# Lummis concedes: CLARITY lowers the cap to 50 million a year

> Lummis states that CLARITY lowers the fundraising cap to 50 million a year and 200 per issuer, a change the Senate text had already contained since June.
> By José Maldonado · Regulation & CBDC · 2026-10-27

A fundraising cap that Senator Cynthia Lummis presents as a concession to Democrats had been written for months in the text she herself was negotiating. On Sunday, October 25, the Wyoming Republican [posted](https://x.com/SenLummis/status/2114365112257564951) on her X account that the opposition had asked to lower the annual limit of Regulation Crypto from 75 to 50 million dollars and to add a lifetime cap of 200 million per issuer, that Republicans had accepted both, and that Democrats had voted against it anyway. Regulation Crypto is the exemption with which a token issuer could raise money from the public without registering the operation as a securities offering.

That change did not happen on Sunday. The substitute that the Senate Banking Committee reported on June 1 already sets the cap at 50 million a year for a maximum of four fiscal years, with 200 million accumulated per issuer, according to the [text of H.R. 3633](https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/3633/text), while the version approved by the House on July 17, 2025 spoke of 75 million for each twelve-month period. Lummis's post did not announce a new revision of the bill: it claimed credit for a concession that was already in it and blamed the opposition for the subsequent blockage.

What remains is a bill stalled for 41 days, with 49 votes in favor and 50 against on September 15, eleven short of the 60 the Senate requires to open debate, and a regulator moving ahead on its own with a proposal that keeps the 75 million. For anyone issuing or investing from Spain, the cut to CLARITY's 50 million a year is a second-tier figure: the useful question is not how much the cap was lowered, but which door remains open while Congress does not legislate.

## What did Lummis say and what had been in the bill for months?

The senator, who chairs the digital assets subcommittee of the banking committee, has posted a string of messages since October 23 in which she attributes a different demand to Democrats each day and responds that her party accepted it.

Sunday's focused on the caps in the section that creates Regulation Crypto, the registration exemption for offerings of investment contracts tied to what the text calls ancillary assets, that is, tokens of a network whose value still depends on the issuer's efforts.

![Senator Lummis's post on X](https://content.observatorioblockchain.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/cynthia-lummis-x.webp)
*Senator Lummis's post on X*

The bill adds disclosure thresholds: below 5 million in revenue or daily trading volume there is no obligation, between 5 and 25 million reviewed financial statements suffice, and above that figure an audit is required.

### A figure with great significance

The scope of the figure deserves nuance. The Senate text does not set a single cap of 50 million, but the greater of two numbers: those 50 million a year or 10% of the dollar value of ancillary assets in circulation, as set out in the [section-by-section breakdown](https://www.lummis.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/CLARITY-Act-Sec-by-Section-1.pdf) published by the senator herself.

That second branch is what decides in large networks. A project with 2 billion in tokens in circulation could raise up to 200 million a year without leaving the exemption, four times the figure Lummis presents as a concession wrung from the opposition.

The cap of 200 million accumulated per issuer is what really bounds the perimeter, and the text counts it as total gross revenue under the exemption, not as an annual average.

The detail matters. If the hard number is the accumulated one, arguing between a 75 and a 50 million annual cap changes little for a mid-sized issuer and nothing for a network with many tokens outstanding. Sunday's headline, CLARITY 50 million a year, describes the architecture the committee closed in June, not a last-minute shift.

## Three caps and no calendar

Today three versions of the same limit coexist, and none is in force. The Senate's is the only one written into a text that could be voted on; the House's stopped at its July 2025 approval; the SEC's is a proposal whose comment period closed on October 20 and which keeps the 75 million.

Rule or text

Annual cap

Accumulated cap

Status

CLARITY, Senate substitute

50 M$ a year, or 10% of ancillary assets in circulation if greater

200 M$ per issuer

Reported on June 1, no vote since September 15

CLARITY approved by the House

75 M$ for each 12 months

not stated in the legislative summary

Approved by 294 votes to 134

Regulation Crypto Assets (SEC)

75 M$ every 12 months

not stated in the proposal

Proposal, comments closed on October 20

The regulator's proposal, published on August 18 and named Regulation Crypto Assets, creates two exemptions (up to 5 million over four years and up to 75 million every twelve months) and a conditional safe harbor so that a token stops being considered an investment contract if it meets certain conditions, all within [file S7-2026-27](https://www.sec.gov/rules-regulations/2026/08/s7-2026-27). Its status remains that of a proposal, and the agency's own chairman, Paul Atkins, defended it as an exercise of existing authority while Congress was writing its law.

## The 49-50 that does not move

The September 15 vote was not about the caps. The Senate decided whether to open debate on H.R. 3633, a procedural step requiring 60 votes that ended at 49 in favor and 50 against, as recorded in the [bill's record](https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/3633): the 49 yeses were Republicans, the noes included four Republicans and two independents, and Chris Coons did not vote. Eleven votes of difference that no adjustment of figures can resolve.

The blockage has another name. Negotiations broke down over the ethics clause, with Democrats demanding an enforceable prohibition preventing the president, senior officials and their families from profiting from cryptoassets, and Republicans unwilling to accept the version they sought. None of Lummis's messages this week addresses that point, which is what keeps the text from being voted on.

Tillis filed a motion to reconsider the result, but there is no new vote on the calendar. As long as the Senate does not call one, the only practicable federal route for an issuer is the SEC's proposal. As we reported in [CLARITY fails and the US will regulate the crypto industry piece by piece](https://observatorioblockchain.com/en/regulation-cbdc/clarity-fracasa-y-eeuu-regulara-la-industria-cripto-por-piezas/), the real rulebook is already being written at the agencies.

## What changes for those issuing from Spain?

For a Spanish issuer, the 50 million cap is not the rule governing its activity. Anyone raising money in Spain does so under MiCA, which imposes its own disclosure and reserve obligations depending on the type of token, so CLARITY only comes into play if the round includes US investors.

That is where the real interest in the figure lies. An exemption of 50 or 75 million allows tokens to be sold to US retail investors without full registration, with reduced disclosure and with liability for fraud intact.

The Senate text adds that such offerings would be outside each state's securities registration, though it preserves state anti-fraud powers. It is the difference between an accessible market and a prospectus hundreds of pages long.

This should be read with the caution owed to what has not been approved. The exemption does not exist until the law exists, and the SEC's proposal is not a final rule either: comments closed on October 20 and the regulator can change it. An issuer planning a round for 2027 today depends on two open processes and no fixed calendar.

## A rulebook advancing without Congress

The episode leaves a law negotiated in public and not voted on, and a regulator writing rules in the meantime. The SEC keeps its proposal with the higher cap, the House had already approved its own by 294 votes to 134, and the Senate keeps looking at the ethics clause. Every week without a vote pushes the market's design toward the regulator and away from the legislative solution the sector has been requesting for two years.

The senator's own track record anticipated this scenario, since she had already warned that [CLARITY could be delayed until 2030](https://observatorioblockchain.com/en/regulation-cbdc/lummis-alerta-clarity-podria-aplazarse-2030/). If Sunday's exchange of messages shows anything, it is that concessions are announced faster than they are voted on: a cap of 50 million with 200 accumulated is a defensible figure for protecting retail investors, and also a headline that does not move a Senate that needs 60 votes and has 49.
