# AFME calls for tokenized securities to remain under MiFID and not MiCA

> AFME argued on September 30 in the MiCA review that tokenized securities should remain under MiFID. The EBA and ESMA call for that boundary to be clarified.
> By José Maldonado · Regulation & CBDC · 2026-10-16

One hundred and fifty global and European banks speak through a single association in Brussels. That voice asked on September 30 that no one move its boundary: tokenized financial instruments must remain under MiFID and the securities acquis, and not under the cryptoassets regulation merely for using a distributed ledger, according to the response of the Association for Financial Markets in Europe (AFME) to the European consultation on MiCA.

The underlying argument is technological neutrality. AFME maintains that the use of a distributed ledger should not change the classification of an instrument, and that the delimitation between the revised MiFID II and MiCA is sufficiently clear following ESMA's guidelines and the joint classification test by the European authorities. The response arrived on the day the consultation, opened on May 20, closed.

The responses feed the report the Commission must deliver before June 30, 2027 on the application of the regulation, which may be accompanied by a legislative proposal. Four other authorities have already set out their position in writing: the European Banking Authority, the markets authority ESMA, the anti-money laundering authority AMLA and the resolution board SRB. None disputes that tokenized securities belong to securities law, although several believe that boundary is not as clear as the banking sector claims.

## AFME's request

The document, prepared with the support of the law firm Clifford Chance, responds to the Commission's official questionnaire. To the first question, on whether cryptoassets that qualify as financial instruments should continue to be governed by sectoral legislation, AFME ticks yes.

To the second, on whether that distinction is clear enough, it also answers yes. Its justification is literal: "it is imperative that the use of DLT does not in itself bring about a change in the classification of an instrument."

The text adds that touching the perimeter would bring legal uncertainty and considerable costs, as well as consequences for the functioning of the market in terms of liquidity, risk hedging and collateral eligibility.

Its recipe involves supervisory guidelines and frequently asked questions for doubtful cases, and impact assessments prior to any decision. Pending improvements, it argues, should be channelled through the securities rules that already exist: MiFID II, MiFIR, the depositaries regulation and the DLT pilot regime. The press release sums up the package in four recommendations.

*   Keep tokenized financial instruments under MiFID and the rest of securities legislation, instead of MiCA.
*   Support global and multi-issuance stablecoin models with equivalence assessments and supervisory cooperation.
*   Create an optional pan-European regime, the so-called regime 28, with common rules on ownership, transfer, collateral and cross-border enforcement.
*   Confirm that tokenized deposits remain deposits under banking rules, and do not fall under MiCA for using DLT.

## Regulators' responses

The consultation was aimed at a specialized audience and not the general public, so the census of published responses is made up mainly of supervisors and industry associations. The dates order the debate and should be fixed before comparing positions.

The European Banking Authority went first on September 24. ESMA and AFME coincided on the 30th. AMLA published on October 7 a text dated September 30, and the resolution board did the same on October 8.

Authority

Date

Position on the perimeter

EBA

September 24

Outside MiCA and under MiFID, but the concept of financial instrument is not harmonized

ESMA

September 30

Alignment with MiFID II, binding classification opinions and derivatives settled in stablecoins under MiFID

AFME (industry)

September 30

The current boundary is clear and should not be moved; any change requires an impact assessment

AMLA

Dated September 30, published October 7

Extend the framework to staking, lending and borrowing, and define what a DeFi arrangement is

SRB

October 8

Resolution and crisis management of systemic stablecoins, and fit with the BRRD

None of those five responses changes an obligation today. They are contributions to a file that may end up in the application report and, if the Commission sees fit, in a legislative proposal.

The map has two well-separated halves. The prudential and markets supervisors discuss where the boundary should lie, while the anti-money laundering and resolution authorities discuss what to do with what falls outside it.

AMLA wants to regulate staking, lending and borrowing as activities with their own risks, and calls for a legal definition of a DeFi arrangement. The resolution board calls for bridges between MiCA and the bank resolution framework.

## The boundary the industry does not want moved

The perimeter is defined by an exclusion: MiCA does not apply to cryptoassets that qualify as financial instruments, because those remain under MiFID II and the rest of securities regulation. Deciding which side a token falls on is not a formality.

That choice determines the authorization a firm needs, the conduct and disclosure rules that apply, the eligibility of the asset as financial collateral and the capital calculation a bank must make for its exposure.

