sphere and has become a broader debate on Bitcoin governance and the role certain developers can play in the evolution of the protocol.
The constitution of Bitcoin
Without going into the technical details of BIP-110, Saylor offers a much broader reflection on how Bitcoin works. In his view, consensus rules constitute the true constitution of the network, since they determine asset ownership, guarantee bitcoin's scarcity and allow millions of participants to share the same validation system without the need for a central authority.
Bitcoin's consensus rules are its constitution. They define ownership, scarcity, settlement and power. Rewriting them for the convenience of any faction is an attack on the economic rights of every participant today and of every future generation, he stated. From that perspective, he believes the debate should not focus solely on the specific content of BIP-110, but on the precedent that modifying the protocol's fundamental rules to solve short-term problems could set.
The fear of a capture of consensus
One of the businessman's main arguments is that Bitcoin would lose an essential part of its strength if consensus rules began to be modified to respond to the interests of different groups. Once a faction captures consensus, all factions learn that they can achieve through politics what they could not win in the market. The protocol war becomes permanent, he writes
According to Saylor, that dynamic would progressively erode trust in the network, reduce investment and ultimately weaken Bitcoin's security.
In that context, he also rejects proposals that, in his view, could alter the economics of the protocol, such as limiting certain transactions, incorporating new features directly into the base layer or increasing block size. Although these are initiatives with different objectives, he believes they all share the same risk: altering the consensus that has remained stable for more than fifteen years.
Two different views of Bitcoin
Saylor's remarks reflect the growing tension between two visions of Bitcoin's future. On the one hand, some developers advocate introducing improvements to the protocol to respond to new uses and technical challenges. On the other, the more conservative sector argues that Bitcoin's main strength lies precisely in the stability of its rules and the difficulty of modifying them.
Since Satoshi Nakamoto's disappearance in 2010, Bitcoin has operated without a formal authority capable of imposing changes. Any modification of the protocol requires broad consensus among developers, node operators, miners, companies and users.
For this reason, Saylor believes the debate opened by BIP-110 goes far beyond a specific proposal. In his view, what is at stake is preserving the principle that has defined Bitcoin since its origins: being a neutral protocol whose rules change only exceptionally and with extraordinarily broad consensus.
Changes to the protocol must be rare, conservative and driven by necessity, not ambition. Defend Bitcoin's constitution. Defend the future. he concludes.