Latest

Artificial Intelligence

OpenAI will have to pay damages for using protected songs

OpenAI is ordered in Germany to pay for using protected lyrics without a license, in a landmark ruling that redefines AI in Europe

OpenAI will have to pay damages for using protected songs
OpenAI will have to pay damages for using protected songs

OpenAI has been ordered to pay damages for the unauthorized use of protected song lyrics, following a landmark ruling issued on November 11, 2025 by the Munich Regional Court. The ruling, in favor of GEMA, an entity representing more than 90,000 authors and music publishers in Germany, marks a turning point in the regulation of AI in Europe.

The court ruling establishes that the company must stop reproducing the lyrics in dispute within German territory, in addition to facing damages whose amount has yet to be determined. This ruling represents one of the first major legal setbacks for an AI company over copyright on the continent.

OpenAI used protected lyrics

The case originated from a lawsuit filed by GEMA, in which the organization accused OpenAI of having used protected lyrics to train its models without holding licenses or financially compensating rights holders. During the proceedings, GEMA managed to demonstrate that the system could reproduce extensive fragments, and even complete lyrics, of well-known songs through simple prompts.

In its defense, OpenAI argued that its models do not store texts literally, but rather learn statistical patterns from large datasets. It also maintained that responsibility for any possible infringement would fall on the user making the query, and that its activity would be covered by the European Text and Data Mining (TDM) exceptions.

However, the court rejected these arguments on key points, considering that the system's ability to reproduce complete lyrics evidences the technical reproduction of the content, which implies that the works were, in a sense, memorized. It also concluded that the data mining exceptions do not apply when the final output can compete with the original works and affect the economic interests of authors.

The ruling drives new litigation

The ruling also stresses that OpenAI is liable as the provider of the system, regardless of user involvement. This criterion reinforces technology companies' obligation to control the operation and outputs of their tools.

Less traffic, more AI: how the media business is changing, according to KPMG

The impact of the ruling has driven new litigation, such as the case between GEMA and Suno AI, a music generator, whose verdict is expected in June 2026. It has also accelerated negotiations between artificial intelligence companies and collective management organizations in Europe, given the risk of restrictions or blocks in various markets.

Experts consider that this decision marks the beginning of a new stage in the relationship between artificial intelligence and copyright, in which the need for licensing agreements and clear regulatory frameworks will become increasingly urgent.

Alfredo Collosa

Author

Alfredo Collosa

Alfredo Collosa is a tax specialist. Public accountant. Bachelor's degree in Business Administration. Official Master's in Public Finance and Tax Administration from UNED/IEF in Spain. AMLCA Anti-Money Laundering Certificate (Florida University, US) and member of MetaLaw

The latest
From Huang to Botín, from Zara to Byron: corporate responsibility in global capitalism

Keep reading