AFME acknowledges that difficult cases remain. Its response mentions assets marketed as NFTs but issued in large series, wrapped tokens, governance tokens with economic rights and synthetic exposures as the fronts where practice is evolving fastest.

It adds the boundary between asset-referenced tokens and money market funds, where tokenized products with a stable net asset value can behave like electronic money and even fall within the scope of the cryptoassets rule.

The point of friction is that the industry considers resolved a problem that supervisors see as open. AFME asserts that ESMA's guidelines and the common test have substantially reduced uncertainty. Supervisors respond that the instrument exists, but that its outcome depends on each national law.

## Supervisors share a destination and differ on method

The European Banking Authority reaches the same destination by another route. On the first question it chooses that cryptoassets that are financial instruments remain under sectoral legislation, but on the second it dissents: the distinction does not seem clear enough to it.

It asks the Commission to harmonize the definition of financial instrument "at the first legislative opportunity." Its reasoning is that the same token can be a financial instrument in one Member State and an asset-referenced token in another.

The banking supervisor adds two practical consequences that explain its haste. If a tokenized security ceased to be a financial instrument, the scope of existing authorizations would be in doubt and new regulated activities and new licences would be needed.

Eligibility as financial collateral would also wobble. The EBA recalls that the prudential treatment is already the same as that of a traditional asset, following the Basel Committee standard and Article 501d of the capital regulation.

### Different points of view

ESMA agrees on the direction and differs on the tool. Its September 30 response calls for better alignment between MiCA and MiFID II, and proposes that the European authorities' opinions on the classification of a token cease to be mere advice.

It also wants it written that settling a derivative with stablecoins does not prevent that derivative from being a financial instrument, and that an already authorized investment firm should not have to obtain an additional licence to offer transfers.

There is one area where the industry and the markets supervisor go hand in hand. Both AFME and ESMA back an optional European regime for DLT-based assets, a twenty-eighth framework that would coexist with national laws without replacing them.

ESMA frames it as a way to issue, transfer and settle tokenized securities with common rules. AFME wants it above all to resolve ownership, collateral and cross-border enforcement, and to prevent firms from accumulating licences for each country where they operate.

## Where does AFME not ask for fewer rules?

The document is not a deregulatory catalogue. AFME calls for introducing staking as a cryptoasset service with its own requirements, instead of leaving it incidentally covered by the custody authorization, and backs a proportionate framework for NFT service providers.

It also places prediction markets and perpetual futures on cryptoassets under MiFID, and not under MiCA, when they are contracts that already fit Annex I of the directive. It is the same logic, applied in the opposite direction.

That combination draws a narrower position than a quick reading suggests. The association accepts extending the perimeter when the activity has an identifiable intermediary to hold accountable, and rejects it when the extension is justified by the technical support of the asset.

The maxim the EBA invokes, same risk, same rule, is also the industry's axis: the same rule for the same business, applied to whoever provides it and not to the support where it is recorded. That nuance separates banking from supervisors less than it seems.

## The other track, the DLT pilot regime

Tokenized securities have had their own European testing ground since March 23, 2023. The DLT pilot regime allows financial instruments on a distributed ledger to be traded and settled with temporary exemptions from some traditional market rules.

It admits shares with a capitalization below 500 million euros, bonds of up to 1 billion and fund units with less than 500 million under management. Its uptake has been scarce due to restrictive thresholds and complex requirements.

The Union's economy ministers agreed on October 9 to multiply by fifty the ceiling for activity per infrastructure, from 6 billion euros to 300 billion. The measure seeks to relaunch a regime with little traction.

The text also allows reaching 500 billion through a delegated act, well above the 100 billion the Commission proposed. All those ceilings measure the same thing: how many securities can be housed under the temporary umbrella.

It adds a simplified regime for small operators with a ceiling of 10 billion euros and opens the door to new entities, including cryptoasset trading platforms. European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde objected to the maximum figure.

As we reported in [The EU proposes raising the limit for tokenized markets to 300 billion](https://observatorioblockchain.com/en/tokenization/ue-300000-millones-mercados-tokenizados/), the Council text is a negotiating position and not law in force. The Parliament must still set its own, so the figure may move.

The sequence fits what the banking sector is asking for. While AFME demands that tokenized securities not leave securities law, the Council expands the securities infrastructure designed to host them. Neither of the two movements decides which side of the boundary a specific token falls on
