Latest

Finance

VanEck breaks with Gemini and moves custody of its ETFs to Coinbase

VanEck terminates Gemini's custody and compensation for its bitcoin, ether and Solana ETFs from February 16, 2027, and moves to Coinbase.

Translated from Spanish by an automated system. The Spanish original prevails. Read the Spanish original

VanEck breaks with Gemini and moves custody of its ETFs to Coinbase
VanEck breaks with Gemini and moves custody of its ETFs to Coinbase

On November 16, VanEck sent Gemini a written notice to terminate the custody and compensation agreements for three of its US exchange-traded funds: the bitcoin, ether and Solana funds. The termination was made public on Thursday the 19th in three 8-K forms signed that day, and will take effect around February 16, 2027. Gemini will continue providing the service until then.

The move leaves Coinbase Custody as the current custodian of the three products, which trade under the tickers HODL, ETHV and VSOL. It is a change of provider, not a withdrawal of funds or a warning about the assets, and here it is worth not confusing the size of the headline with the size of the event. What matters is that a sponsor with almost three years of track record in crypto ETFs is changing custodian in three funds at once, with three months' notice.

The third fund adds a nuance the first two do not have. Terminating the Solana ETF agreement also ends the annex covering staking, that is, locking up the fund's tokens to help operate the network in exchange for rewards. The filing does not explain what happens to that yield or whether the fund will keep it with another provider, and that is one of the questions left open.

Three funds, one notice and one date

The administrative sequence is simple and worth keeping in order because it sets the deadlines. The notice went out on November 16, the 8-Ks were signed on Thursday the 19th and the termination will take effect around February 16, 2027. That three-month window is the standard in these contracts and leaves room to migrate processes without interrupting the fund's operations.

Fund Ticker Outgoing custodian Current custodian Effect
VanEck Bitcoin ETF HODL Gemini Coinbase Custody From February 16, 2027
VanEck Ethereum ETF ETHV Gemini Coinbase Custody From February 16, 2027
VanEck Solana ETF VSOL Gemini Coinbase Custody From February 16, 2027, with the end of the staking annex

The size figure that helps put the matter in perspective is in HODL's quarterly report: as of September 30 the fund held about 14,726 BTC, valued at 1.23 billion dollars. The 8-K does not say how much of that bitcoin was in Gemini's hands, and that omission matters because Gemini was listed as HODL's primary bitcoin custodian, with Coinbase Custody listed as an additional custodian.

What does changing custodian in an ETF mean?

In a traditional investment fund, the custodian is a piece of infrastructure that rarely makes the news. In a spot crypto ETF, the custodian holds the keys that move the assets, and that is why its identity is material for the investor: if something fails, the fund depends on the custodian responding with the same solvency and the same controls as a depositary bank.

The industry itself has been flagging concentration risk for years. A handful of specialized custodians serves most spot ETFs, and that concentration creates a single point of failure that no prospectus fully resolves.

That pattern already has a track record in the Spanish market. Custody concentration is the hidden risk of crypto ETFs, and the VanEck case merely makes it visible in a specific contract.

There is an additional element that does not appear in the 8-K and is worth separating from the noise. Gemini has competed with Coinbase for the institutional custody business for years and has traded on Nasdaq since September 2025, so losing three mandates is financial news for the custodian as well as operational news for the fund. Neither VanEck nor Gemini explained the reasons for the split, and the fund did not detail how many assets must be physically moved either.

The timing, in the middle of Solana ETF season

The calendar is not neutral. Spot Solana ETFs have been building their market for months, and VSOL is one of the products competing for that flow. Changing custodian in a fund that is still seeking its investor base adds a variable issuers usually avoid, and the end of the staking annex hits precisely the selling point that differentiates a SOL ETF from a direct purchase.

In the ether fund, the change comes at a time of weak prices. Ether fell 8% on Friday the 20th and was trading around 1,620 dollars, with the crypto market digesting capital outflows from bitcoin ETFs and the prospect of a rate hike in December. A change of custodian does not move the price, but it adds questions in a week when the investor already had plenty.

The useful comparison is in the business surrounding the funds. Settlement and custody processes for tokenized securities are advancing on their own, with agreements such as the one that will bring DTCC's infrastructure to Solana in 2027, and the New York Stock Exchange's choice of Avalanche to settle tokenized shares shows that the debate over who safekeeps and who settles is moving on all fronts.

What remains to be known

Three questions remain without a public answer. The first is what proportion of HODL's bitcoin was at Gemini and how much must be physically moved, a figure the quarterly reports could clarify in February. The second is whether the Solana fund will keep staking with another provider or give up that source of yield. The third is whether the change of custodian alters fees, because a new contract can translate into a different cost that the prospectus does not yet reflect.

None of the three is an alarm. They are the questions an informed investor asks when a fund changes the piece that holds its assets, and the fact that the market is asking them now, three months in advance and without urgency, is a sign of maturity rather than crisis.

Custody has become the news

For years, the debate over crypto ETFs revolved around regulatory approval and volume. Now that the funds exist and move billions, the focus shifts to the plumbing: who custodies, who compensates and what happens if one of the two fails. The VanEck and Gemini case is small in dollars and big as a precedent, because it shows that sponsors are willing to change provider when the terms stop fitting.

The next chapter will be written in February, when the migration takes effect and the quarterly reports allow positions to be compared. Until then, the figure that sums up the situation is simple: three funds, one custodian that stays and one date on the calendar. In a market that lives on price headlines, the news is that the infrastructure is moving too.

For the retail investor, the practical consequence is that the prospectus is not enough: it is worth knowing who holds the keys and what exit clauses exist before the sponsor exercises them, because the notice arrives when the decision has already been made.

José Maldonado

Author

José Maldonado

Activist and blogger on technology, free software and blockchain.

The latest
Bitcoin loses $60,000 and IBIT suffers its largest withdrawal

Keep reading