UNESCO has established that artificial intelligence (AI) must not replace human judicial reasoning, but be used only as a support tool under strict oversight.
The organization published the document "Guidelines for the Use of AI Systems in Courts and Tribunals", drawn up from global consultations with multiple actors in the judicial field. More than 36,000 professionals from over 160 countries took part in its development, which made it possible to integrate different legal traditions, technological levels and social needs, as well as to raise awareness of the benefits and risks of these technologies.
Ethical and legal challenges
At a time when AI is taking on an increasingly relevant role in courts, UNESCO warns that current decisions on its implementation will shape the administration of justice over the coming decades. The Guidelines are therefore presented as a key framework for guiding its responsible integration into judicial systems worldwide.
Your salary is the target: algorithms wait for you to get paid before sending you "offers"
The document acknowledges that artificial intelligence can improve access to justice, speed up case management and support judicial decision-making. However, it also stresses that its use poses significant ethical, legal and human rights challenges. To address them, it sets out fifteen fundamental principles to guide its adoption and oversight, among them the protection of human rights, transparency, accountability, human oversight and the reliability of systems.
The Guidelines insist that AI must be a complementary tool, never a substitute. Its role is to facilitate access to information and improve the efficiency of the judicial system, but always under human control and with constant ethical review. The aim is to ensure that technology contributes to fairer justice without compromising the fundamental principles of law.
Risks of inappropriate use
The document also warns of the risks of inappropriate use. Faulty or misused systems can violate rights such as a fair trial, due process, privacy or equality before the law, as well as affecting essential values such as impartiality and judicial independence. It therefore stresses the need to prevent harm and avoid possible human rights violations.
UNESCO also stresses that the effective implementation of AI in the judicial field requires adequate staff training and reliable, accessible tools that respect fundamental rights. Adopting rules is not enough; professionals must be prepared for the ethical and responsible use of these technologies.
Finally, the document warns that tools such as language models can produce apparently coherent but incorrect answers, since they operate on probabilistic bases and do not understand real legal meaning. This makes prudent use necessary, especially by people without legal training. UNESCO concludes that artificial intelligence should serve to improve justice, but never to replace human judgment, which remains essential to guaranteeing the rule of law.